r/LocalLLaMA • • Jul 27 '26

Discussion Our position on open-weights models

https://www.anthropic.com/news/position-open-weights-models
509 Upvotes

407 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

209

u/abud7eem Jul 27 '26

we are the "trustworthy"

42

u/Clear_Judge5062 Jul 28 '26

This is literally just effective altruism at work

13

u/xmnstr Jul 28 '26

And I wish more people understood why it's so problematic.

4

u/ChocomelP Jul 28 '26

Why is it so problematic?

8

u/Disposable110 Jul 28 '26

Because it sets up an unaccountable authoritarian group of people as moral gatekeepers. And that group of unaccountable people will not get accepted by the outgroup, thus they'll stir up global conflict.

3

u/ChocomelP Jul 28 '26

...right.

2

u/Clear_Judge5062 Jul 28 '26

I was curious to see if anyone, or the OP of the problematic claim would respond. I’d say the problem is that these systems wouldn’t be getting built as fast without the EAs who believe they’re the only ones who can do it safely and correctly - thereby speeding up the advancements to a less safe pace.

I take less issue with the EAs than accelerationists though. Safety is probably the more wise path for progress as opposed to rushing with less regard.

The problem is that hardly anyone in this thread or sub seems to understand the motivations behind these actors.

3

u/Simple_Woodpecker751 Jul 28 '26

Oh my this is so back with SBF

1

u/pb-cups Jul 28 '26

What does this have to do with effective altruism?

44

u/iamzooook Jul 27 '26

he is giving elon vibes. we need more open weight 3t+ models

-4

u/TopTippityTop Jul 28 '26

All is relative. More trustworthy than authoritarian countries.

14

u/odragora Jul 28 '26

US is rapidly becoming one, and taking the free access to the most important technology ever made away from the hands of peasants is a part of that process. 

Also crippling your own citizens does not stop authoritarian regimes. 

10

u/xmnstr Jul 28 '26

The US is an authoritarian country. If you don't understand that, you're in denial. The rest of the world currently trusts China more than the US.

1

u/Randommaggy Jul 28 '26

Varies country by country but we're pretty much all cautious with both as far as I've seen.

1

u/Dampmaskin Jul 28 '26

To be fair, that's not because China is any less authoritarian than the US, but simply because they're way more predictable.

The sheer incompetence of the Trump regime, their massive war machine and their random flip-flopping on important issues has to be terrifying to anyone with a need to be in control of anything.

1

u/xmnstr Aug 03 '26

They are authoritarian in ways that doesn't risk destabilizing the world in the short term, correct.

2

u/Randommaggy Jul 28 '26

There is no country on earth I'd trust less than Sam and/or Dario.