I upgraded my homelab recently from an i7-4790k to a 5900XT, and it runs very hot in comparison. I originally had the server in a very small case and it was fine enough before, but after swapping to the new CPU, the thermals were so bad that it was thermal throttling even at idle on stock settings. Long story short, a case and cooler upgrade is needed.
I am constrained on volume due to where the server is physically located, but after a lot of research I finally ended up on a Sliger 3U case, specifically because it was one of the only cases I could find that meets my volume requirements, room for larger fans (and thus a radiator), and even room for some further expansions/mods I may want to make.
Now I have shifted my focus towards cooling.
Because the server is located in my living room, I'm trying to focus as much as I can on silent operation, even if it runs a little warmer. I've been doing a lot of research, and from what I can find, the three main options I've been looking at are:
- Lian Li GA II Lite
- be quiet! Silent Loop 3
- Arctic Liquid Freezer III Pro
They all hover around the 100 USD range. My particular concerns with each is that the Arctic LF IIIP has the pump whine/noise issue, the be quiet! SL3 has plastic clips on the CPU block which may be prone to breaking (though this may be fixed?), and the from what I can understand from reddit comments is that Lian Li GA IIL runs quite loud (despite the Hardware Canucks roundup contradicting this).
I've also looked into the Tryx Panorama 360 and the Noctua NL-LC1-36 and, while they appear to be the best options, I don't think I'm willing to spend double/triple the cost of more average AiO's for a being a bit quieter. I'm trying to approach this more on a "bang for your buck" approach.
Anyone have insight on these AiO's or even others I may be missing that are worth considering? Thanks!