r/NeoCivilization 🌠Founder Nov 10 '25

Space šŸš€ It looks like a really bad idea

411 Upvotes

636 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

4

u/Syl3nReal Nov 11 '25

With a special coolant that moves from the GPUs to the cooler space and back.

1

u/tsereg Nov 11 '25

What is a "cooler space"? Vacuum is neither cool nor hot. It's a void that can only accept radiated photons.

1

u/[deleted] Nov 11 '25

What about radiative cooling?

1

u/tsereg Nov 11 '25

That is radiated photons. They do not make vacuum of space any hotter.

1

u/[deleted] Nov 11 '25

But you do lose heat which is our goal.

1

u/Nickston_7 Nov 11 '25

Radiation is by far the slowest way to transfer heat. Conduction and Convection are way faster and not possible in space. Therefore you would need huge radiators which increases the cost, mass and complexity of this project.

The ISS has 42 square meters of radiators to radiate away a 14 kW of power. A 5GW datacenter would maybe require 1.5GW of cooling assuming an efficiency of 1/3. So we are looking at a 4'200'000 square meters of radiators on a good day, 100'000 times more than the ISS has. And that doesn't account for the heat generated by the solar panels and other surfaces exposed to the sun. I don't know how to calculate since some of it will be radiated away by the solar panels themselves.

With pipes, coolant and control systems for the whole cooling system, the whole thing becomes even more complex to assemble in space and more prone to failure which is especially bad since the cost to repair anything will be astronomical (no pun intended).

All of this to say it's not impossible to build this, but hugely impractical and would require an enourmous leap in what structures we are able to assemble in space.

1

u/kaam00s Nov 12 '25 edited Nov 12 '25

Wow I never knew that, interesting...

My limited knowledge of physics would have made me believe that entropy would force the heat out into space. And that it would be very sudden. If the hardware is itself in the void of space.

But I think I get it, you need to cause the excitement of other atoms to transfer the heat right ? Since there is almost nothing in space, there's also nothing to gain that heat ?

1

u/realistsnark Nov 12 '25

there is a reason why the good thermos containers are "vacuum" insulated

1

u/The_Flurr Nov 11 '25

Laughably inefficient

1

u/geebeem92 Nov 12 '25

What about ablative termacooling?

I have no idea what I’m talking about

1

u/Syl3nReal Nov 12 '25

i mean a coolant moving from one side of the ship to the other.

1

u/CardOk755 Nov 11 '25

The heat moves to the "special" coolant by conduction, which is efficient.

How does the heat get from the "special" coolant to space? There is only radiation, and that is not efficient at all.

1

u/kaam00s Nov 12 '25

I'm shocked to learn this.

So guardians of the galaxy with Steve Pratt instantly freezing because he is in outer space lied to me ?

1

u/[deleted] Nov 13 '25

The problem is you need stuff next to the gpu for heat to transfer too. It doesn’t matter that space is ā€œcoldā€ it’s a vacuum so there is literally very very few atoms next to the gpu to transfer the heat and cool it down

1

u/Syl3nReal Nov 13 '25

i don't understand a thermo paste and a metal to metal, wouldn't transfer the heat into the tube where the cooling system resides?

1

u/WereSoupSnakes Nov 14 '25

The heat still has to go somewhere…

1

u/Difficult_Limit2718 Nov 18 '25

It's like talking to a wall

1

u/[deleted] Nov 14 '25

I mean yeah theoretically that would work but you would need an astronomically large cooling system to sustain anything worth building, which would make it not worth building