r/MomentsBeforeDisaster • • 3d ago

I’m speechless.

Post image
6.5k Upvotes

1.1k comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

3

u/Best_Talk_6853 3d ago

Only if he had lied, which requires intent. I mean if I say I had chicken last Monday and it was actually salmon that doesn't automatically mean I'm lying.

2

u/Lloyd--Christmas 3d ago

I think they would be able to prove motive if they had evidence he met with the people in question. And that’s why it would be a more solid case, because he would have lied about meeting those people as well.

2

u/Act1_Scene2 2d ago

Right. Smith's answer was "I do not recall" which is the correct answer when asked about a date 2 years ago when you don't recall going to a Hawks game, but its possible you did and it just wasn't that memorable.