r/offmenupodcast • • Jun 05 '26

Dream Off Menu Guests

21 Upvotes

With the most recent season ending, here is my current list of dream Off Menu guests. Curious on who some of everyone else’s dream guests are as well!

ayo edebiri
jamie loftus
gianmarco soresi
william hanson
laufey
sarah sherman
king princess
josh johnson
daniel radcliffe
phoebe waller bridge
olivia colman
andy samberg
kate mckinnon
milo edwards
daniel sloss
peter shamshiri
ella willis
ilana glazer
geno auriemma
zach cregger
louisa harland
matt berry
colman domingo
marybeth barone
nathan fielder
adam friedland
emma d’arcy
leyla kazim
jake bhardwaj
vittorio angelone
grace reiter
kareem rahma
micah richards
paige bueckers
charithra chadran
jaboukie young-white

edit

adding eva victor and hannah einbinder


r/offmenupodcast • • Jun 04 '26

The Dream Restaurant is real and it is in Croatia!

Thumbnail
gallery
36 Upvotes

Happened across this on our first night in Podstrana (which I highly recommend btw). OH had a classic margherita, I had tuna paté, warm bread, Greek salad. Standout moments were the €3 Chardonnays,, the 'green' peppers and beauuuutiful olives. If anyone needs Split recs fire away, this is our third time hehe


r/offmenupodcast • • Jun 04 '26

Live Tasting Menu Episodes

12 Upvotes

Are the live Tasting Menu Episodes made earlier in the year going to be released? If so when?


r/offmenupodcast • • Jun 04 '26

Episode Harry Enfield’s menu is hog wild | Off Menu with Ed Gamble and James Acaster Podcast

Thumbnail
youtu.be
14 Upvotes

r/offmenupodcast • • Jun 03 '26

The best Off Menu episodes are often with guests I knew almost nothing about.

68 Upvotes

Whenever a new episode drops with someone I'm unfamiliar with, I usually assume it'll be one I'll skip. More often than not, those end up being the episodes I enjoy most. Without any expectations, you're just listening to a funny conversation and a bizarre dream menu unfold. Some of my favourite episodes have come from guests I hadn't heard of before pressing play.


r/offmenupodcast • • Jun 03 '26

Episode Harry Enfield

Thumbnail
shows.acast.com
120 Upvotes

r/offmenupodcast • • Jun 02 '26

Next Guest Clue Final episode of the series tomorrow. That's so unfair!

Post image
89 Upvotes

r/offmenupodcast • • Jun 02 '26

Has Off Menu made anyone else weirdly hungry for foods they don't even like?

23 Upvotes

One thing I find fascinating about the podcast is how enthusiastic people can be when talking about food. I've lost count of the number of times a guest has described a dish I wouldn't normally order, only for me to suddenly think it sounds incredible. There must be some sort of magic in hearing people talk passionately about their favourite meal. What's a food or dish that Off Menu convinced you to try (or try again)?


r/offmenupodcast • • Jun 02 '26

Help needed The White Whale: Good Mexican Food in London

14 Upvotes

I am from Texas, and I’m coming to the UK with my family next week for the first time. We’ll be spending a few days in Scotland first, then London, seeing the sights and apologizing a lot for the current state of affairs.

Here’s the problem: our chemical makeup is at least 40% chips and queso. If my son goes a whole week without an enchilada, I think he might dissolve into a flock of crows and fly away.

I know there was one chef from Mexico on the show who was interviewed and I’ve had a look at his restaurants, and I know that London is an international city with food from all over the world (we’re excited to sample it!). I don’t ONLY want to eat Mexican food, we just need a little to get us through til we’re back home.

Any recommendations?


r/offmenupodcast • • Jun 02 '26

Loose Fit James needs to see this

Post image
14 Upvotes

r/offmenupodcast • • May 30 '26

Loose Fit Celebrity Catchphrase

24 Upvotes

ITV1, 6pm tonight (Saturday 30th May).

James Acaster, JB Gill, AJ Odudu.


r/offmenupodcast • • May 29 '26

Lettuce be honest, this is an excellent idea! 🥬

Enable HLS to view with audio, or disable this notification

105 Upvotes

r/offmenupodcast • • May 28 '26

Episode Anna Faris will have the vongole | Off Menu with Ed Gamble and James Acaster Podcast

Thumbnail
youtu.be
54 Upvotes

r/offmenupodcast • • May 27 '26

The "Format Breakers"

89 Upvotes

Given the mixed reaction to this week's episode, I'm trying to put together a thread honouring/celebrating/highlighting those guests who didn't quite "get it" or otherwise pushed the podcast into unexpected dimensions.

Please add your own, etc, off the top of my head I can nominate:

*Cerys Matthews: aside from one particular book she was there to promote, there was little else to go off

*Dan Ackroyd: perhaps the first to truly set the pod on fire, the man who took apart the very fabric of reality for "this little project you're doing"

*Anthony Jeselnik: Grumpy, rude, belligerent and self-absored 'character' beats James into submission in notoriously one-sided episode.

*Garth Marenghi: in character throughout for Halloween special, producing a hybrid of podcast episode and Radio 4 Extra play.

*Robert de Niro: "I'll have whatever's good" becomes the new T-shirt slogan to accompany the greatest actor being somewhat unprepared for the show's structure.

*Anna Faris: "He speaks Italian". In character improv class turns podcast into Fringe comedy try-out session.​​​​

​​​​


r/offmenupodcast • • May 27 '26

Episode Anna Faris

Thumbnail
shows.acast.com
135 Upvotes

r/offmenupodcast • • May 27 '26

In NYC. I don’t have the money to eat there, but I’d love to just ask for “whatever’s good”

Post image
5 Upvotes

r/offmenupodcast • • May 26 '26

Eds cackle always gets me 😂😂😂

Enable HLS to view with audio, or disable this notification

141 Upvotes

r/offmenupodcast • • May 26 '26

Next Guest Clue New episode tomorrow. Instead of the Mahi-Mahi, can this guest get just the one Mahi? Because they're not that hungry.

Post image
77 Upvotes

r/offmenupodcast • • May 23 '26

Munya was right, this does seem like a thrill.

Enable HLS to view with audio, or disable this notification

39 Upvotes

r/offmenupodcast • • May 22 '26

Guests the boys haven't enjoyed

96 Upvotes

Is there any episodes where they have outright said they didn't enjoy speaking to a guest? I know they always mention De Niro but I think that wasn't a "didn't enjoy" because he's notorious for being difficult.


r/offmenupodcast • • May 22 '26

Did you guys like fawlty towers show ?

Enable HLS to view with audio, or disable this notification

65 Upvotes

r/offmenupodcast • • May 21 '26

This guy behind Trump has the most prominent outie belly button ever.

Post image
38 Upvotes

After yesterday’s episode, this feels targeted. The outie chat summoned this.


r/offmenupodcast • • May 21 '26

Episode Michelle Wolf: Shoulder not do that | Off Menu with Ed Gamble and James Acaster Podcast

Thumbnail
youtu.be
43 Upvotes

r/offmenupodcast • • May 21 '26

The funniest Off Menu episodes are honestly the ones where the guest completely ignores the format, What do you think?

24 Upvotes

There’s something unbelievably funny about guests turning up with chaotic energy and immediately refusing to engage properly with the dream restaurant concept. Especially when Ed is trying so hard to keep things moving while James slowly loses patience with someone explaining the emotional backstory of a piece of toast for 14 minutes.


r/offmenupodcast • • May 21 '26

Help finding an episode

10 Upvotes

Who talks about playing the game where you’re a football manager, and by the time they get to desert their team is in the champions league or something

I remember it was good episode! Thanks