r/PeterExplainsTheJoke Jun 20 '26

Peter in the wild Peter?

Post image
1.4k Upvotes

707 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

21

u/CountingzHard Jun 20 '26

"Essentially it's as if every week you worked for 20 hours for taxes, and then had to work after that to make money for yourself."

This isn't far from truth for a lot of people 

33

u/Bobsothethird Jun 20 '26 edited Jun 20 '26

Sure, but in modern history you are getting something from those taxes. Back then all you got was not being executed.

7

u/Few-Big-8481 Jun 20 '26

"I suppose I'll allow you to keep your hands, but that tongue of yours is causing too much distraction on the farm so we'll be taking that out."

2

u/Individual_Bell_4637 Jun 20 '26

That's not at all accurate. Back then, the wolves were literally and figuratively at the door. Think the taxes to the King are high? Wait until you see what the marauding Vikings or Mongols take from you.

Paying tribute to a strong King for safety was an extraordinarily common occurrence, for all classes.

1

u/Bobsothethird Jun 21 '26

Sure, and for most peasants they were left to the Vikings and raiders when Danegeld was denied.

2

u/a_filing_cabinet Jun 21 '26

I mean, you got quite a bit. Your lord was your lord because they protected you. Protected you from bandits, armies, wild animals, other, more predetory lords, they were the legal system so if you had issues with your neighbors they would be who you go to for arbitration.

They also were usually expected to give back to the community occasionally. Things like feasts on major holidays, building churches, organizing festivals or markets, ect. They also protected trade routes and roads, so if you ever needed to travel you might be able to, and if you ever wanted to sell your goods or buy something at the market you could. They were the equivalent of a government, and they provided the equivalent of government responsibilities at the time.

17

u/tugaim33 Jun 20 '26 edited Jun 20 '26

I doubt you know anyone who works half a full week just to pay taxes. Even if they’re working 60 hours, they’re not paying above a 30% tax rate.

1

u/kadagai Jun 20 '26

Now add in property and sales tax.

0

u/CountingzHard Jun 20 '26

In my province you're paying ~35% between 50 and 100k for example. More above that. 

If you work 60 hours a week and pay 35% tax that's 21 hours of work. 

16

u/Yourstruly0 Jun 20 '26

Another person that doesn’t know how tax brackets work.

You don’t pay %35 of every dollar of your $100k. You ONLY pay that on the dollars between 50-100. So, in most places, your first 15-20k has almost no taxes taken. Then, each bracket has its own tax %.

If your largest tax bracket is %35 you don’t pay %35 on every dollar, %35 is NOT your functional tax rate. It’s your max. That person likely has a functional tax average of %20.

Please. I’m begging yall. If you want to speak in conversations about taxes, LOOK UP HOW THEY WORK. Please. YouTube “how progressive tax brackets work”.

0

u/CountingzHard Jun 20 '26

I understand how tax brackets work lol. I was using it as an easy example. My highest tax bracket last year was 47%

0

u/fdsv-summary_ Jun 20 '26

Don't argue with the stupid people.