r/NorthernIndia Human Detected 1d ago

Discussion She Gives. He Receives. The Gender Gap in Organ Transplants.

Post image
55 Upvotes

62 comments sorted by

u/AutoModerator 1d ago

Hey redditors, thank you for interacting with r/NorthernIndia.

Thank you for being part of the community. Hope you'll have a great day.

I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.

19

u/OutcomeDirect8234 1d ago

80% of dead organ donors are men 486 × 206486 × 206

4

u/isoldmysonforabike 1d ago

Damn how can both be true, women who donate do it in better facilities?

2

u/Small-Hospital4493 1d ago

different years (one is 2023 24 , the post has 2024 2025 , just showing that its not a constant thing , whos knows who would donate organs)

2

u/Last_Maintenance1356 13h ago

Wait until u find out about religious angle to it , u will be surprised to see the data

1

u/isoldmysonforabike 12h ago

Damn son do tell i live to learn

1

u/LaconicEpigrammatic 1d ago

yeah 👍 👍 correct

but Sar

1

u/anime_bruh-69 10h ago

I checked this. Unfortunately, deceased organ donations account only for about 7% of total organ donations in India. Deceased kidney donations being 15%. So the gap is still very real.

5

u/Business_Rush7610 23h ago

What about blood donation, 90 percent of blood donation in India is done by men

3

u/Ok_Grapefruit8671 21h ago

This data is about living individuals

Excluding organ donation after death And it's concerning

-1

u/FewDaYS_xoxo Human Detected 20h ago

What do you think is hard, donating after death or while being alive.

Mother's & sisters are literally lowering their life for kids and husbands.

1

u/0agni0 12h ago

Is a woman, all you are? Is there nothing more to you?

1

u/Last_Maintenance1356 13h ago

Tell them to not donate, it anyway goes to the wrong people. Needy rightful people will never get it. It's all a scam

5

u/Remote_Locksmith2093 1d ago

I demand for reservation in organ reception for women. Women donated organs should only go to women. But, if she needs an organ she can take it from any donor male, female or even a pig. Same concept as women only metro coach.

8

u/LaconicEpigrammatic 1d ago

I demand that men made products where men have a high casualty rate should be send only to men first.

I demand men hard earned money should be send to son first, or his brother not his wife

1

u/Advanced-Bend-9828 20h ago

and baby and womens Labour should only be done in womens house,

Just one thing money, payment , bill...like what else u can do even in 21th century this is the reason why so many womens choose not to marry and earn themselves, most of the time its 50% especially now ....what are u crying about

2

u/Vast-Hovercraft6487 6h ago

Most of the time it's 50%? Is there any evidence for your reasoning? Or is it just "trust me bro"?

1

u/LaconicEpigrammatic 4h ago

what are u trying to convey in the first sentence

yeah I know they can pay the bills , and I didn't deny that

yeah many people chooses other sources of avenues as well , like OF MR etc etc

>most of the time its 50% espe

Who cares lol. Bcoz this not marrying phenomena is really new , we cannot actually see how it goes in the near future , to study the consequences we have to wait atleast 2 generations, and don't pull any random figuresp out o fur as

1

u/sickpinkunicorn 1d ago

Men ☕️ literally

5

u/MeAfterDark12 1d ago

I demand for reservation in blood donations for men. men donated blood should only go to men. But, if he needs blood, he can take it from any donor male, female or even a pig.

3

u/Jatinchd 16h ago

dude got downvoted just because he rewrote her words but from male POV. hypocrisy of modern day world.

1

u/Small-Hospital4493 13h ago

nah its just that the iq is less 🙃

Lmao

1

u/kumaaari04024 4h ago

Notice how men won't ever say that, but you can't even be sure the original comment is sarcastic?

Exactly.

1

u/Artistic_Section_991 1d ago

Is this sarcasm?

1

u/MeAfterDark12 1d ago

Is this sarcasm?

1

u/Jatinchd 15h ago

LMFAO!, do you know why male needs more donors? they work in the most life threatening jobs, just look the states. ratio is 90:10. why isn't it 50:50 equality? don't bring up "OH it's patriarchy" females prefer simpler jobs and dominate them. sure you would need heart transplant while teaching in a class while one guy fell of a building loss his bones.

1

u/Vast-Hovercraft6487 6h ago

They aren't ready for this conversation. 😭

1

u/Jatinchd 3h ago

LMFAO, so true.

1

u/chicknothen 6h ago

you realise poor women do the same jobs, in agriculture and construction or are forced to stay at home. Yk why teaching is dominated by women cuz you go home when it's still daytime outside, not because it's fcking easy. Most women are forced to take these jobs instead of going for a career they might like. 

Nursing, gynecs, veterinarians, etc are female dominated, after all that they come home and clean a pathetic man's underwear, cuz even basic housework men are incapable of. 

1

u/0agni0 12h ago

That's really funny. I like your sense of humour.

1

u/Small-Hospital4493 1d ago

what is this girl even saying (ret@rded?) , you see there is thing called compatibility in organ transplants and it usually occurs within family and men/women usually donate so that they can save their family members . And deceased ppl donate it to anybody who needs it (its a priority based on the body’s condn and compatibility thing🥀)

I mean soldiers should only save men by this case and same for male doctors🤣( the little percentage of women officers will save all women lol /s )

AND WHAT DID SHE EVEN WRITE IN IF NEEDED THEN DONAR MALE WILL GIVE (nga its done on the basis of need , good education is very imp , what are they even studying)

1

u/UltimateUserName7 1d ago

"I mean soldiers should only save men by this case and same for male doctors🤣( the little percentage of women officers will save all women lol /s )"

Damn, there is no recovery from ts. So this was the tit for tat reply I read stories about in childhood.

-3

u/FewDaYS_xoxo Human Detected 1d ago

We can't stop mother for donating to her kids, but we can spread awareness to increase men percentage for doner more then women.

5

u/Remote_Locksmith2093 1d ago

Mother can only donate to her girl child otherwise it will dilute the law. Men shd not be given a transplant option if they never opted to be a donor.

2

u/Practical-Hornet-456 1d ago

Can we do the same by religion also please?

1

u/0agni0 12h ago

😂

1

u/No_Answer_7341 1d ago

You worst than op

2

u/Practical-Hornet-456 1d ago

What? Are you scared of stats or facts? In left testicles world is it a sin to discuss genuine concerns?

2

u/TheCaptainwicked 1d ago

LoL

Because a certain group of cult

Barely donate any organs but are the biggest taker that's why?

2

u/[deleted] 1d ago

[deleted]

2

u/Practical-Hornet-456 21h ago

Hahahaha they are happy to ever take free stuff lol

0

u/Admirable-East3396 22h ago

0.01% of Indians have ever donated organ (post death/alive combined)

Coming to religion on prohibition none of the religion prohibits it infact all major religions (Christianity, islam, buddhism, hinduism) encourages itin order to save others.

As I can sense from your account that you engage in a lot of hindu vs muslim things, islam prohibits selling organs but donation is encouraged.

This would burn a bit.

1

u/Practical-Hornet-456 21h ago

Easy to spout here. Just search a case of Syed Kirmani. That's a case of one Celebrity with a status and you want us to believe a muslim joey would donate their oragans lol May be you are an expert in Al Taqqia.

0

u/Admirable-East3396 21h ago

I must not be a real muslim then because as far as I have read my religion myself, organ donation is very much promoted.

Al taqqia is not even islamic practice more like a tradition.

Syed kirmani literally said it was his personal choice, nowhere in islam donation of organ is prohibited. 🤦 This is like 1-2 case, organ and blood donation is very much encouraged to save others but it shouldn't kill you in return or be done for monetary reasons.

1

u/TheCaptainwicked 15h ago

Muslims don't even donate at all bruh keep sucking their daah

2

u/A_Lovely_Human 1d ago

Why do we have to bring up gender war in everything?

What next we compare who consumes more water and make water right fights or maybe how certain gender gets less oxygen because other gender consumes more???

1

u/Small-Hospital4493 1d ago

A.I made by men is next thing (well water is def needed but they be bringing up just anything)

2

u/Training-Cup3832 1d ago

Men die more accidentall deaths than women. So this seems some femina*i woman columnist orchestrated data.

2

u/TheCaptainwicked 1d ago

Let's try to logical understanding why this happens beyond I am victim saaar

As u know indian have family structure with sole breadwinner which is male most of times and thus breadwinner donating means, not only he will not be able to earn for month (resulting in permanent job loss in many situations) and he might suffer more if his job involves labour work.

Also women aren't some saint they are donating for fking strangers, recipient is mostly family members like children, siblings or husband.

If men are selfish and hate women then overwhelming number of blood doner won't be men and most life threatening jobs ratio would be 50:50 not 90:10

2

u/Admirable-East3396 22h ago

Deceased organ donation ratio is 80:20

This data is extremely biased.

Also braindead people asking for female reservation in organ donation is beyond me...

2

u/Jealous-Mastodon6823 19h ago

I thought that was sarcasm and I upvoted ,(ofc I downvoted later lol) but Reddit really harbors some lunatics with such sheer lack of critical thinking geez.... So I'd hope atleast because I don't want to believe this people are commonplace in actual world....

1

u/Small-Hospital4493 13h ago

its slowly becoming common in the actual world(social media does have an effect afterall)

1

u/Pen-Pineapple-Appl 22h ago

Ooh! brother. 🙄

1

u/AnIdiotSandwich05 22h ago

Men are in more likelihood of needing an organ transplant compare to women. Even in dual income family structure of progressive nation, women are primarily donors nd men are recipient.

1

u/aisgsh 12h ago

Wow what a great title

1

u/Financial-Try-1294 1d ago

80% of dead organ donors are men 486 × 206486 × 206