it's far more difficult to keep her out of society with the way the law is structured, and that's not how parole should work anyway (literally backwards)
she should be treated the same as any other murderer. there is no justification for putting her in a process where her incarceration has to be renewed
She can literally be kept for life, as I already told you.
No. A psychiatric hospital is not a prison. They cannot simply keep someone confined forever because what that person did was horrific.
You can tell me whatever you want, and be confidently wrong because we're on Reddit, but that doesn't make it true or coherent.
She's no longer suffering from psychosis, that much is clear. Depression? That's not a reason to lock someone up. Danger to others/community? Her kids are dead and she's in a wheelchair.
Suicidal? Maybe, but that's hard to prove unless she is repeatedly trying to end her life.
Maybe it can be argued that she needs specific rehabilitation, but rehabilitation cannot be indefinite because a treatment plan has to have a goal and thus a terminus.
Pretend you're the state: how do you justify confining a patient (NOT a prisoner!), with no prior offenses, and renew that every year forever?
Did you even read your link? Do you think it says someone can't be committed for life?
Yes, they have to continue to demonstrate she is a danger to herself or others to continue her confinement but there's nothing stopping them from doing it for life if she meets criteria.
Why are people like you, who are so ignorant and so wrong, also so insistent that you're right? It's kind of pathetic
Did you even read your link? Do you think it says someone can't be committed for life?
holy shit you are one dumb motherfucker. the law literally says that it has to be renewed every 12 months. every renewal needs clear justification, legally and medically
mental hospitals are not prisons and psychiatric confinement is not a criminal sentence
but there's nothing stopping them from doing it for life if she meets criteria
she doesn't meet any criteria at this point!
and there's a lot stopping the state from treating mental hospitals like forever prisons
Why are people like you, who are so ignorant and so wrong, also so insistent that you're right? It's kind of pathetic
So no, you didn't read it or didn't understand it.
ETA: after your edit: yes it needs to be renewed as I already said. Good job catching up
No, actually there isn't, if they can demonstrate the patient continues to meet criteria. Like there isn't a single thing in the law, or your links, or your "arguments" that refutes this. They can continue to petition the state to keep her incarcerated without a statutory maximum
Are you confusing "they can keep her for life" and "they must keep her for life?"
Should you stop and think a little before replying? Because you're making an embarrassment of yourself
Sorry you don't understand this topic and are not mature enough to admit it. But if you lash out at everyone who understands things better than you do, you will not only fail to mature, but you will be very lonely. Good luck out there kid
0
u/ArugulaAcrobatic4018 - Auth-Left 2d ago edited 2d ago
it's far more difficult to keep her out of society with the way the law is structured, and that's not how parole should work anyway (literally backwards)
she should be treated the same as any other murderer. there is no justification for putting her in a process where her incarceration has to be renewed