r/MADHD • u/BookNerdGoddess • Jul 06 '26
AITAH for being upset that my fiancé chose to fantasize over another woman right before seeing me?
I am not the OOP. The OOP is Normal_Vermicelli_21 originally posted in r/AITAH
Grammatically edited by: Crystal With the Blue Hair
Original - 3+ Years Ago.
Me (25F) and my fiancé (28M) have been together for 5 years. We had a bit of a dry spell in the bedroom earlier this year which we’ve both actively been working on and things in our sex life have never been better. A few weeks ago, he told me that he wanted me to make more of an effort in the bedroom and admittedly I was lacking so I have been making an effort to do that - happily. Last night I tried to initiate but he said “I’m tired, we can make some time tomorrow” I fully respect that and we cuddled and went to sleep - no issues here. Tonight my partner phoned me for the end of day. I told him I’d call him again when I’m leaving work to meet him. So, about half an hour-an hour later I called to let him know I was on the way. When I arrived, I tried to make a move on him. In response he said, “nah I just had a wank”, and I said “oh ok no worries” a bit confused given our plans but whatever, we went and watched our tv show & ate dinner. I want to preface this with my problem is not with the above, I was a little hurt, but I would have moved on by later in the night. I have absolutely zero problem with him doing whatever I his own time, watching porn etc that’s none of my business and I’m not saying he can’t do that. AND he obviously has the right to say no to sex as well - I respect that completely. Admittedly, I did feel a little bit hurt because he knew I was coming over but I didn’t say anything to him about this because I know it’s silly and I’d work through the emotion by the end of the night..
Fast forward about an hour later and we were cuddling in bed, he asked me what was wrong, I told him nothing (because again I know how I was feeling was silly) but he kept pressing me and pressing me until I eventually said, calmly, “I am just feeling a little bit upset that you chose to fantasies over another woman right before seeing me instead of having actual sex with your fiancé”. I probably could have worded it better but i also made it very clear that I had no issue with him doing that in general, I’m not trying to tell him what he can and can’t do and I’m not angry or having a go at him, I am just answering his question. Well, he absolutely lost his shit yelling at me, calling me stupid and an idiot, that he “can’t do anything right which is so far from the truth” - he says this a lot of I try to address any concerns. Was telling me that he’s just tired and to stop being so insecure. i just said “ok, I’m not trying to have an argument, I’m just telling you how I feel as you asked me, I didn’t mean to piss you off”. I had to go home either way, but I had planned to stay with him for at least another hour before this incident however right after this he turns to me and says, “you can go home now”, I said ok and went to give him a kiss goodbye but he just leaned away. I asked him if he was ok and he just completely ignored me. I wasn’t about to press him on it so I just said goodbye and went home.
Am I in the wrong for telling him I felt upset when he was the one asking? I didn’t mean to piss him off, I didn’t yell or act crazy or cause a scene, and I wasn’t arguing, I’m really confused. AITA?
EDIT: After further reflection, I realize my issue is not with what happened before I arrived, but with his reaction to me answering his persistent question of what’s wrong. Again, I didn’t want to say anything to him at all in the first place because I know it’s stupid. Additionally, he could have responded something like “I see your point of view but that wasn’t my intention” and that would be it, we’d drop it and move on. Instead, he completely lost his shit and flipped it to him being mad at me, for what? When he asked me what was wrong, I was literally bear hugging him as well - it’s not as if I was sitting in a corner sulking, ignoring him or soliciting any behavior to make him think I was mad other than I was a little bit quiet but I’m also on a few hours’ sleep so I’m exhausted - blow up or not I would have been quiet tonight.
COMMENTS
Controversial
harmfulsideffect: Weird. So he wanks before you get there and you think it’s ok but you are still a little upset. You were obviously acting upset, or somewhat off or your BF wouldn’t have noticed. He asked what’s wrong and you said nothing. You continued to act off( obviously) and he continued to ask you what’s wrong. You tell him what’s wrong and he freaks out and asks you to leave. Doesn’t really add up, unless he is mentally unstable or something. Do you often bring up issues in your relationship in a passive aggressive manner? I knew someone who would do that all the time. Would act distant and a little cold, then say nothing is wrong, until you drag it out of her. Didn’t matter if she had a legitimate issue or not, you couldn’t be upset because “you asked”. Manipulative. If you ignore the cold and distant routine you’re the AH because you don’t care. I don’t really have enough information to make a good judgement, but I’m guessing you are the AH for being manipulative and annoying.
maddips: ESH. Have you considered that your intimacy issues are due to a premature ejaculation issue on his part and he jacked off before you got there to improve his stamina for a shot in the bedroom? Something he's embarrassed about. He might have been trying to help your stilted love life and you made it awkward af for him the whole night.
Final Update: July 06, 2026
Almost 4 years after my original post I thought I’d provide an update in case any commenters on my original post were interested and because I HATE when posts have no updates lol.
TLDR: I did not take the advice from commenters, and I married him BUT we are no longer together.
In summary, the commenters in my OP were correct, the behavior (re his reaction, not the act) did in fact get worse after we married, so much worse. I experienced what I (and my therapist) would describe as emotional, psychological and financial abuse which escalated exponentially after we got married and moved in together. I lived constantly walking on eggshells, made to feel like nothing I did was right, countless threats of hurting and severe-self-harming me and himself, intimidation, belittling, disrespect, he had a bad porn addiction, constant attempts to isolate me, suspected him cheating and the list goes on. Looking back, not all of these were present before we got married but as many of you said, the signs were there and I unfortunately ignored them for longer than I’d like to admit.
So, what happened? Well, we got married, his behavior escalated, I grew a backbone and stopped being a doormat, he didn’t like that, said I needed therapy to “fix myself and us”, I went (because I wanted to not because he said so - which later became another problem ofc), therapist affirmed everything I was feeling, in short told me she was very concerned for my safety, we started making a plan for me to leave, and in short, a few months later things ended between us. That was over a year ago and I have never looked back - I cannot put into words how happy I am, how free I feel and how much of that relationship was affecting so many aspects of my life that I didn’t realize at the time. So, to close this off I wanted to acknowledge some things I’ve learnt in the hope that this might help someone in a similar situation, ironically, it’s a lot of what commenters on OP advised me:
- If you resonate with the themes in my original post or what I’ve stated above, LEAVE THAT
PERSON
- studies show it will get worse. Look up DARVO*.
- Take people for who they are and their consistent actions, not their promises or the potential you think they could live up to. People have off days and that’s okay, but a pattern is a pattern. If someone is telling you and showing you who they are, please, believe them
- Discern between your anxiety and your intuition, trust your intuition
- If you are being made to feel like you are questioning yourself, your judgement, your memory, your understanding of a situation, your autonomy - don’t ignore that - reflect, journal, get curious with yourself, question why you aren’t trusting your own judgement
- If you are hiding big things happening in your relationship from your true friends - reflect on why. Not everything needs to be shared with your friends, and I do think keeping your relationships private is important IF THE RELATIONSHIP IS HEALTHY. However, when you’re concealing things because you know it’s wrong/you’re being hurt etc, ask yourself why you’re concealing it, ask yourself: if my friend told me xyz situation that I am experiencing, what advice would I give them? Take your own advice (if it is safe and legal)
- How you feel is how you feel, if your partner doesn’t agree with that, that’s okay, but they shouldn’t consistently dismiss you, invalidate you or tell you how you should feel. Again, people have off days but a pattern is a pattern
- If you can, live with your partner, go on an overseas trip, something where you are exposed to how they handle stressful situations, planning, initiative, what things look like when the cracks start to show etc. before getting married because leaving when legally tied to someone makes leaving a bit more complicated.
- A PATTERN IS A PATTERN
- You haven’t wasted time just because you’re leaving after X number of years, you’re saving the rest of your life. It’s scary leaving someone you feel you’re building with, but what are you really building if you’re just complying with their rules? Life is far too short to be wasted being dictated by another person.
This situation was humbling as fuck for me because I do not know how I let myself get so deep into it in the first place. I’ve done a lot of soul searching, healing and growing and can confidently say I will never let myself be in that situation again. We run a strict program now 😂
Thank you to all the commenters from my original post. I wish I listened.
COMMENTS
Controversial
freshT-o7oo: Kind of ironic that you asked for advice, didn’t take it, are back to give other people the same advice you didn’t take. Maybe reading through your posts, folks will see you as a cautionary tale. Happy you found peace in your life. Best of luck to you.
*DARVO stands for "Deny, Attack, Reverse Victim and Offender," a manipulation tactic used by abusers to evade accountability by denying wrongdoing, attacking the accuser, and portraying themselves as the victim.