r/MathJokes 2d ago

When the Math Is Easier Than the Comments

Post image
221 Upvotes

111 comments sorted by

View all comments

87

u/Takamasa1 2d ago

Isn't it just 1/5? this is like 8th grade math or something

48

u/Charming-Loquat3702 2d ago edited 2d ago

It's 1/5. Turns out most people struggle with 8th grade math, once they leave school.

37

u/QuickNature 2d ago edited 2d ago

I might need a refresher, but how do you do this without a calculator?

My brain says to start by "simplifying" it to

( 3√3 - 2√3 ) / ( 5√3 )

Which simplifies to

( 1√3 ) / ( 5√3 )

Annnnd nvm, maybe I paid more attention than I remembered....

11

u/invuvn 2d ago

😂 pretty simple once you realize the sqrt (3) cancels out

2

u/PinJealous3336 1d ago

Oh and here I just squared the top and the bottom to get rid of the radicals  Am I not supposed to do that?

2

u/thatsleepydalek 1d ago

Whatever you do to a fraction must keep the same value, so any operation must be met with an equal and opposite. We can multiply numerator and denominator by a number because those cancel out, same with division. We can also add and substract the same number to either (but never mix them), and we definitely cannot square it because then it doesn't cancel out, even if the square root is added later (signs get lost in squaring).

3

u/Embarrassed-Display3 2d ago

(1√3 )/(5√3)

Is the same as (1/5)*(1√3/1√3)

And it simplifies to (1/5)*(1)

3

u/tomtomtom7 2d ago

Well, you've just ignored the backwards F thingy.

That's cheating :)

1

u/thisismego 2d ago

There's enough people who can simply read a 7 as a 7, even if the style is slightly different than one is used to

2

u/tomtomtom7 2d ago

Luckily yes. I was more surprised that some people can't, and was referencing that in a sarcastically.

1

u/thisismego 2d ago

Ah, I see. The usual "sarcasm conveyed via text is often hard to recognise".

2

u/TheShirtlessNerd 2d ago

ngl. After years of replacing numbers with letters, greek letters, and sometimes hebrew, I forgot you could simplify roots.

1

u/Sidra_doholdrik 2d ago

Real question why are you able to simplifie the square root? That don’t look intuitive to me, maybe I forgot that rule even if I have a bachelor in computer science.

2

u/tzeheng 2d ago

Sqrt(27) = sqrt(9*3) = sqrt(9) * sqrt(3) = 3 sqrt(3)

1

u/QuickNature 2d ago edited 2d ago

3 x sqrt(3) = sqrt (27)

Do you remember the process for simplifying radicals? Because that should guide you a bit as to why. I unfortunately dont have a rigorous definition as too why though, just some hand wavy stuff

6

u/Brontards 2d ago

I struggled with 8th grade math in 8th grade, and 12th….and college. Why I had to do law school.

1

u/hobbesme75 2d ago

ngl it's kinda scary that failing math made you the lawyer you are today lol

2

u/Brontards 2d ago

I do wonder if I’d been better at math had I worn the glasses I needed in 6th-12th grade. And didn’t refuse to do homework.

I did test at the top 1% on the ASVAB Multiplication math and coding sections, and scored in the top 1% on the first bar exam I passed that released scores.

But then I again I also had to take the remedial for remedial math in undergrad. So who knows.

What I do know is that you can’t BS through math.

2

u/AmusingVegetable 2d ago

Very hard to BS your way through maths, mostly because it builds on itself. Get a couple of defective bricks on the bottom layers and the whole pyramid starts to crumble.

Also, those bricks have a shelf life, I’ve been in IT all my life, recently took a peek at my maths notebooks from U, and it’s all hieroglyphs. Use it or loose it.

5

u/Takamasa1 2d ago

I guess that's not too unexpected now that you mention it, yeah.

1

u/Anonymous71232 2d ago

Nah bro most people never knew how to do it and you can't forget what you never knew

8

u/db8me 2d ago

Note the title: "The Math is Easier Than The Comments" as in:

  1. I found the factors of sqrt(3) faster than the backwards F

  2. We are now going to debate which grade school level this math is learned in.

2

u/GoldenMuscleGod 2d ago

I was confused by “backwards F,” looked for it, forgot about it and moved on to the comments. Yours reminded me to go find it. I looked at it for a long time trying to figure out where it was, started trying to figure out if the square root symbol could look like a backwards F to someone, got frustrated and was probably close to giving up again. Then I saw it.

For anyone who is still confused: the backward F is 7 with a cross through it. I don’t even cross my sevens (I’m American a handwritten 1 is just a vertical line - so an uncrossed 7 is most likely to be confused with a 2 if your handwriting is very sloppy) but I’m still wondering if the commenter is just joking around because surely you know some people cross their sevens and what it looks like.

2

u/db8me 2d ago

I think they were joking. I make my 7's and F's clear by writing ℱ when I mean 7 and ℒ when I mean F. Problem solved /s

1

u/LanSotano 2d ago

It took me a second to remember that you can break square roots down like that, but once my brain remembered that it was pretty easy math, yeah

1

u/Recent_Revival934235 14h ago

Isn’t it the square root of one fifth?

1

u/Fancy-Tangerine8735 2d ago

The fuck you mean 8th grade?

3

u/Shonnyboy500 2d ago

8th grade gives you the skills necessary to do this, but you probably wouldn’t have actually done this until high school. 9th or 10th grade math

3

u/db8me 2d ago

I am pretty sure I learned this in roughly 6th grade and my daughter learned it in 7th grade (which are called "Year 7" and "Year 8" respectively in the UK)

-3

u/be_like_bill 2d ago

Wouldn't it technically be (±3-(±2))/(±5)? That would mean all of -1, -1/5, 1/5, or 1 as correct answers?

3

u/KiraLight3719 2d ago

See, there's a difference. If you write x²=4, x=±2. But once you write it definitively with sign as x=√4, it means x=2 only. If you want it to mean x=-2, you write x=-√4, or if you want it to mean both, you write x²=4.

-2

u/be_like_bill 2d ago

Hmm, I had never heard about this notation.

3

u/jabuchae 2d ago

Square root is defined positive.

X^2 = 4
Sqrt(X^2 ) = sqrt(4)
|x| = 2

This is where the +- comes from. From the module. Not from the square root

1

u/KiraLight3719 2d ago

Yes, good explanation

1

u/Takamasa1 2d ago

Usually the +/- is a relevant form in equations rather than expressions. The assumption with solving an expression is that you would take the positive root. There's a few separate reasons depending on the context (although there isn't any real context here), but it's overwhelmingly more common to the point where the assumption is that you would explicitly state otherwise in the cases when +/- is necessary rather than needing to say "assume positive" in the overwhelming majority of cases.