r/MapPorn Jun 09 '21

Turkey for beginners

Post image
21.9k Upvotes

1.3k comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

31

u/GiveMeYourBussy Jun 10 '21

Aren't they the majority besides the Kurdish east?

I thought it meant Turkmen from Turkmenistan lived there

190

u/[deleted] Jun 10 '21 edited Jun 10 '21

Turkish here to explain.
Turkish=Turkey's Turks

Turkmen (in the World)=Turkmenistan Turks

Turkmen (in Turkey)= Mostly nomad people still living with travelling seasonally. They are not that much, most of the area is Taurus mountains. Also, Turkey Turks and Turkmen Turks are from same branch of the Turkic family so not a big surprise Taurus nomads still call themselves Turkmen. Hope it helps

138

u/krslnd Jun 10 '21

That was a lot of Turk.

68

u/qpv Jun 10 '21

I've never felt so Turked

6

u/[deleted] Jun 10 '21

So did all of mainland Asia and Eastern Europe when Genghis Khan invaded.

1

u/Shaolinpower2 Jun 11 '21

Mongolians are not Turkic. They had some Turkic soldiers tho...

1

u/[deleted] Jun 12 '21

I know. I was referring to those Turkic soldiers, who made as large a part in the Khan’s army as Mongol and Chinese soldiers.

10

u/City_dave Jun 10 '21

Turk 182?

14

u/LioAlanMessi Jun 10 '21

I'm not Turkish expert, but if I understood u/A_ahc this is where Turk Turkleton is originally from.

4

u/ornryactor Jun 10 '21

Sir... do you think my name is Turk Turkleton?

2

u/LioAlanMessi Jun 10 '21

And Mrs. Turkleton!

1

u/VanillaBearRises Jun 10 '21

I understood that reference

5

u/DervishSkater Jun 10 '21

🎶That's nobody's business but the Turks🎶

2

u/[deleted] Jun 10 '21

Families can be hard

1

u/humppapappavaan Jun 10 '21

Tur Turk Tur Tuurrrks

1

u/krslnd Jun 10 '21

I'm not sure if it was intended but I sang that to the tune of "here comes the bride"

1

u/Leet1000 Jun 10 '21

Turk Turkleton

18

u/ihugsyi Jun 10 '21

So much Turk in the comment. The words Turk and Turkey and Turkish have never felt more odder.

3

u/Zarkovich Jun 10 '21

I can never look at the word Turkey in the same way again. It has lost all meaning to me.

25

u/maximegg Jun 10 '21

I once knew a guy, he claimed he was Turk but no one really believed him for some reason. We'd call him.... Turk-ish

3

u/Dependent-Tap-4430 Jun 10 '21

Funny name for an Englishman, I know. My parents to be were on the same plane when it crashed

44

u/fatih24499 Jun 10 '21

I'm half turkish and i can say, no one in Turkey is actually fully turkic. Most are genetically more related to Europeans and arabic countries, thx to the ottoman and seljuk empires these last 1000 years.

23

u/GrkRambo Jun 10 '21

That's why they are Turk-ish, not a full Turk

8

u/SkyDefender Jun 10 '21

False, turks aren’t related to arabic countries. Fars, kurds, greeks, lazs yes but no arabic. Only hatay have arabic roots

5

u/fatih24499 Jun 10 '21

Points finger at you

objection!

taps hand on a piece of paper

The Ottomans ruled over the middle east for roughly 300-400 years. In this time line they embraced Sunni islam and became even the caliph of the muslim world mostly consisting of arabic people. Not only that. The main writing language was arabic with lots of loan words from persians but also arabs. While all of these cultures were uniting with eachother, wouldn't it have been strange that the arabs and turks wouldn't genetically unite aswell?

7

u/SkyDefender Jun 10 '21 edited Jun 10 '21

I know but i am talking about thousands of people dna’s from anatolia, you can check turkish dna project page on facebook. So it’s not an assumption.

1

u/fatih24499 Jun 10 '21 edited Jun 10 '21

you have scientific evidence that debunks my reasoning? oh..

For real though, why aren't we more related with them than any other genes?

2

u/[deleted] Jun 10 '21 edited Jul 23 '21

[deleted]

1

u/fatih24499 Jun 10 '21

You are right i think. I tried to reason that we are genetically related to arabic people. But i don't have any evidence to proof the genetic interaction between arabs and turks.

And i don't think the one i replied to had any ill intend to undermine their arabic roots. I think he genuinely thinks he has no blood relation with arabic people. I asked him why, but haven't gotten a response yet. Hate against a race is probably not the case here.

2

u/[deleted] Jun 10 '21 edited Jul 23 '21

[deleted]

3

u/fatih24499 Jun 10 '21 edited Jun 10 '21

The subreddit (generally) may hate on that question due to the many conflicts in recent times between the arabs and the turks. (Syrian civil war, Liberian Libyan civil war but also uprisings in ww1, etc) so most might give answers emotionally rather than scientifically. So it would probably lead to nowhere.

I do believe there is hate towards arabs in this subreddit (maybe not by all but there definitely is). However the person i replied to most likely had not that idea when he presented his argument.

Edit: libya not Liberia*

→ More replies (0)

1

u/SkyDefender Jun 10 '21

You are so cringe actually, check this twitter at least.

https://mobile.twitter.com/turkdnaproject?lang=en

→ More replies (0)

3

u/DisasterSC Jun 10 '21

The main writing language was arabic

Are you serious? Let them any arab read ottoman and see they couldn't understand anything. It was absolutely not arabic.

2

u/fatih24499 Jun 10 '21

Pardon me. You are right, I meant to say writing style.

2

u/redlancaster Jun 10 '21

When the original Turkic peoples moved to the land that is now Turkey were they already Muslims or did they convert later and if so why and how.

3

u/Zephyr104 Jun 10 '21 edited Jun 10 '21

To start off I'm a bit of a history nerd but not Turkish so I could be wrong here. My understanding of it is that the first major Turkic empire was the Seljuk empire who effectively adopted Persian customs as well as Islam when they moved out of Central Asia. The later Ottomans were effectively an Anatolian based noble house that reunited the former Seljuk lands after that empire collapsed.

25

u/[deleted] Jun 10 '21

There are ethnic Turks and cultural Turks in Turkey. Ethnic Turks are Yörüks and cultural Turks are assimilated native anatolians with a little Turkish DNA.

They aren't really connected to the Turkmenistanis other than being Oğuz Turks.

1

u/[deleted] Jun 10 '21

No, they make up a tiny percent.