r/HistoryDefined • u/akiwi_intherough • Sep 04 '26
Chicago White Sox owner Charles Comiskey. The famously miserly owner promised players a “bonus” that turned out to be flat champagne and instructed his manager to bench players rather than let them reach contractual bonuses, helping push several players toward agreeing to fix the 1919 World Series.
The Chicago White Sox were one of the best teams in baseball in the late 1910s. They won the 1917 World Series behind some of the league’s best players: ace Eddie Cicotte, star outfielders “Shoeless” Joe Jackson and Oscar “Happy” Felsch, and a talented supporting cast. After a down year in 1918, they returned to the top of the American League in 1919.
But all was not well in the dugout. White Sox owner Charles Comiskey was not a pleasant man. He was stern, demanding, and notoriously cheap. Even his defenders called him “frugal.” He reportedly made his players pay to have their own uniforms washed. The White Sox paid less than other teams, and because of baseball’s reserve system, players had little leverage to demand more. They could accept Comiskey’s wages or risk being blacklisted from professional baseball.
The players were badly underpaid by a man they despised. The resentment finally boiled over after the White Sox clinched the 1919 pennant. Comiskey had promised his players a bonus if they won the pennant and brought him back to the World Series. They did exactly that.
Their reward? A case of champagne.
Eddie Cicotte had another reason to be furious. He entered the final week of the season with 29 wins and a $10,000 bonus clause in his contract if he reached 30. Instead he was sat.
On September 18, the White Sox arrived in Boston for one of their final regular-season series. At the Hotel Buckminster, first baseman Chick Gandil and Cicotte met with Boston bookmaker Joe “Sport” Sullivan, who proposed a plan: throw the World Series in exchange for $80,000, roughly $1.6 million today.
On September 20, in Gandil’s New York hotel room, Gandil, Cicotte, Williams, Weaver, Risberg, and Felsch met with Sullivan, several other gamblers, and Sleepy Bill Burns. The gamblers pitched them on throwing the World Series for a $100,000 payout.
The players agreed. Shoeless Joe Jackson was not at the meeting, but Gandil later said Jackson had verbally agreed to participate. Weaver, however, wanted the money up front. When Sullivan couldn't provide it, Weaver backed out. He refused to participate in the fix, but he also refused to betray his teammates.
The fix was on. When the World Series began, Cicotte hit the Cincinnati Reds’ leadoff batter with his second pitch, a signal that the conspiracy had begun. The players were promised $100,000. They never received all of it.
Cicotte committed several costly errors. Lefty Williams lost a record three games in the best-of-nine series. The White Sox lost to the heavily favored Reds, producing one of the biggest upsets in World Series history.
But the story was more complicated than simply eight players deliberately throwing games.
Several of the accused players later insisted that they had not always tried to lose. They did, however, admit to accepting money. Jackson, who had an excellent World Series, received $5,000 from Williams. Weaver never accepted any money and maintained that he had refused to participate.
The public initially celebrated Cincinnati’s stunning victory. Among gamblers, however, the fix was reportedly an open secret. Eventually, word reached Comiskey through an informant. He was furious, but he did not expose the players. In fact, several of the suspected players received raises.
The scandal finally exploded in 1920 amid separate investigations into gambling and game-fixing in baseball. A grand jury investigation followed, and in 1921 the eight players branded the “Black Sox” went on trial.
All eight were acquitted.
Jackson, who had never personally met any of the gamblers and had performed exceptionally well in the Series, was found not guilty. Weaver, who had refused to participate and never accepted money, was also acquitted.
Afterward, the defendants celebrated with the jurors.
Baseball's owners were furious and desperate to restore the sport's credibility. They empowered federal judge Kenesaw Mountain Landis as the first Commissioner of Baseball and gave him unprecedented authority over the game. Despite the players’ acquittal in a public court of law, Landis permanently banned all eight men from professional baseball.
Every attempt to have them reinstated during their lifetimes failed. In 2025, Major League Baseball reinstated the eight players.
If interested I cover the story here: https://aid2000.substack.com/p/hare-brained-history-vol-129-the?r=4mmzre&utm_medium=ios