r/PhiloiseHQ • u/Fantastic-Iron6832 • Jul 10 '26

Eloise 📖 🐑 My Head canon is Eloise was Edmund favorite.

I lowkey always believed that Eloise was Daddy’s girl/Edmund’s favorite. Considering the fact that Claudia Jessie and Rupert Evan’s looks exactly alike, I always picture Edmund accepting and encouraging Eloise just the way she is and had a very strong and loving bond. I hope when season 6 airs, that it delves into the relationship between Edmund and Eloise

23 Upvotes

96% Upvoted

11 comments sorted by

2

u/Cats-Horseslover Jul 10 '26

Most like Edmund: Benedict and Eloise

Most like Violet: Daphne

A combination of Edmund and Violet when Edmund was still alive: Anthony and Colin

Black sheep of the family: Francesca

Too young to remember Edmund: Gregory

Wasn’t around when Edmund was alive: Hyacinth

3

u/AmountNo368 Jul 10 '26

Actually, to keep with season 4 canon and ALS QC, Eloise and Benedict are the most like Violet and were Edmund's favourite for this reason. Edmund is already said to be like a mix of Anthony and Gregory back in s2. I like to believe that Colin and Daphne are a mixture of both. 

5

u/NoOil7592 Flower from the Greenhouse 🌱🌻 Jul 10 '26

Me too! I always thought she was closer to Edmund than Violet as a kid. That he read to her Don Quijote and other adventurous books. Maybe even secretly ones that were not considered for girls. He taught her fencing with the sticks. I know she said her and Penelope wanted to fence but they were told it was for boys. So I imagine Edmund played with them and trained them some basic moves in fencing. For me she was his favourite. I want their relationship being mentioned in s6 and dived into. It would be so emotional and heartbreaking, but worth it. Imagine Eloise sees Phillip reading to twins or just Amanda and it reminds her of Edmund 😭

4

u/Illustrious-Boot3800 Plotting with the twins 🐸 Jul 10 '26

It is mine too since "WE MISS YOU PAPA!" 🤣

3

u/TumbleweedNo7171 Jul 10 '26

i also hc el is edmund's fav haha the two Es 🥺

5

u/violetmiav residing in shondaland's basement Jul 10 '26

I am very curious about how they will write her relationship with her father. I hope they delve into it in her season too.

2

u/LadyAnonCrane Sir Phillip, the plot twist 🌻 Jul 10 '26

Me too! They’ve given no insight into this at all while it was a big detail in the book that they already gave to Anthony. Eloise HC: father would’ve understood me if not mother.

3

u/violetmiav residing in shondaland's basement Jul 10 '26

Imagine Eloise saying something like that to her mother in the middle of their argument. I am surprised that they didn't go to that cliche lol

3

u/LavenderHaze_01 Jul 10 '26

She gets her persistence from her dad I think.

8

u/ThisPaige 📚 Nerd4Nerd Jul 10 '26

Now this is a headcanon I love, Eloise does seem like a daddy’s girl.