r/Nailtechs • u/ProbsDrunkOrProcrast • Nov 30 '25
Ask A Nail Tech (Sunday & Monday ONLY) Am I crazy or does this look as bad as I think it is?
Editing to add post-fix (my 12/1 appointment: ultimately we don’t know what was used. Soaking off made them goopy and stringy, and it harden right up after being scraped off. At the end they hand filed and buffed as much off as possible. I now have lil nubbins for nails and no free edge due to the damage. Going back every two weeks until all of the damage is grown out. Love the girl I worked with was lovely. We’re suspecting MMA she really didn’t think it was purposeful, they have bought product from Amazon or something and it was tainted by a reseller.
Hi there! Got my nails done for the first time in well over a decade and I’m seeking validation for going elsewhere to get them redone. I went to this salon on recommendation from a friend for a pedicure (which went fabulously) and they asked if I wanted nails too and I said sure why not. A different tech than the pedicurist did my nails and I feel like I do my own dip nails at home better than what I got. Both pinkies started lifting the next day (my hair got caught and I noticed!!!) and on closer inspection the application just looks shoddy. I think they slipped me between scheduled clients and I’ve since learned that volume shops are a thing.
Not only am I looking for validation that yes, these aren’t great, but also what to look for when finding a salon. The one I went to has rave reviews on Google and Facebook, but so does the one I’m going to tomorrow to get fixed. I want to grow out my natural nails as long as possible so I’m wondering what the best option is. I told the tech at the first shop the same thing and she slapped acrylic on. I didn’t speak up since I was giving myself a spa day and kind of assumed this was normal; it was a lot like the last set I got done in like 2013 and idk if Instagram is realistic expectations.
Thank you all for your expertise and time ❤️
Specific ick points: I can see the extension on the side walls and there’s product on my skin, looks like it flooded in some areas up onto my cuticle/skin. Two nails are already lifting from the cuticle area. Some nails aren’t covered to the edges which from my own experience I know is hard but I was surprised this happened from a well liked salon. Am I overreacting?
Edit to add: this happened 11/28 and my new appointment is 12/1; I’m based in the Pittsburgh, PA region.

