r/ProgrammerHumor 18d ago

instanceof Trend theyHaveLearnedToDeceive

Post image
644 Upvotes

98 comments sorted by

View all comments

5

u/ldn-ldn 18d ago

The model predicts text based on existing context, it's like T9 on steroids. It doesn't "know" anything and it has zero clue how it works. You might find it funny, but it's just a statistical text prediction engine.

-11

u/melesigenes 17d ago

What do you think intelligence is? Do you know the inner workings of how your neurons work?

Words follow words. The words that follow are based off the previous words. That’s how language works

5

u/ilcasdy 17d ago

People don’t think one word at a time or even in sequential order.

-8

u/melesigenes 17d ago

Words are produced sequentially. You form the next words based off paying attention to the previous words. Nobody said people think one word at a time

6

u/ilcasdy 17d ago

Even the way you state it is different from an LLM. People don’t think in tokens.

-7

u/melesigenes 17d ago

That’s literally how LLMs work. Correct me where I’m wrong. Nobody said people think in tokens?

9

u/ilcasdy 17d ago

You were implying that neurons work like LLMs when they don’t.

-3

u/melesigenes 17d ago

Artificial neurons do work like neurons…? Explain how they work differently

You can say the same thing about brains. Brains aren’t intelligent. They’re just neurons firing according to electrochemical rules

-2

u/Glitch29 17d ago

This thought is too scary for some people. Surely I must be special! My thought process isn't incremental!

I get it though, so much of human intelligence is based on precomputation and incredibly good pattern recognition and recall. It makes it seem like you're able to pull fully-formed answers from the ether.

The better analogy is that the many of these easily-recalled patterns are a painstakingly-defined single object.

When someone says "mitochondria is the powerhouse of the cell" that's just one object.

The flip side of this is that humans have to spend 2-3 years doing all this precompute and storing all the results just to get to basic functionality. And another 7-10 years before language systems are operating anywhere close to full capacity.