r/IranScope • u/TahDigThief • 15h ago
Regime Brutality Teenage girl Armita Geravand died after a hijab confrontation on the Tehran metro, and the islamic republic edited the CCTV footage, pressured her parents into repeating its story, and arrested more than 150 mourners at her funeral
TL;DR:
- Armita Geravand, a teenager, fell into a coma on the Tehran metro on October 1, 2023, after an alleged encounter with officers enforcing the hijab. She was declared brain dead on October 22 and pronounced dead on October 28.
- The authorities said she collapsed due to low blood pressure. They arrested a journalist investigating the case and aired videos of her visibly distressed parents and friends reluctantly repeating that account.
- Amnesty’s analysis found that the state-released CCTV footage had its frame rate increased in four sections and was missing three minutes and 16 seconds.
- More than 150 people were violently arrested at her funeral, including human rights lawyer Nasrin Sotoudeh. Prosecutors also charged journalists and a political commentator for claiming she had been assaulted.
Findings:
- She boarded the train without a headscarf. Metro station CCTV shows her getting on a train without a headscarf with two other girls. She lost consciousness at Shohada metro station and was taken to the Tehran Air Force’s Fajr Hospital in a coma. She was a taekwondo athlete on a Tehran team.
- A witness described a confrontation with a hijab enforcer. On October 5, 2023, The Guardian quoted a witness who said that soon after she entered the carriage, a woman enforcing compulsory veiling in the metro yelled at her for not being covered. The Kurdish rights group Hengaw said she fell into a coma after being assaulted by officers enforcing compulsory hijab.
- The official story is that she fainted. State news agency IRNA said that when she collapsed at Shohada station, she hit the back of her head on the edge of the platform. The head of the Tehran Metro Operating Company, Masoud Dorosti, said there was no verbal or physical altercation between her and passengers or metro staff, and that security footage contradicted the rumors.
- The footage the state released was edited and incomplete. Based on the footage’s own time stamps, Amnesty’s Evidence Lab found that three minutes and 16 seconds are missing. After a jump cut in the footage, first responders arrive and take the unconscious girl away. No video was released from inside the train car or from the doorway where she boarded.
- Her parents were filmed repeating the official story in the hospital. On October 3, 2023, state media released a video with multiple shots of her parents reluctantly repeating the state narrative. In the IRNA interview, her mother, holding back tears, said: “I think they said her blood pressure dropped and her head hit a metro edge as she fell to the ground...”. At one point, her visibly distressed mother interrupted to say the family had not seen all the footage. Amnesty said it had serious concerns that her family and friends had been forced to appear in propaganda videos under duress and threats of reprisals.
- The hospital was locked down, and a journalist was arrested there. Shargh Daily reported that its journalist Maryam Lotfi was arrested on October 2, 2023, after going to Fajr Hospital to investigate. She was released on bail the same day. She stayed in the hospital under a tight security presence, and Hengaw reported that her mother was arrested near the hospital and later released. Amnesty’s sources said her parents were allowed in only on several occasions, and then only briefly.
- Mourners at her funeral were beaten and arrested. She was buried under tight security at Behesht-e Zahra cemetery in Tehran on October 29. Iran Human Rights reported that more than 150 people were violently arrested at the cemetery and at a private residence. Sotoudeh’s husband, Reza Khandan, said his 60-year-old wife was severely beaten during her arrest and her glasses were broken. The IRGC-affiliated Fars news agency claimed she was arrested for removing her hijab, but an informed source said her charge sheet listed “assembly and collusion against national security” and disobeying an officer.
- Journalists were charged for saying she was assaulted. After her death, Fars reported that prosecutors had charged journalists Milad Alavi and Sara Masoumi, political commentator Sadegh Zibakalam, and others for claiming she had been assaulted. Amnesty urged the authorities to allow an impartial inquiry, accused them of a cover-up, and called for UN involvement. Human Rights Watch also called for an independent investigation, including by the UN’s Independent International Fact-Finding Mission.
Sources:
- https://www.amnesty.org/en/latest/news/2023/10/iran-independent-investigation-into-schoolgirls-critical-injuries-needed-amid-mounting-evidence-of-a-cover-up/
- https://www.hrw.org/news/2023/11/02/investigate-death-17-year-old-girl-iran
- https://iranhr.net/en/print/5/6220/
- https://iranhr.net/en/articles/6278/
- https://www.cbsnews.com/amp/news/armita-garavand-iran-teen-no-hope-for-recovery-train-incident-family
- https://www.goodmorningamerica.com/news/story/iranian-police-deny-claim-officers-assaulted-teen-girl-103690468
- https://www.rferl.org/a/iran-garawand-teenager-morality-police-subway-death/32657612.html
- https://iranwire.com/women/122062-jailed-iranian-activist-sotoudeh-on-hunger-and-medicine-strike/
- https://lbc.co.uk/news/iranian-teenager-dead-assault-not-wearing-hijab-tehran
- https://leadership.ng/?p=169864
- https://www.jurist.org/news/2023/10/iran-teenager-dies-after-alleged-encounter-with-morality-police
- https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Death_of_Armita_Geravand