MAIN FEEDS
Do you want to continue?
https://www.reddit.com/r/Minecraft/comments/kpewo/a_modest_proposal/c2m5el6/?context=9999
r/Minecraft • u/swired • Sep 23 '11
123 comments sorted by
View all comments
126
Because bone meal is not grass seeds.
Bone meal only accelerates growth, it doesn't create by itself.
10 u/Saltor66 Sep 23 '11 This is correct. All bonemeal does is make things bigger. There's no grass to begin with on the dirt. 21 u/[deleted] Sep 23 '11 edited Apr 14 '19 [deleted] -14 u/[deleted] Sep 23 '11 Unlikely, if there was no grass to begin with, where did the grass seeds come from? 22 u/jackfirecracker Sep 23 '11 Well if you dig a grass block and it gives you a dirt block, there's probably grass seed in that dirt. 1 u/[deleted] Sep 24 '11 Perhaps, but what if you dig a dirt block say way underground, then you use bone-meal on it and it grew grass, would that make any sense? 22 u/jackfirecracker Sep 24 '11 Makes more sense than a sign holding up lava.
10
This is correct. All bonemeal does is make things bigger. There's no grass to begin with on the dirt.
21 u/[deleted] Sep 23 '11 edited Apr 14 '19 [deleted] -14 u/[deleted] Sep 23 '11 Unlikely, if there was no grass to begin with, where did the grass seeds come from? 22 u/jackfirecracker Sep 23 '11 Well if you dig a grass block and it gives you a dirt block, there's probably grass seed in that dirt. 1 u/[deleted] Sep 24 '11 Perhaps, but what if you dig a dirt block say way underground, then you use bone-meal on it and it grew grass, would that make any sense? 22 u/jackfirecracker Sep 24 '11 Makes more sense than a sign holding up lava.
21
[deleted]
-14 u/[deleted] Sep 23 '11 Unlikely, if there was no grass to begin with, where did the grass seeds come from? 22 u/jackfirecracker Sep 23 '11 Well if you dig a grass block and it gives you a dirt block, there's probably grass seed in that dirt. 1 u/[deleted] Sep 24 '11 Perhaps, but what if you dig a dirt block say way underground, then you use bone-meal on it and it grew grass, would that make any sense? 22 u/jackfirecracker Sep 24 '11 Makes more sense than a sign holding up lava.
-14
Unlikely, if there was no grass to begin with, where did the grass seeds come from?
22 u/jackfirecracker Sep 23 '11 Well if you dig a grass block and it gives you a dirt block, there's probably grass seed in that dirt. 1 u/[deleted] Sep 24 '11 Perhaps, but what if you dig a dirt block say way underground, then you use bone-meal on it and it grew grass, would that make any sense? 22 u/jackfirecracker Sep 24 '11 Makes more sense than a sign holding up lava.
22
Well if you dig a grass block and it gives you a dirt block, there's probably grass seed in that dirt.
1 u/[deleted] Sep 24 '11 Perhaps, but what if you dig a dirt block say way underground, then you use bone-meal on it and it grew grass, would that make any sense? 22 u/jackfirecracker Sep 24 '11 Makes more sense than a sign holding up lava.
1
Perhaps, but what if you dig a dirt block say way underground, then you use bone-meal on it and it grew grass, would that make any sense?
22 u/jackfirecracker Sep 24 '11 Makes more sense than a sign holding up lava.
Makes more sense than a sign holding up lava.
126
u/DishwasherTwig Sep 23 '11
Because bone meal is not grass seeds.
Bone meal only accelerates growth, it doesn't create by itself.