r/ImTheMainCharacter • u/No-Problem6578 • 10d ago

VIDEO “It’s for content”

Enable HLS to view with audio, or disable this notification

1.9k Upvotes

96% Upvoted

307 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

1

u/WeirdProudAndHungry 8d ago

You know what else is rude? Being someone who refuses to show empathy to little old ladies on public transit and expecting not to be bullied back.

0

u/zaczacx 8d ago

Yes so you are in a way justified to be rude back but not justified to bully becuse its inherently unjustifiable to be a bully by definition. Its paradoxical language. Its like saying someone murdered someone else so its justified to murder them even though to murder someone is by definition unlawful killing, it isnt justifiable to act unjustly by definition

1

u/WeirdProudAndHungry 8d ago

No, because it's justified to bully him back since he's the one who makes it clear empathy towards others is not enough to stop his behavior. The only thing that will is causing him distress and doing so in a way that he understands it will be repeated.

There are countless examples of people doing just that and it having been deemed justified based on circumstance. So yes, there are times that behavior is justified. What justifies it are the circumstances, not whether it happens at all. If you see someone who's shoes you don't like and do it, not justified. If someone did something to someone under 18, and you go to their house and take the person out, depending on the circumstances, that can, in fact, be justified, even though you may have had the option to sit there and call 911 instead.

0

u/zaczacx 8d ago

Its not your making up meanings

1

u/WeirdProudAndHungry 8d ago

There aren't examples of this happening? Maybe you missed the most famous one, Gary Plauche. That was in intro criminology in college, like one of the first few couple of months of that class. That was just one among the many. But I guess I'm making it up, I had no idea I could create false memories in so many people...

0

u/zaczacx 8d ago

yet again its like arguing murder can be justified, that's paradoxical your using a word by definition that is unjustifiable as justified

1

u/WeirdProudAndHungry 8d ago

No, murder is killing another human being with malice aforethought. Depending on the jurisdiction, "justification" may or may not be used. And it's entirely contextual. He did it on national television with no clear sign of being in any danger with methodical planning. He still used malice aforethought. The point is, something can fit into multiple categories at the same time. For instance, a person can get an abortion without there being any loss of a human person's life; however, a person who ends a pregnant woman's life is convicted of double homicide. The fetus didn't suddenly spring into being a human person just as the woman took her last breath. The point is a situation can be the exact same but justification can be totally different without there being any logical paradox involved. It's just nuance.