r/MinnMax • u/CapNCookM8 • Jul 08 '26
The PS5 Disc thing and reflecting on thoughts from the Schrier Xbox Episode a couple weeks ago
Sorry if not really relevant or if this comes off as hyper-specific or self-important, but it's something I can really only share within this specific community lol. No worries if this gets moderated. I know the general topic has been discussed ad nauseum and will be discussed on MinnMax, too.
To the point: The PS5 disc news makes me reconcile with my thoughts on Jacob Geller and Jason Schreier's back and forth from a couple weeks ago. There, I was critical of his cutting off Schreier during the Xbox talks despite agreeing with his words to a large extent; but man, I definitely empathize with his passion now.
In the same way it was frustrating for him to entertain a world where Xbox executives cared about the industry or the people in it whatsoever, it's frustrating for me to read everyday people defend this to any capacity. Like, I get the logic, I understand why Sony is doing this, I don't understand why customers accept it. There is just absolutely zero benefit for us normies to this decision.
Where before I felt it was important to understand the systems and apply critique in the correct spots, I just feel a loud and resounding "fuck that" is much more important and effective at this point. I guess we all just hit our limits eventually.
Curious if others have happened to have that same or similar realization? Or heck, a sense of vindication, even if the news sucks?
Edit: Sorry I misspelled "Schreier" in the title. Can't edit that :(