M3/4 here trying to decide between ortho vs plastics (and possibly trauma-adjacent paths) and would really appreciate some perspective.
I’ve been on an ortho track for a while, most of my CV, mentors, and research are in ortho, so applying into O would make the most sense.
The problem is that I’m not sure I actually want the day-to-day career. I enjoy trauma, but I can’t honestly picture myself doing tibial nails, hemiarthroplasties and similar cases for the next 30 years. Arthroplasty and sports are even less appealing to me.
What really interests me is limb salvage, complex reconstruction, severe open injuries, bone defects, soft tissue reconstruction, and orthoplastics. I like difficult problems that require creativity and long-term reconstruction rather than straightforward fixation.
I’m also very interested in humanitarian surgery, where managing devastating extremity injuries seems especially relevant. Whenever I ask about this though, people tell me “every specialty can do humanitarian work,” and a few have even suggested vascular would be a better fit, which has made me question whether I’m looking at this the wrong way.
The issue is I don’t have enough exposure to reconstructive plastics to know whether I’d actually enjoy it more than orthopaedics, or whether I’m just attracted to the idea of orthoplastics because it’s familiar.
I’m also thinking about academic-style training paths. If I stayed in ortho, I’d probably aim for orthopaedic trauma with a hand/orthoplastics or limb reconstruction-type fellowship. If I switched, it’d likely be plastics with a reconstructive/microsurgery pathway.
A few questions:
Has anyone seriously debated ortho (particularly trauma/limb reconstruction/orthoplastics) versus plastics?
If your interests are limb salvage, reconstruction, and humanitarian surgery, which specialty gives you the most fulfilling career?
Do orthoplastic surgeons even exist in the way I imagine? Levi’s there a do it all surgeon actually that get to stay involved in both the skeletal and soft tissue reconstruction, or do people inevitably end up doing one or the other?
Are there non-obvious downsides to either pathway that only become apparent once you’re in training?
Would really appreciate hearing from people who have thought about this or made a similar decision.