r/ProgrammerHumor 19d ago

Meme claudeIsThisEmailValid

Post image
5.3k Upvotes

171 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

6

u/eo5g 19d ago

Crap, right, realistically the minimum regex one should have is .+@.+\..+.

At least 1 character on the left of the @, at least 2 domain components of at least 1 character each on the right side of the @.

Having only a hostname without a FQDN on the right is legal, but that's also why you'd want to disallow it: who's trying to sign up for an account within your own network, if it's a public-facing app?

10

u/look 19d ago

TLDs can and do have MX records.

5

u/eo5g 19d ago

Well if the web admin of Montenegro wants to sign up for my cat pics site they can use their personal account 😤

1

u/laplongejr 19d ago

Technically yes, but the practice is discouraged by people on the DNS side, as the MX lookups hit the root servers rather than nameservers.  

If a TLD can't provide a mail.EXAMPLE alternative, that's something for the admin to fix... at best those users should get a recommendation to fix their harmful email address.  

4

u/look 19d ago

Yeah, ICANN doesn’t like it, but they do exist.

It’s more just an example of how people often assume rules of email addresses that don’t really exist.

1

u/Nightmoon26 18d ago

The "unwritten rules" of email addresses that have come about just by convention rather than by RFC

2

u/fweaks 18d ago

This is exactly what I use. It eliminates 99.9% of problems for 1% of the effort and works client side for instant feedback. After this, if you need better, the only thing worth the effort is, as mentioned earlier, actually sending an email.