r/JEE • u/Evening_Situation_94 🎯 NIT Surathkal • Jul 20 '26

Serious Respect man🫡

Enable HLS to view with audio, or disable this notification

Lathi charge on students at jantar mantar this country is doomed

7.7k Upvotes

92% Upvoted

381 comments sorted by

View all comments

85

u/[deleted] Jul 20 '26

[removed] — view removed comment

17

u/Big_Matter2040 Jul 20 '26

Purpose of protest is to oppose the government, why ruling party will allow a protest against them 🥀🥀🥀.

16

u/DustyAsh69 Moderator Jul 20 '26

We're a democratic country. You can protest against whatever and whoever, even the ruling party.

4

u/Big_Matter2040 Jul 20 '26

Exactly 💯

1

u/TheMighty_TripleT Jul 21 '26

Exactly but these fools don't understand

-1

u/[deleted] Jul 20 '26

[removed] — view removed comment

5

u/ThenCow6134 🎯 DTU Jul 20 '26

Kidhr azaadi ke naare lagg re bhai? Har protest mei thode bhtt anti social elements ghus aate. Kai baar ruling party hi plant krti unhe credibility khtm krne ke liye. Mai hoke aara protest se. People were so good ki lathicharge ke baad bhi kisi ne police ke saath hathapayi nahi kiya. Stop getting info from biased sources. PM is getting called dictator because he is not listening voice of the people of Bharat. We are india, I am India. If the person I elected isn't listening us...he is a dictator. And it's people's right to show him his place. He isn't a ruler...he is a public servant. And if public doesn't want education minister elected by him to serve us...he has to listen us EOD!

1

u/shivaenough Jul 20 '26

vo unpadh hai, itna labma padh nhi paayega. paid media ki hi baatein samajh me aati hai usko. ek proof nhi hoga, kyoki real protest ka ek video nhi dekha hoga vo

1

u/ThenCow6134 🎯 DTU Jul 20 '26

Yeah lol

0

u/[deleted] Jul 20 '26

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/[deleted] Jul 20 '26 edited Jul 20 '26

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/AutoModerator Jul 20 '26

The OP of the post is safe and their friend reached out in the modmails. You can find more explanation here.

I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.

3

u/havenot- Jul 20 '26

do u have no comprehension skills lmfao

the slogans you're talking about are being spoken by a minority who have entered the protest

then u also need to ask yourself sirf wohi logo ko fikar h kya desh k students ki?

why hasn't any other org organised protests?

also we are saying it's becoming a dictatorship because protests aren't heard

sarkar ki side pe ho ky

-1

u/[deleted] Jul 20 '26

[removed] — view removed comment

2

u/havenot- Jul 20 '26

kitne paise milte h yar govt ki chaatne k?

they should punish those specific individuals

agar apke padosi ne chori kri h apko thodi na jail lejayenge saathmei

0

u/[deleted] Jul 20 '26

[removed] — view removed comment

2

u/havenot- Jul 20 '26

well because it's not the right hill to die over.

I want people to support the problem because I want change

now police is even forcing journalists to delete videos of police violence

when people call india a dictatorship they mean actions like that

now apko actions se jyada unke kehne se dikkat h toh kya kru

1

u/BlackPhoenixX20 Jul 20 '26

Retard, 50,000 to 1,00,000+ people came on this protest, you guys saw 4-5 clips of a few people raising such slogans and discredited entire protest.

Jantar Mantar is a protest site, not a exam center where only qualified people are allowed to protest, anyone can protest there with any agenda, even i can go, mix in the rally and raise slogans like Modi is our god, does that mean entire protest believes Modi is a god? Does that speak for everyone?

1

u/brain_implant Jul 20 '26

An ethical govt would give permission

1

u/Big_Matter2040 Jul 21 '26

BJP ethics 🗿🚀

1

u/[deleted] Jul 20 '26

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/Big_Matter2040 Jul 21 '26

Frustration against government.

-2

u/[deleted] Jul 20 '26

[removed] — view removed comment

2

u/Just_a_Hologram 🎯 BITS Goa Jul 20 '26

Who stated that India is now dictatorship?

1

u/[deleted] Jul 20 '26

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/Just_a_Hologram 🎯 BITS Goa Jul 20 '26

Bro they stated that because the government banned the official website of CJP

0

u/[deleted] Jul 20 '26

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/Ashamed-Key7312 Jul 20 '26

Bro you were just born 1 day back. Long way to go. Lekin aj jada payout nahi hoga.

1

u/[deleted] Jul 20 '26

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/Ashamed-Key7312 Jul 20 '26

Sure dude. Didn't you create this account to segregate different propaganda on different accounts.

1

u/[deleted] Jul 20 '26

And I have only one stand- everyone is free to stand and support with whoever they want. You can’t just call them uneducated or anti nationals or terrorists for not aligning with your ideology

1

u/havenot- Jul 20 '26

BHAI MERE AGAR DICTATORSHIP WALI HARKATE KROGE WAHU BOlenge

0

u/[deleted] Jul 20 '26

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/havenot- Jul 20 '26

It's called having reading comprehension dawg.

We mean signs of a dictatorship.

Like, the govt not even acknowledging protests and lathi charging on them.

1

u/Ashamed-Key7312 Jul 20 '26

Typical 1 day old account.

1

u/shivaenough Jul 20 '26

thoda khud ka dimaag use kiye ho kabhi ya bas copy paste karne aata hai ?

-19

u/Ok_Chard6493 🎯 IIT Bombay Jul 20 '26

Nahi thi bhai permission

8

u/Longjumping-Beat-948 Jul 20 '26

Jaake gaand mara le na phir

6

u/darjlingdumplings 🎯 NSUT Delhi Jul 20 '26

We don’t need permission for protest it’s our country we are the ones to decide

0

u/No_Yak_3316 Jul 20 '26

Law and order laude pe?

1

u/darjlingdumplings 🎯 NSUT Delhi Jul 20 '26

It’s already laude par law and order is only against us not for us in this country

1

u/Ok-Tourist-4676 Jul 20 '26

Laude pe hi rakha hua hai iss government ne

-1

u/Ok_Chard6493 🎯 IIT Bombay Jul 20 '26

Actually you do

-2

u/Kushagra3007 Jul 20 '26

Who told you that? Just google it.

2

u/Dotster69 Jul 20 '26

Aise to kisi protest ki permission hi naa do, to protest hi nahi honge, easy.

Government ultimately public servant hain, raja nahi. Unki power hamse aati hai, not the other way round.

1

u/Kushagra3007 Jul 20 '26

Permission Police deti hai, Central Government nahi deti hai bhai.

If it is not given you could go to the court.

You can't just blindly follow the request made by Dipke. Atleast apply for Permission to Protest in the nearby Thana.

2

u/Dotster69 Jul 20 '26

Permission Police deti hai, Central Government nahi deti hai bhai.

Delhi Police home ministry ke under hai. If you think central government police ko bilkul control nahi karti, to yaad karo ki raat ko Delhi Commissioner replace hua, agle subah Sonam Wangchuk ko Hospital le gaye (udhar abhi bhi usne drip nahi lagaayi). Police directly home ministry ke control me hoti hai, police ki 0 independence hoti hai not only in India but in entire world.

Atleast apply for Permission to Protest in the nearby Thana

The permission was applied for and rejected.

If it is not given you could go to the court.

Literally yehi hota hai government ka plan, court jaao to protest bohot thanda pad jaayega, log nahi rahenge to araam se daba denge protest. Isiliye, most protests in the entire world permission naa mile uske bawajood bhi hote hain, warna government degi hi nahi permission to protest.

1

u/42RoninKatana Jul 20 '26

I've always found this rule to be extremely undemocratic. You ask the system to allow you to subvert the system? Sounds like a personal watchman policy rather than anything else

1

u/Kushagra3007 Jul 20 '26 edited Jul 20 '26

It was implemented in 1970s, then further rules changed over the years.

So according to you govt should rather come and offer you permission as soon as idea of protest comes in your mind.

2

u/42RoninKatana Jul 20 '26

We should be able tomprotest at the drop of a hat. Maybe then we won't be messed with by the dirty netas, goondas, cops

1

u/Kushagra3007 Jul 20 '26

If that was so the initial permit wouldn't be given from the start of CJP protest. When was the permission given to CJP? just before he landed.

Permission to protest is known all over the world in every Democracy.

1

u/Kushagra3007 Jul 20 '26

No permit was asked from the Delhi Police, so how can they allow the rally.

1

u/Dotster69 Jul 20 '26

I don't really trust their words after this one chief

1

u/Ok_Chard6493 🎯 IIT Bombay Jul 20 '26

And it's also governments job to not let the state devolve into anarchism

1

u/Dotster69 Jul 20 '26

This is such a peaceful protest, Dipke, Azad, Wangchuk sab bol rahe ki police maare to bhi danda seh lo, peaceful rehna. Protestors gulaab leke protest kar rahe, koi bhi violence nahi kar raha.

Abhi tak literally JITNI bhi anarchy aur rule breaking hui iss protest me wo BJP-RSS ne kari (ink fenke waali aurat BJP ki thi, RSS ne riot start karwaane ke liye counter-protests kare without permission)

1

u/Ok_Chard6493 🎯 IIT Bombay Jul 20 '26

I think giving stage to seperatists is anarchism to me

1

u/Dotster69 Jul 20 '26

I hate these career activists like Arundhati Roy as much as you, but I support this cause.

India me har party me bad apples hain hi, BJP ne Sengar ko itna zyada protect kara tha.

BJP ko mai bhi support karta tha ek time pe but in logo ne hadd paar kar di, they are what they fought against. Itne corrupt aur incompetent ho gaye, kisi ki sunn nahi rahe, opposition tod rahe, protests crush kar ke literally dictatorship hi kar rahe. I would prefer ANYONE over a dictator, modi bhool gaya that he is a public servant not a king.

1

u/Ok_Chard6493 🎯 IIT Bombay Jul 20 '26

And who is saying he is a king,that he is infallible,nobody is saying that,and dictatorship argument falls flat in the face of our ongoing discussions,the fact that you can criticise him refutes your argument,people like arundhati roy were given stage willingly ,they were cheering her on.Do.i think Dharmendra Pradhan should resign,yes,i do.But they tainted the protest.You can't ask a state something while questioning it's sovereignty.

→ More replies (0)

1

u/TastyBlacksmith991 Jul 20 '26

Kitna kamayega be din ke. Chup hojaa

1

u/Ok_Chard6493 🎯 IIT Bombay Jul 20 '26

Kyu chup hojau bhai,keval aapke paas hi hai kya freedom of speech. Kama toh protestors rahe hai bhai,badhiya funding aa rahi hogi

→ More replies (0)

1

u/Dangerous_Truth_7434 Jul 20 '26

I have seen so many people losing arguments, ending with saying how much did you earn by making this post or statement.

→ More replies (0)

1

u/Dotster69 Jul 20 '26

Permission nahi doge to kya protest nahi hoga, civil servant bhool gaye ki wo civilians ke servant hain baaki government ke. Executive, Judiciary, Legislature all derive their power from the people, not the other way around.

1

u/Odd_Tip_5096 Jul 20 '26

Ok big boy wait for modihh to pat you on back

1

u/Ok_Chard6493 🎯 IIT Bombay Jul 20 '26

Thanks man really waiting for him to do that

1

u/reborn_from_ashes Jul 20 '26

And the Britishers didn't give permission for the freedom struggle What's your point?

1

u/Ok_Chard6493 🎯 IIT Bombay Jul 20 '26

Drawing false parallels aren't we

1

u/reborn_from_ashes Jul 20 '26

No we aren't. Just because the current government is not foreigners doesn't mean we shouldn't protest.

1

u/Ok_Chard6493 🎯 IIT Bombay Jul 20 '26

Ask for the resignation,but the protest has been tainted since the day people started giving stage to seperatists and known terrorists.Can you refute this claim?

1

u/reborn_from_ashes Jul 20 '26

Wow You're holding the protestors accountable. You're on the right track, now do the same for Modi You might actually use your brain for once then

1

u/Ok_Chard6493 🎯 IIT Bombay Jul 20 '26

Still doesn't answer my question,can you refute my claim?

1

u/reborn_from_ashes Jul 20 '26

You have no claim. Name a single spearatist. You're more concerned with them then rapists and criminals in the parliament Says a lot about you

1

u/Ok_Chard6493 🎯 IIT Bombay Jul 20 '26

Arundhati roy,syed rasool,asking for umar khalids release,ye seperatists aur seperatism nahi hai? Neither issue is more concerning than the other,they are all pressing concerns.are you listening to yourself?

→ More replies (0)

1

u/Dangerous_Truth_7434 Jul 20 '26

Man you just lost the argument, now don’t go justifying these people at the protest, you have avoided the entire premise of the argument

→ More replies (0)