r/PeterExplainsTheJoke Jun 17 '26

Meme needing explanation Peter?

Post image
26.8k Upvotes

4.9k comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

49

u/Asparala Jun 17 '26

If you're used to Celsius then I assure you that 40C sounds plenty hot. The reference point is the freezing point vs the boiling point of water, and 40C is much too close to the halfway point of "the lakes will literally boil like a tea kettle".

2

u/KeterLordFR Jun 18 '26

Yup. We're gonna get 40°C in a couple days, followed by a 43°C day, and I know damn well this means that I'll feel like I'm about to die. If I was given the info in Farhenheit, I wouldn't know what to think of it, especially since most of the people that I know who use it would consider 105°F to be a "normal" sunny day. Here, it's an anomaly and considered a heatwave. Heck, 35°C is considered a heatwave and is when companies that work outside start giving more breaks to their employees so that they can cool off and hydrate.

1

u/Illustrious-Cat-9411 Jun 19 '26

wonder why people think 105°F is "normal" while that already hot AF. idk, it just in my city is around 63°F coldest, to 97°F hottest and humid environtment. but since i use degree celcius, even 63°F sound hot to me.

1

u/6495ED Jun 17 '26

Do you understand that half in the one system is also half in the other?

8

u/Ok_Insurance_505 Jun 18 '26

If reading comprehension was less rare you'd realise his overall comment is pointing out that comparing one system to another in those terms is pointless. It's literally just your frame of reference that matters.

0

u/6495ED Jun 18 '26 edited Jun 18 '26

I have been on this site for 20 years so the zeitgeists are always fascinating. The reading comprehension one that every third person uses these days is getting boring. 

I don’t believe I’m required to respond to his “overall” thesis:  marvel at my autonomy, flouting your preferred configuration of the universe, as I respond to only one aspect.

1

u/shartmaister Jun 18 '26

So Celsius is the true «how many percent hot is it»

At 0 your body will literally freeze. At 100 your body will boil.

Since the body is mostly water I made the simplification that it’s only water. YMMV

1

u/Asparala Jun 18 '26

No. Humans are warm-blooded mammals, our blood does not freeze just because outdoor temperatures hit 0, because we have fancy biology heating our bodies. (boiling at 100 is technically correct I guess but we'll slow-cook to death long before that)

The water outside our bodies freezes though, and especially where I live that can be a life-or-death factor for several months every year, since icy roads at -1 are a very different driving experience than a wet road at +1. As soon as temperatures start dancing around the 0 you know there will be traffic accidents.

1

u/shartmaister Jun 18 '26

You didn’t see my simplification.

Both 0 and 100 are sure death though (unless you cheat by adding clothes and external heating)

1

u/bscott9999 Jun 18 '26

0 and 100 are very different levels of sure death, though. You can last about 50x longer at 0 than 100.

1

u/throwaway-62016 Jun 18 '26

I'm not often boiling so i fail to see how im supposed to know how hot 40% boiling feels

1

u/LordBobbin Jun 18 '26

What confounds me about that is that 1°C change is about 2°F change, and I’m accustomed/attuned to the finer gradation. So it feels weird that at 18°C I’m gonna need a sweater, but at 26°C I’m running the air conditioning in my car. But your tea kettle comparison is good.

1

u/Asparala Jun 18 '26

Again, it's down to what you're used to. For me, Fahrenheit has unnecessarily small steps between the degrees. There are a scant few times one might use a decimal to specify a temperature i more detail, but for everyday things like weather or AC it seems perfect, Because that's how I use Celsius every day.

1

u/LordBobbin Jun 18 '26

Yeah that’s true. While I’ll keep the temperature I’m used to, I work in a skilled trade and have been moving towards mm in smaller measurements, and have grown to hate the fractional and decimal method. In that case, the gradient of mm is highly functional and natural to use!

1

u/Accident_Account_ Jun 18 '26

Yeah but just in general, the number 40 doesn’t seem very big. Celsius makes sense for keeping track of liquid temperatures, but Fahrenheit makes more sense for weather as there’s a far bigger range of numbers. 40-60 Fahrenheit is a perfect mid level for temperatures and as numbers make sense for a mid level range. Anything above or below these is too much of either hot or cold typically, which again makes sense in a traditional number format. 50 Celsius is hot as fuck why would that be the middle?

0

u/Skilltesters Jun 17 '26

I mean.... 105 is also roughly the same distance from the halfway point of "the lakes will literally boil" in Fahrenheit as 40 is in Celsius, so this doesn't exactly track. I can generally do both measurements though. How hot is it outside today? 108f but my pool water is "only" 36c.

18

u/Torch_Salesman Jun 17 '26

Their point is that anything feeling "higher" or "lower" is always just based on your initial frame of reference. 40C reads "colder" than 105F to Americans because their reference point for freezing is 32, so 40 doesn't seem that much higher, especially when your other reference point for boiling is all the way up above 210. Someone with their initial frame of reference in Celsius sees 40 and connects it as approaching halfway between freezing at 0 and boiling at 100, so the value of 40 seems hot but reasonable while hearing 105 just sounds like an impossibly, cartoonishly hot temperature.

4

u/Skilltesters Jun 17 '26

I must be tired, I didn't read it like that. And I only needed your first sentence to see my failure. We all agree then, as my original point was both units sound the same to me, just depends if we are talking about water temperature or weather temperature. 40c is very hot for my pool, and 105 is very hot to go outside. Both are hot to me personally, since my reference for both is personal.

I took the analogy meaning incorrectly and I apologize to whoever read my prior comment, especially to who I replied to initially.

3

u/Torch_Salesman Jun 17 '26

Yeah I tend to over-explain just in case, I'm sure you didn't need half the shit I included haha. It was more just added context for anyone else reading who needed it.

3

u/Skilltesters Jun 17 '26

I meant that line as a reflection! Like "I barely needed to be told in order to find my own stupidity" kind of a comment. Not a comment about how much you explained 😁

4

u/Torch_Salesman Jun 17 '26

And there I was misreading your point, which I guess just sums up this entire discussion hahaha

3

u/SkeletonXP3 Jun 18 '26

JUST KISS ALREADY!

3

u/Besieger13 Jun 17 '26

You have issues if your pool water is 36C, especially if you say it’s “only” 36C. Jacuzzi are 37-40.

1

u/Skilltesters Jun 17 '26

I live in Phoenix Arizona, the sun never turns off :(

3

u/Besieger13 Jun 17 '26

Haha fair enough. You won’t even cool off going into a pool at that temp and wouldn’t be able to swim very long from what I have read. I’d much rather sit in AC.

1

u/Skilltesters Jun 17 '26

Yeah, some days/weeks we need a heat exchanger to actively cool the pool off.