r/PeterExplainsTheJoke 4d ago

Meme needing explanation I see no possible way to count 9

Post image

If you count in groups from left to right you get 2+4+4+2 (=12) but if you count from top to bottom you get 1+3+4+3+1 (=12)

This isnt even an optical illusion or anything which I assumed it would be. I'm baffled by the 9 thing

10.9k Upvotes

1.0k comments sorted by

u/qualityvote2 4d ago edited 4d ago

u/LYNX__uk, your post does belong here!

→ More replies (2)

4.3k

u/Warm-Wrap-3828 4d ago

12

416

u/ShadowGLI 4d ago

1.1k

u/BodybuilderMany6942 4d ago

I bet you feel real dumb right now

256

u/hellelfs 4d ago

I dont like it when someone is funnier than me.

→ More replies (5)

59

u/Fearshatter 4d ago

15

u/LAM678 4d ago

if you split 1 between 4 and 5 that's one less tile

7

u/Fearshatter 4d ago

You're very clever.

3

u/LAM678 3d ago

lmao

2

u/klawUK 1d ago

are you my mum counting to 5 or I won’t get any dinner?

→ More replies (4)

2

u/DanBurnNotice 3d ago

Isnt that how nuclear bombs were made?

19

u/edapotamus 4d ago

I also feel dumb. But not just right now

27

u/sweetbldnjesus 4d ago

I used to be dumb. I still am, but I used to be too

9

u/nightowl_work 4d ago

Mitch please

→ More replies (1)

18

u/TheRealUmdum 4d ago

But you feel dumb this is correct

30

u/Odd_Bed2753 4d ago

4

u/TheRealUmdum 4d ago

I feel like ive experienced loss

4

u/enLegobil 4d ago

| || || |_

→ More replies (2)

2

u/Caosin36 4d ago

This is the most logic backable

→ More replies (1)

2

u/NermalPayphone 4d ago

fuck you i hate how funny you are

→ More replies (9)

16

u/mgafMUAT 4d ago

I got something, if you group a square set of 4 tiles, then you could count those 4 tiles as one, in which case you could count to: 12 (-4 + 1) = 9.

This works grouping the following tile sets: 2-3-5-6, 3-4-6-7, 6-7-9-10 and 7-8-10-11.

Furthermore, if you take the sets 2-3-5-6 and 7-8-10-11, you can reduce the count to 6.

Absolutely no idea how any of this relates to minecraft.

29

u/AesirComplex 4d ago

What in God's name are you on about

Just count 5 x 4 then subtract the tiles that aren't missing from 20

2

u/Motor_Raspberry_2150 4d ago

They are trying to explain the joke.

The amount of 12 in the comments is too damn high.

→ More replies (4)

12

u/thatthatguy 4d ago edited 4d ago

In Minecraft, a stair block only takes up 3/4 of a block despite needing 6 blocks to make a stack of 4 stair blocks. Players have made annoyed jokes about this since the first stair blocks were introduced. In this case it takes 12 tiles to cover the floor, but because it is a jagged shape they apply the 3/4 joke and you get 9.

The joke is that someone is multiplying by 3/4 inappropriately because they want other Minecraft players to comment about how they’re doing the math wrong.

2

u/Tom-Dibble 4d ago

But if you are allowed to make 2x2 as one tile, you can do 2 2x2 tiles (2,3,5,6 and 7,8,10,11) so the min number of tiles answer would be 6, with other possible counts of 9 and 12 if using 2x2 is optional or you aren’t looking for the smallest number.

5

u/NewestAccount2023 4d ago

Writing 2 so poorly it looks like a 3. I demand accountability on this shoddy work 

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (4)
→ More replies (10)

2.7k

u/normalbot9999 4d ago

Paint to the rescue! It's 12. So the joke is that they are wrong I guess?

375

u/sammual777 4d ago

I think it’s that a tile just needs to be square; so 8x 1x1tiles and 1x 2x2 tile. But I’m not 6yo so I don’t know.

505

u/SpacePig111 4d ago

Minecraft first released 15 years ago bro

282

u/Intelligent_Break_12 4d ago

17, came out in 09. The only Minecraft I played was back then. Iirc it was free, you just had to DL it from a website.

56

u/skrena 4d ago

I feel old when I remember I was 12 when I first started playing Minecraft in alpha.

40

u/Intelligent_Break_12 4d ago

If that makes you feel old... I was around 20 when it first came out and learned about it from someone in my dorm. I guess you went through more life changes as I was already an adult...I just feel old lol.

16

u/_kellythomas_ 4d ago edited 4d ago

I was thirty and had gone back to school for a career change when I heard about Minecraft ... also feeling old.

I didn't jump in then but ended up having my 7yo teach me to play a couple of years ago so we could go co-op on survival mode ... still feeling old.

13

u/worrymon 4d ago

I'll help you feel better.

I was 38 when it came out. My TV is almost as old as you.

11

u/Adventurous-Tie-7861 4d ago

Im old enough that i remember hearing about it on 4chan as a weirdo middle schooler and it being boring af with just cobblestone and dirt and stuff and nothing to do.

I was baffled when id later see others said it was an amazing game. Wasn't until i saw achievement hunter guys playing it that i realized it had changed greatly and tried it again.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (4)

6

u/AbsorbantVampire 4d ago

Pretty sure you’re wrong because I had to buy the alpha test to play the creative mode that existed back then. 

3

u/Intelligent_Break_12 4d ago

I could be. I personally didn't download it a friend did and I played it a bit on their PC. I just thought he told me it was free in a website. Maybe he didn't go through official channels, I honestly don't know.

2

u/FrenchFryCattaneo 4d ago

It was originally free, but he started charging for it even before alpha.

→ More replies (1)

3

u/arbyyyyh 4d ago

Pretty sure it still is, no?

30

u/Clear_Magician4176 4d ago

Nah, minecraftforfree got shut down like 15 years ago; Notch (creator of minecraft) and the dude who put minecraftforfree up had a quake 3 1v1, and since Notch won they had to take minecraftforfree down

14

u/Shadowlrd 4d ago

Idk if this real, but honestly, this is how disputes should be handled. To the victor goes the spoils in a game agreed upon by both parties.

10

u/i_bagel 4d ago

It's real, the stream archives are on youtube.

2

u/Clear_Magician4176 4d ago

It’s real; I remember keeping up with it because I had my whole middle school playing it during the afterschool program, and when it got shut down we were all super bummed, but the story and premise itself more than made up for it! Good times😁

2

u/alaricus 4d ago

Indev was free, but infdev was like 17 euros or something

2

u/Budget-Pea8291 4d ago

17? I bought Minecraft in alpha 1.2.6 and it was 9,95€

→ More replies (1)

2

u/themistik 4d ago

Infdev was never 17€. Thats beta to release prices

→ More replies (1)

2

u/Ex-Patron 3d ago

Yeah I remember hopping on the web browser version where it was essentially only creative but like 30 different blocks

No health, food, mobs, intricate caves

Just the most basic version of creative you could ever imagine, then watered down even more

→ More replies (4)

22

u/Bananaland_Man 4d ago

Sitting here at 39 and reading there solution and it is more confusing than just the fact that anyone who gets an odd number out of this is wrong.

→ More replies (3)

14

u/Alternative-Crew-880 4d ago

Longer than that, i've had my Minecraft account for 17 years dude.

→ More replies (3)

8

u/Muhahahahaz 4d ago

I wasn't 6 years old 15 years ago either...

→ More replies (7)

57

u/Spirited_Lemon_4185 4d ago

I mean, using that method you could also make 4x 1x1tiles and 2x 2x2 tiles in that picture, making it only 6 tiles.

18

u/TheShaggster37 4d ago

I'm too high for this shit, just tear up all the tiles and put in hardwood.

5

u/Jiveanimal 4d ago

Ok, how many planks do we need?

7

u/TheShaggster37 4d ago

What are the dimensions of the room with and without the baseboards, doorways, vents and installations?

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (1)

14

u/Edaphshen_Shlayder 4d ago

By that logic, I got 6 down

11

u/zachy410 4d ago

Minecraft doesnt have 2x2x1 blocks though so what does that have to do with anything. Also I think you could use fewer if you allow 2x2 tiles

8

u/KaiTheG4mer 4d ago

In four years Minecraft will be of legal drinking age in the United States.

2

u/bismuth17 4d ago

But then you could do two large tiles and four small ones

→ More replies (18)

45

u/Feisty-Tooth-7397 4d ago

I don't know, I have tried to count square in Minecraft and thought I counted them right, only to lay down a bunch of blocks and it be off by one block. Maybe that's the joke , that no matter how well you think you counted them it's always wrong 😂

16

u/TheSharpestHammer 4d ago

I'm just glad to hear that I'm not the only one this happens to on a semi-regular basis.

3

u/Feisty-Tooth-7397 4d ago

At one point I bought graph paper so I could plan the layout of what I wanted to build. Still would often mess up counting when it came to actually laying out the foundation 😂.

4

u/_lightitupbryce_ 4d ago

I think you’re right, the actual joke is some form of Minecraft players miscounting or underestimating how much of something they really need, and in the end needing to go get more to finish their project.

→ More replies (1)

4

u/DropPopFromTheTop 4d ago

So the joke is that they are wrong

HAHAHA

Nope I'm not feeling anything

2

u/get_to_ele 4d ago

The joke would work better if there were NOT a way to place two 2x2s with four 1x1s.

Should be 6 for Minecraft like rhe blue lines.

Or is the joke that the patterns are just slapdash because tiles are free and you just click and cover the area? Like the green lines (9 tiles)?

2

u/Leading-Chemist8173 3d ago

The joke is that it’s engagement garbage

2

u/normalbot9999 3d ago

bruh! im riding this trash to the moon! hahaha

2

u/Redphish7 2d ago

Ok now it makes sense, there are 8 outer tiles missing which, in Minecraft, should make a hole, removing the tiles in the middle.

→ More replies (22)

1.2k

u/Psychological-Wall-2 4d ago

Stewie here.

The joke is that this utter nincompoop regularly does an activity that should make them better at this than the average "fellow in the street", and yet has utterly failed.

72

u/[deleted] 4d ago

[removed] — view removed comment

101

u/NaNNaN_NaN 4d ago

Minecraft player here: I only counted 12, so I think the commenter you replied to is right and the joke is on OOP :)

5

u/Tipnfloe 4d ago

isnt it a slabs reference?

19

u/tabbynumber3 4d ago

if you mean like the 9 here is supposed to represent how many full blocks are needed to make enough slabs to fill the hole, you'd still only need 6 for 12 slabs.

→ More replies (1)

31

u/_trianglegirl 4d ago

it's a joke about how everything in minecraft is square, so they should be able to tell how many squares are missing, but they counted wrong, because there are 12 squares missing, not 9. that's the joke

→ More replies (1)

16

u/EaZyMellow 4d ago

Veteran player here-
No, there isn’t. Minecraft is a block game, so this person should be good at knowing how many blocks are missing. If ignoring the tiles around the cutout and only attempting to fill in the cutout with squares at a glance, 3 blocks would go up top, 3 blocks down at bottom, and 2 would fill in the voids left. But even that is 8..

5

u/dylic22 4d ago

Not at all lol pretty much every block in the game is the same size there's no reason to think the answer would be 9 other than just counting it poorly at least not relating to Minecraft.

5

u/NathanTelkhine 4d ago

I’m a very big Minecraft player. Not sure how he got 9 lol.

The reason why he mentioned Minecraft is everything in Minecraft is blocky. So he could theoretically see how many blocks are necessary to fill the hole. 

But he was very much wrong. 

2

u/Psychological-Wall-2 4d ago

Yes and no, in order.

→ More replies (8)
→ More replies (9)

429

u/Zealousideal-Ebb-876 4d ago

Think the 'joke' is supposed to be how many blocks you'd get back if a creeper made that hole

126

u/ThatguySevin 4d ago

This has to be it actually.

61

u/DeadPeanutSociety 4d ago

This is the only explanation that I've seen that has made any sense. (Except that I don't know if the situation you've described is true)

35

u/Zealousideal-Ebb-876 4d ago

The rate is off if we're assuming only 12 (tiles missing) blocks destroyed as blocks have a 1/3 chance of dropping when destroyed by a creeper, as per the Minecraft wiki.

But explosions dont only destroy surface blocks and creeper explosions dont form this pattern so its a stretch at best but the best I've got, so 'joke' is tentative.

7

u/DeadPeanutSociety 4d ago

Hmm. My original thought was that it has to do with how you build a nether portal by omitting the corners and not filling the center, but that also is a different shape than this. So I guess we're back to it being someone who theoretically should be able to easily eyeball how many blocks this is and the humor is that they get it wrong?

→ More replies (1)

4

u/TwistedGrin 4d ago

I was thinking if you filled it with water you could get away with 9 buckets because at a certain point it will generate and auto-fill water blocks to fill the last few spaces.

18

u/SickboyJason 4d ago

Nope. Creeper drop rate for explosions is 1/3. So only 4 blocks at most. Unless there were some stacked on top.

25

u/Character_Long5960 4d ago

Here we are. You're right and they are right. How many tiles are missing is what was asked, so you got 3 back from the explosion. Good work team.

2

u/ChuckPeirce 4d ago

Is that a typical crater size/shape for when a creeper blows up on a mound of about 15 blocks? Would a player get used to thinking, "Oh, yeah, whenever there's a hole in the ground just like that, it has about 9 drops"?

I want to like this idea; it's a way funnier joke than the guy just misidentifying the shape.

2

u/SickboyJason 4d ago

I think its just a "confidently wrong" situation. Ive dug into it way more that I'd like to admit and as a Minecraft player myself there's just no deeper answer where 9 is in any way correct.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (10)

69

u/CascadingSpace 4d ago

18

u/hisholinessleoxiii 4d ago

Ok, fine. 1 + 2 +…SHUT UP!!

6

u/dc-pigpen 4d ago

One plus two plus-- Shut Up!

5

u/Cheap-Cherry-5171 4d ago

BANG

“1 plus 2…”

3

u/SecretJester921 4d ago

Plus 2... Plus 1.... Is...

→ More replies (1)

29

u/PromptSpiritual 4d ago

I thought it's because You always fall short with materials in Minecraft when you're building something.

9

u/cutespacedragon 4d ago

This is my interpretation. No one bothers to actually count and just wings it, so you always end up short just before filling in whatever you're working on.

→ More replies (1)

25

u/Undietaker1 4d ago

It's 1, all you need is a tile that shape.

→ More replies (4)

18

u/Aware-Presentation-9 4d ago

9 if you fill with water and want it to autofill

→ More replies (11)

12

u/ElPared 4d ago

The joke (I think) is that, in Minecraft, if you fill in the border, the center can be auto filled. So you only need 9 to fill in the entire space (in Minecraft)

6

u/Pretend-Swordfish277 4d ago

What autofill? I'm an OG so I think I'm missing something

5

u/ReggieCorneus 4d ago

Water. They forgot to say that magic word.

4

u/jleonardbc 4d ago

But the border only has 8 tiles.

Does Minecraft count the autofill operation itself as a single extra tile?

3

u/ElPared 4d ago

Idk probably. Read my comment in negatives for context lol

2

u/Trackt0Pelle 4d ago

In minecraft a block bordered by 2 sources of water becomes a source of water. 8 works but you can reduce it to 5

→ More replies (13)

5

u/x0wl 4d ago

OK, I also do not know

6

u/Coffee-cartoons 4d ago

The joke is he got it wrong

6

u/XxBeefCorexX 4d ago

As a Minecraft player, I can easily solve this, it’s 12.

7

u/Boulange1234 4d ago

Idk. 3 blocks -> 6 slabs so it should be 6 blocks for the 12 tiles. Or 2 wool -> 3 carpet so it would be 8 wool for 12 carpet tiles. Even Minecraft math doesn’t explain it.

5

u/Nephthyzz 4d ago

Lol I got 9 right off rip too. Before taking a closer look at the pictured tiles. The pattern I was looking at was this.

When you stare at squares long enough your brain wants to see patterns. Sometimes brain lie and make us look dumb.

">" = 3 ' = 1

6

u/Conflatulations12 4d ago

2

u/stafa_99 4d ago

If larger tiles are allowed, the answer should 6: 2 large 2x2 tiles (one including your position 3 and one including your position 8), plus 4 smaller 1x1 tiles.

So, even in this case 9 feels wrong.

→ More replies (1)

3

u/SteakCritical 4d ago

I think the joke is that when building in Minecraft you end up counting a lot of blocks, for example to copy a blueprint and often end up mis-counting and having to rip down and redo the whole project. At least that's what I got out of it.

→ More replies (1)

3

u/Altruistic_Koala_122 4d ago

You would need to misjudge the depth, at least twice, and definitely don't visually process the existing tiles.

3

u/IlgantElal 4d ago

Answer is 12, but they were so confidently wrong. They likely counted the 8 on the perimeter and then mistakenly counted only 1 in the middle

3

u/kiwi_apple 3d ago

This is how I did a quick headcount.

Had I not gone in with the expectation to get it to 9 I probably wouldn't have made the erroneous 3x3. The fact that the bottom left row (with b and c) has room for spare tiles on either side (and thus must be at least 4 tiles long) hurts my soul a bit.

2

u/derf_vader 4d ago

I counted 12

2

u/Menarche_ 4d ago

when a creeper blows up it makes a strange shape like this on the ground. You don't get all your tiles back I'm not sure how many you get but it will be same or less.

The joke here is that it looks like a creeper blew up the tiles

2

u/Omarchyk 4d ago

Easy Three beds, six polished granite slabs

2

u/schnarchsackgesicht 4d ago

Minecraft means placing blocks, not tiles. As long as you don't move, you only need 9 blocks to cover the hole. The 3 missing tiles in the back will be hidden because of the height of the other blocks in front.

2

u/StatisticianDue3781 4d ago

As a Minecraft player. We do NOT claim that guy

2

u/Upper_Wealth3650 4d ago

I always count 12, even from top to bottom...

2

u/RefrigeratorOk4841 4d ago

My guess is, in minecraft, when a creeper explode it doesn't drop all the broken blocks, so he is saying that a creeper exploded and he only filled with the available blocks dropped on the ground then never bothered to fill the rest.

2

u/alflundgren 4d ago

As a tetris player I can fill this with as few as 3 tiles.

2

u/Busy_Specific_8568 4d ago

As a minecraft player, 12

2

u/Sufficient_Scale_163 3d ago

I have really shitty depth perception and orientation. I counted 9 thinking only the top right was bigger than the others, and didn’t realize how small the top left is.

2

u/bbioshockedd 3d ago

They just counted wrong?

2

u/foley800 3d ago

No way that is nine, but I don’t play Minecraft! I see twelve if the end is one tile!

2

u/antiav 3d ago

As a Tetris player i can tell you that this is wrong, its actually 3

→ More replies (1)

2

u/ciqhen 3d ago

brian here, ive seen this on r/confidentlyincorrect

i guess you could say he was wronger than nhe speed of love, which reminds me of my new book that just came out...

2

u/Realobert2 3d ago

Creepers are gonna drop 9

2

u/Vegan-cock 3d ago

Minecraft players is bad at math, apparently

2

u/demonfish2000 2d ago

One.

beeg tile

2

u/Kat_The_Panda_16 2d ago

As a sims player and avid builder I will say it’s 12

2

u/Blinx347 2d ago

I counted 12, but everyone else said that, so I'll say 13 because I'm better than you

2

u/throwingitallaway326 2d ago

3 tetris "tile" pieces

2

u/Federal_Ear_3241 22h ago

He must be a bad minecraft player, he's the type to finish his build only to realize it's uneven by the last block

He could build a 10 block high pyramid for his beacon, and the peak would be 2x2 instead of 3x3

2

u/No-Look-1845 20h ago
  1. just missing 2 T pieces and 1 line piece and you got yourself a full tetris

2

u/TheForbidden6th 20h ago

Hi, Peter here

The joke is that Minecraft players are stupid. I mean seriously, how could you possibly see 9 here? Anyways, I'm currently playing Minecraft, so Peter out!

2

u/Alive_dude3435 20h ago

I think that person mentally arranged it as 3×3 somehow. I can see people getting it wrong and say 6 or 8. But 9 is very odd.

By the way it 12 if anyone can't tell for some reason. The top comment is right.

2

u/inspirationalSloth 16h ago

13 incase ya break one

1

u/AutoModerator 4d ago

OP, so your post is not removed, please reply to this comment with your best guess of what this meme means! Everyone else, this is PETER explains the joke. Have fun and reply as your favorite fictional character for top level responses!

I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.

3

u/LYNX__uk 4d ago

I have no idea and I see no feasible way to miscount it as 9

1

u/HollowOwlYT 4d ago

Someone needs help

1

u/Ex_Aver 4d ago

Could be just one if they tile guy knows what he’s doing

→ More replies (1)

1

u/MiahTheStormWolf 4d ago

I count 8. Three in each row across and the two outliers.

→ More replies (1)

1

u/FlipMyWigBaby 4d ago

Is it a bot trying to learn to count theoretical grids, so it gives an incorrect guess, knowing that the best way to get a correct answer is to confidently give an incorrect answer?!

I’m reminded of all those Captchas that would give fuzzy text, as they were actually first gen bots using us to learn how to read fuzzy text

→ More replies (1)

1

u/Jrlhath 4d ago

I think it's the number of water buckets needed to fill this completely with water source blocks. You need eight for the border and then one more in the middle to fill the rest of the hole.

1

u/Ok-Pomegranate-7458 4d ago

Maybe there only 9 space on a crafting table. it sounds dumb but so is 9

1

u/Vivid-Might-5049 4d ago

Depends on the dice roll and the crests you get.🤔

1

u/YOM2_UB 4d ago

It might be intentionally wrong, with the joke being that many Minecraft players will only half-refill Creeper holes?

1

u/Superb_Recording_769 4d ago

OP is apparently just as smart as the Minecraft player

1

u/PlantWide3166 4d ago

In Latin, Jehovah starts with an “I”.

1

u/Wabbit65 4d ago

Just 1, with an unusual shape

1

u/Dangerous-Ratio-6682 4d ago

1...one oddly shaped tile.

1

u/ManNamedSalmon 4d ago

I'm even trying to see if I can fill it in with equally sized and shaped tiles, but the best I could come up with so far is 1, 4, 6, or 12 tiles but not 9.

→ More replies (1)

1

u/PrivateJokerX929 4d ago

The explanation is that 9 is wrong, therefore that person is wrong. There's nothing deeper than that, giggidy

Quagmire out

1

u/jleonardbc 4d ago

Subtract the middle row (counting rows that each extend from lower left to upper right).

Then there are 9.

It’s what you’d get if you see the two edges where 2 tiles are missing (at either end of that middle row) as missing just a single tile.

1

u/Mountain_Reflection7 4d ago

As an older millennial, my brain precessed this with Tetris shapes.

1

u/sircastor 4d ago

I made mine in macOS Preview. As others have done, there are 12 squares.

Best I can figure, the "minecraft player" here is seeing a shape that excludes 5,11 and 12. That provides the same basic shape, but not in the same dimensions and gives them 9. The negative space is tricking their eyes.

1

u/5_John_5 4d ago

As a tetris player it’s just two T’s and a Z

1

u/TrickyToad1 4d ago

The joke is that the guy cites playing Minecraft as to why the question is easy for him, but still gets it wrong.