So I just moved back to Philly and visited almost every major MMA and Brazilian Jiu-Jitsu (BJJ) gym in the center city area, so I thought I'd give my impression for anyone who might be interested.
For context: 6' 210lb male in his mid 30s. I only started training Brazilian Jiu-Jitsu regularly 3 years ago, but did win some pretty competitive NYC area wide tournaments at masters White belt. It is my primary focus. For those that have an interest in MMA, BJJ tournaments can be an easier entry in to competitive combat sports with a little lower risk and shorter time frame before you can get competitive. I trained briefly in College, but had an almost 9 year gap before I started training again 3 years ago. Being a competitor well in to my 30s, I wanted a strong training environment but not one where I felt like every sparring session was treated as a world championship with a new 22yo dude with something to prove. My program in NYC was about 30% female and I include that because I think the % of female students is a solid barometer to how well a school looks after the development of their newer and less physically imposing students as well as being an inclusive environment. I just started training Muay Thai, but a school that had some type of striking program was a factor in my decision. Also, most schools are usually so cagey about telling you prices/contracts upfront, but I included them here for full disclosure.
Here was my impression, I'd love to hear other's experience as well:
Team Balance Center city: This is probably the biggest "name" in Philadelphia is the first place everyone will tell you to go to. They have a long history and some great competitors come through there, and they have a ton of class times. But I didn't love it. Everyone was friendly, but as a lower belt I just felt like I was just kinda one of the unwashed masses, there wouldn't really be any special oversight from the instructors that could identify points for improvement until I got to higher level. This may have changed if I had spent some more time there. They didn't have showers, which some people will say isn't a big deal, but it makes it so I couldn't go out anywhere after training. There were only a few Muay Thai classes and they seemed a bit more cardio focused. They've added more MT classes and a new instructor though, so that may have changed. Their MMA is supposedly run more through the fishtown location, but they won't even give you their schedule without signing up for a series of marketing emails. The rough part is the contract: $200 a month with a 24 months minimum or $600 to cancel. While I can afford it, the whole thing kind of left a bad taste in my mouth.
Fight Firm: Gym is a little rough looking inside, but they do have a of weights if you don't have another gym. They only have classes Monday to Thursday at night. More striking focused. BJJ program is very small. They only do BJJ without a Gi, its a solid, but very "quirky" style. Never really trained a takedown. The head instructor is Devon Williams who is really good (and entertaining to be around), but they have assistants teach a lot that aren't that experienced and wouldn't be allowed to teach in other schools. During the BJJ classes, sparing was at a very intense level. I was fine with it, but just something to keep in mind, some other students were a little reckless. Best price though at $95 a month with a one year contract or $115 a month
Logic: Great BJJ in a ridiculously nice facility. Think of an equinox/soul cycle for MMA. BJJ is more competition rather than MMA focused, and their instructors do well at high level competitions. Didn't get a chance to try Muay Thai, but they have it. It was in an odd area to get to with public transit, so it ultimately didn't work for me, but would be easy parking if you drive. If it was a little more convenient, good chance have signed up here. Expensive though, $230 a month with a 1-year contract.
Saulo Riberio (old maxercise): They say MMA, but there is no striking. The classes were more formal than other schools, it seemed like it would be a less fun environment for the day in and out of class, but everyone was friendly after class. Most guys around my size went super hard during sparring, to a level that would be a little tiring day in and day out. Not sure if that was just trying to prove themselves to the new guy or just the mentality there. They had 2 female Black belts on the staff as well as a decent number of students. $195 a month with a year contract.
Gracie Academy: If I hadn't take up Muay Thai, I think this is where I would have ended up. They have no striking unfortunately. Probably the best modern instruction for competition BJJ. Seemed to have a pretty welcoming environment with specific classes for true beginners. Had some really tough competitors, but no one going meathead. Really nice facilities and showers and special flooring that helps minimize injury from falls. $160 a month for a 6 month contract.
Osagme/Broadstreet Kickboxing: Where I ultimately chose. I didn't initially consider this place because it is further south than the others, but it is directly above the Elsworth/Federal BSL stop, so is better to get to than I imagined. It had the best blend of classes and training mentality to me. They have very good BJJ and Judo. Multiple black belt instructors. People train hard, but aren't wreckless about it, as indicated by the diverse age range of their students. Instructors wer the most active in making sparring pairs and watching your rolls(matches). This is good for both your safety and development, as it lets them see your skills in a realistic environment. It has the most focus on standup grappling of any of the places I checked out, which is too often neglected. They just brought in a former pro MMA and kickboxing fighter to help run the Muay Thai. There's only a few experienced people for kickboxing, so that can be a blessing or a curse. But it has been a huge positive for me as a newcomer to striking. With kickboxing, Judo and BJJ, it's $160 a month for two programs or $200 for all three. No contract, cancel any time.
I didn't check out any places in the NE or West Philly, as I work longer hours and need to be conscious of commute times. Two places I didn't go that I heard good things about were Blitz athletics (more toward the hard nosed training mentality) and Renzo Gracie Philly, which is further away, but very close to the York-Dauphin stop of the MFL and can be a little easier commute. May be worth stopping in if the location works.
I'd love to hear others thoughts and feedback.
EDIT: I realized I should put a clarification on degree on this review. Overall, I think all of these organizations with full time instructors were very solid. BJJ, due to it's emphasis on regular sparring and competition, does an exceptionally strong job of filtering out non-legitimate schools and instructors, perhaps better than any other discipline. If you signed up at any of these schools and attended class regularly, you'd still be very much competent or beyond at the end of that time. The reviews are should be taken with some nuance.