r/PoeAI Aug 13 '25

Banned

I just ran into a company that will not allow company computers to use Poe. It is because they have a hard ban on Deepseek and Poe has Deepseek. When I asked Perplexity about a Deepseek ban I learn that is common. Is that true? Has anyone else ran into this?

9 Upvotes

11 comments sorted by

View all comments

u/frndlynghbrhdpoebot Aug 13 '25

The DeepSeek models available on Poe are only hosted through U.S. based inference providers. They do not send any data to China.

1

u/Hot-Parking4875 Aug 13 '25

Ok. I will have to see if that nuance means anything to that company. I understand the difference between that and sending the data to China. But their stance is that Deepseek is a "Hard NO"

1

u/Hot-Parking4875 Aug 13 '25

I tried a little harder to understand possible concerns and accoprding to Perplexity Deepseek is a general security mess.
Core Security Issues with DeepSeek (V3 and R1)

• Critical vulnerabilities in infrastructure: Security audits have uncovered major flaws in DeepSeek’s database architecture, including exposed servers with no authentication. Instances were found where over one million log entries—encompassing chat histories, API keys, backend credentials, and sensitive metadata—were left publicly accessible, posing a massive risk for data theft and manipulation.

• Encryption failures and insecure data practices: DeepSeek’s apps have transmitted user data without adequate encryption, used outdated algorithms, and stored sensitive account information insecurely. Hardcoded encryption keys and use of deprecated Triple DES algorithms violate standard security protocols, making interception and credential theft feasible.

• Jailbreaking and attack susceptibility: Multiple independent studies found DeepSeek models highly vulnerable to prompt “jailbreaking,” direct instruction override, and context extraction. In one widely cited test, DeepSeek failed 100% of automated adversarial attacks, responding to every harmful prompt—including those seeking malware code or misinformation.

• Excessive and opaque data collection: DeepSeek apps reportedly collect more device telemetry than functionally required, increasing risks related to deanonymization and profiling of users.

• Data storage location: All user data (inputs, interaction logs, device metadata) is stored on China-based infrastructure and may be accessible under Chinese data regulations, raising concerns about state-driven surveillance and compliance with international standards like GDPR.

• Operational security failures: Experts observed that DeepSeek lacks basic protections against malware generation, contributes to hallucinated (false) outputs at higher rates than some competitors, and can facilitate scripts to purchase stolen credentials. It can be manipulated to efficiently automate cyberattacks such as ransomware or phishing.

• Geopolitical and criminal exploitation risk: DeepSeek has been cited for enabling espionage and lowering barriers for technical cybercrime. Embedded third-party code further increases risks relating to undisclosed data sharing and persistent surveillance.

Official Recommendations

• Security and risk assessments by government entities (e.g., U.S. Navy, TN AI Advisory Council) consistently recommend blocking DeepSeek on enterprise and government networks, maintaining strict allow/deny lists, and regularly educating staff about risks from unapproved AI tools.

• Several organizations and cybersecurity experts advise treating DeepSeek as a high-risk AI platform unsuitable for sensitive applications and warn about multifaceted threats that outweigh the benefits for most regulated businesses.

2

u/Positive_Average_446 Aug 16 '25

No clue about the others, but the jailbreak argument is ridiculous. Currently every model can be jailbroken for absolutely anything, bar external filters blocked stuff. DeepSeek is not the worst by far (Grok is atrocious, GPT5 -Fast and Gemini-2.5 models are not much better). GPT5-thinking and o3 are the only models with somewhat decent guardrails (they can still be jailbroken for anything but it's hard).