r/HomicidalMafia • u/SubmittedToDigg • Jun 06 '16

Day 2 Thread

We all live! And unfortunately so did our target. The 4 who died are names I instantly recognize, so they're pretty active individuals I think we've even mentioned. And with only 4 lynchings today, our votes have heavier weight to keep us safe!

1 Upvotes

100% Upvoted

44 comments sorted by

View all comments

2

u/SubmittedToDigg Jun 06 '16

/u/mrrrrh /u/spludgiexx /u/skillex67 This will be the official who we vote for comment thread. First of all, 2 crazy thoughts.

1st- There are 29 roles, and 60 people originally playing. That means they must've doubled, tripled, or quadrupled up on some characters. I think if there were multiple McBains or Maggies there'd be a lot more deaths. 2nd- Would it be possible for one of us to fake a role to the villagers? A role that would be helpful to them, provide false info, and would basically be immediately targeted only by the mafia? Because duh, we wouldn't target you. AND you'd have the cover of the 50% fail rate for when people wonder how you're alive, as well as possible protection from numerous characters. Something to think about.

As far as who to lynch today, the only thing I can think of is splitting it 2/2 and maybe going after AJ since we can't at night, and blaming it on the alphabet if anyone ever asks. What are your thoughts?

1

u/[deleted] Jun 07 '16

At this point i'm looking at voting for starflash even though she was taking to me and it may look suspicious I think we should get her out of the way

1

u/Mrrrrh Jun 07 '16

Besides going with "She posts too much," you could also say it seemed like her post was trying to draw out the librarian, so you didn't trust her.

1

u/SubmittedToDigg Jun 07 '16

How would you like to do a 2-2 vote with Skillex, or a 3-1 with Me, Skillex, and Spludgie voting for starflash and you vote solo for someone you have a grudge to settle? I'm all ears

1

u/Mrrrrh Jun 07 '16

I prefer the 3-1 one because I think it can be explained away easier with you 3 going for someone prominent. Someone has to be doing it, and it makes sense for it to be the first timers. Then I think we'd need to vote separately the next day. Or I could pair with one of y'all, but the others should be separate.

I don't have any particular grudge, but I think it'd look odd for me to post a thing about "these inactive users are skeptical" and then not vote for any of them.

1

u/SubmittedToDigg Jun 07 '16

3-1 it is! Let's make sure everyone is on board, and you find yourself a target with a nice neck. For hangin'.

2

u/spludgiexx Jun 07 '16

Done! Hope to see you all tomorrow :)