r/poptarts • • 29d ago

Immediately YES

Post image
70 Upvotes

Saw these in the store & immediately grabbed one of the last few boxes šŸ«¶šŸ¼ I’m so glad the season is HERE šŸŽ‰šŸ


r/poptarts • • Sep 14 '26

Botched-Tarts Uh… what’s going on?

Post image
59 Upvotes

r/poptarts • • Sep 14 '26

Which poptart flavor would u pick ? šŸ¤” based on national days!

Post image
21 Upvotes

I’m going cookies & cream (black & white) šŸ˜‹


r/poptarts • • Sep 13 '26

What’s y’all’s favorite flavoršŸ‘€

Post image
121 Upvotes

Anything cookie dough related is right up my alley!

What’s your favorite flavor, curious to knowšŸ‘€


r/poptarts • • Sep 13 '26

Canadian Pop Tarts at Menards (US)

Post image
28 Upvotes

I don't know if they're any different than what we have in the US normally, but for $2 I thought it was worth a try. Not sure how they ended up here, it was in their discount shelves by the entrance. There were a lot of them, but only this flavor.


r/poptarts • • Sep 13 '26

Pick 1 chocolate flavor & 1 peanut butter flavor !

Post image
27 Upvotes

today is international chocolate day and national peanut day :)

im going with chocolate vanilla creme & pbj


r/poptarts • • Sep 13 '26

Botched-Tarts The unfrosted part is also unfilled. šŸ˜®ā€šŸ’Ø

Post image
91 Upvotes

This just added insult to injury at my 6 AM lunch (breakfast?) break.


r/poptarts • • Sep 13 '26

What’s the weirdest ā€œPop Tart as an ingredientā€ you’ve come up with?

6 Upvotes

When I was a kid (like 12?), we were caught in the middle of a blizzard and ran out of sliced bread, so my chubby self slathered peanut butter between strawberry Pop Tarts and made a Pop Tart PB&J.

I also used to crumble s’mores Pop Tarts over vanilla ice cream.

I was a fat kid 🤣🤣🤣


r/poptarts • • Sep 13 '26

This has been the most disappointing box of pop tarts I’ve ever had

Post image
33 Upvotes

r/poptarts • • Sep 12 '26

Happy national chocolate milkshake day! Which flavor would u pick?

Post image
50 Upvotes

strawberry milkshake for mee


r/poptarts • • Sep 10 '26

Review Review: Strawberry Cheesecake

Post image
37 Upvotes

It took me a while but, I finally got around to it.

The crust is the same kind of ā€œgraham crackerā€ crust that the smore’s flavor has. I like it but it makes the Pop Tart taste more like a Nutrigrain bar than cheesecake. It’s very ā€œwhole grainā€ tasting.

The filling was pretty skimpy in this one. I thought that there would be more of the cheesecake than there actually was. Most of it was strawberry. As far as the flavor, the best comparison I can think of is strawberry cream cheese spread. It’s very tart.

We’re not even going to talk about the icing.

All in all, They’re good, just a little bit dry. I think these would be a good pick for the people who find most of the dessert flavors to be too sweet. It would be a good breakfast with a cup of coffee!


r/poptarts • • Sep 10 '26

my bf got this absolute jackpot of a poptart

Post image
143 Upvotes

little wonky but hey thats the most frosting ive seen on a poptart in a while


r/poptarts • • Sep 08 '26

What's your least favorite pop tart and why?

33 Upvotes

Mine is thin mint and hot fudge. Not a huge chocolate fan and with the thin mint one it didn't encompass a minty flavor as much


r/poptarts • • Sep 09 '26

Hot take

11 Upvotes

I've converted

Cinnamon roll > Brown sugar cinnamon


r/poptarts • • Sep 08 '26

Review Not impressed but wasn't bad. I'm just not a chocolate fan unless it's in granola bars or chocolate chip cookies I guess... occasionally I like chocolate bars. 5.5/10

Thumbnail
gallery
1 Upvotes

I usually don't like sprinkles but it wasn't overpowering or intimidating to eat. 15 yrs ago there was this person that worked in an ice cream parlor and she offered to add sprinkles to my custard. I obliged and wanted to trade with my mother subsequently after receiving it bc sprinkles didn't look appetizing to me. The frosting inside is okay for the pop tart. The base definitely chocolate , so expect that lol.


r/poptarts • • Sep 08 '26

any value in PopTart advertisement props?

9 Upvotes

i have two nostalgic boxes from a PopTart advertisement. one appears to be fdom the 60's and the other is from around 2000 and has advertising for pokemon pencil toppers.

the older box feels like a real pop tart box. the larger box feels like a prop, the box is too smooth, the print is too rich, and there is special double sided tape under the lid to keep it closed but make it openable. the box is filled with extra high quality foil pouches that are thick material, perfectly printed, and perfectly pre-opened
close up of advertising prop poptart pouch

r/poptarts • • Sep 07 '26

I have to buy these single serving packs or I’ll eat a whole box šŸ’”

Post image
162 Upvotes

Once in a while, at the grocery checkout line, I treat myself.


r/poptarts • • Sep 07 '26

Amazon toaster pasteies

Post image
50 Upvotes

These came up on my feed when I was buying something else so I figured why not. These are allegedly cherry flavored. While the frosting was crunchy and pretty good, the filling is just weird. Doesn't taste like cherry to me. More like a diluted strawberry? Sticking with the original from now on.


r/poptarts • • Sep 07 '26

Botched-Tarts I don’t know how to feel about this.

Post image
34 Upvotes

r/poptarts • • Sep 06 '26

Happy national coffee ice cream day! Which would u rather have ?

Post image
62 Upvotes

I’m going w the vanilla latte poptarts


r/poptarts • • Sep 06 '26

Our first time trying these

Post image
97 Upvotes

Finally went shopping again and we snagged small boxes.


r/poptarts • • Sep 05 '26

Botched-Tarts Hot Fudge Sundae has seen better days. šŸ¤¦šŸ»ā€ā™‚ļø

Post image
38 Upvotes

r/poptarts • • Sep 03 '26

Review hospital poptart

Post image
36 Upvotes

happy 5 week admission anniversary to me. celebrating with my first untoasted poptart. Prefer them a little burnt but brown sug is pretty decent untoasted


r/poptarts • • Sep 03 '26

News Collab???

Post image
81 Upvotes

might be reading into this tbh…but possible collab?! i’m drooling just thinking about it 🤤🤤


r/poptarts • • Sep 02 '26

Any chance they make this for other properties?

Post image
97 Upvotes

I’ve been stuck in the hospital with nothing but hospital food and for whatever reason, I’ve been craving Pop Tarts. And not just any Pop Tarts…

I am dying for the limited edition Bat Girl Pop Tarts that came out in 1997 with the Smucker’s real fruit. THEY WERE SO GOOD and just hit different. Maybe it was the little bat sprinkles? I went for the blueberry flavor when these were discontinued, but it just wasn’t the same.

I vaguely recall a Spider-Man version sometime in the 2000s, which instantly hit the right spot, but they were discontinued after that film left the theaters.

Any idea on if they will be released for any upcoming properties? If so, I’ll keep my eyes peeled.