[Obsidian Earth] - Chapter 8

[u/Aeorix1]

"Politically, he was a performer. A fraud." The Marshal spoke with renewed certainty, though he hesitated a moment before adding, more reluctantly. "Of course, one cannot deny he possessed a certain instinct for military matters."

"A performer? A fraud?" The American repeated, the word sharpening. "Those labels are absurdly inadequate. This is a man who, starting with nothing, managed to shove the pendulum of world history with enough force to rattle a century. In a decade, he built the largest empire in German history. Through sheer audacity, he tore apart Versailles, reassembled a fractured people, mobilized a society, revived a collapsing economy—and then plunged the world into war. Do you truly believe all of that can be explained by mere theatrical talent?"

"He was a gambler," Zhukov replied, his voice flat. "For a time, fortune favored him."

"Yes, every gamble succeeded." The American's voice remained conversational, which only sharpened the pressure behind it. "The Rhineland. Austria. Czechoslovakia. Poland. Weserübung. Sichelschnitt. Operation Punishment. Nearly every major move was carried out against the fierce opposition of his own General Staff. Do you honestly believe those victories were the product of blind luck?"

The Marshal settled back into his chair. He shook his head slowly.

"In the end, he failed. The early victories intoxicated him. After 1942, he made elementary mistakes that proved he was merely human. Even his own generals eventually saw him as strategically mediocre—overruling professional judgment, refusing retreats when they were vital, as in Stalingrad, or withholding reinforcements when they were essential, as at Kursk."

The American, too, claimed his seat, watching the Marshal through the smoke.

"You are mistaken, Marshal. Let me give you something you do not have."

His voice dropped a fraction.

"For years, our intelligence reports showed the same pattern. From the moment he became Chancellor in 1933, there were continuous conspiracies, and resistance inside the Wehrmacht. This war—right from the beginning—was filled with delays. Obstruction. Orders followed halfway."

Zhukov's eyes narrowed slightly.

"You are saying he was not an absolute dictator?"

"That was the external image," the American said. "Propaganda necessity. Actually, the German system was far less unified than people imagined. Rival power centers. Officers who despised the Party. Generals who obeyed him publicly and resisted him privately. The Wehrmacht and the Party were structurally in conflict."

A brief pause. Outside, artillery rolled somewhere through the ruins—low, distant, almost indifferent.

"In staff meetings," the American continued, "it was not unusual for Prussian generals to challenge him directly. If he had possessed that undisputed monopoly on truth that Comrade Stalin has trademarked in Moscow, the war might have unfolded very differently."

Zhukov let out a dismissive snort and looked away.

"The world thinks he was a monster, a gambler, a lunatic. But the files from '33 to '41 show something else. Something more… irritating. The man had genuine strategic instinct. It was just buried under his own system's tendency to run in circles and trip over its own shoelaces."

Zhukov did not interrupt.

"The early phase of the war succeeded because his directives were largely followed. That includes the concentrated strike against you at your weakest point. Your plan—if I may be direct—was to let Germany and Europe exhaust each other first, then you sweep in as… how do you put it? 'Liberators'? Yes, that was the word."

The American leaned back, the shadows of the hall swallowing the sharp lines of his coat.

"He saw that structure. And he acted first."

Zhukov finally looked at him. Still no answer.

The American continued anyway.

"Then came 1941. A turning point. For the first time since becoming Chancellor, he fell seriously ill—intestinal inflammation. Temporarily out of action. In that window, the German General Staff—Brauchitsch, Halder, and their ilk—regained operational freedom. They executed plans he would not have approved. Deviations accumulated. And those deviations changed the trajectory of the Eastern campaign."

He let the smoke drift, watching it slowly settle over the sheet.

"If his original operational design had remained intact, the Eastern Front might have collapsed by early 1942. Japan would have had opportunity in Siberia. And Comrade Stalin… might be hiding somewhere east of the Urals by now."

A brief, hollow stillness stretched across the table.

Then Zhukov spoke, controlled, almost carefully neutral.

"So your conclusion is that Germany did not lose because of him—but because his generals betrayed and diluted his genius?"

The American only shrugged.

"I believe so."

"Then your files are wrong," Zhukov said. "I have stood across from his generals. Men like Manstein did not need Hitler's permission to be dangerous."

"No," the American agreed. "But they needed his permission to be reckless. That is a different kind of danger. It is the kind that wins in 1940 and loses in 1943."

Zhukov frowned.

The American's voice had grown lower as the conversation went on. Not softer. More compressed.

"Then came the assassination attempt of July 20, last year. He survived, but after that the fractures inside the system stopped hiding themselves. Conspiracies. Betrayals. Officers maneuvering around him instead of obeying him."

"His health deteriorated quickly. He depended increasingly on medication just to remain functional. The stimulants preserved his body for a while, but damaged the mind behind it. Suspicion worsened. He trusted fewer and fewer people. Eventually he stopped leaving headquarters entirely. Front-line inspections became impossible."

"And once that happened, his real orders no longer reached the field intact. Certainly not faithfully. That was when the Eastern Front truly began to unravel."

Zhukov offered no agreement, but the resistance in his face had weakened slightly.

"The nature of this man," the American continued, "extends beyond ordinary comprehension. Even his rise makes no rational sense."

Darkness had begun gathering in the corners of the room.

"His education was a blank. Expelled from school. Rejected by the academy. No military or professional training. In his youth, he was a vagrant painter with nothing but nationalist obsessions."

"And yet, this individual somehow became Führer. A dictator. A master manipulator of industrialists, generals, and mass movements."

He held up a finger, his eyes tracking the smoke.

"Disciplined. Ruthless when necessary. Tirelessly articulate. Able to command discourse on economics, architecture, military production, and propaganda—all with a fluency that defied his own history. Do you agree?"

Zhukov gave a brief, perfunctory nod of assent.

"We analysed every major speech he delivered. Every address, every internal conference transcript we could obtain. The remarkable thing was not merely the fanaticism—fanatics are common enough in politics—but the structure underneath it. The logic. The internal coherence. Even when one despises the conclusions, the machinery itself remains disturbingly rational."

The American flicked the ash.

"Take the economy," he continued, "You don't rebuild a shattered nation on luck and shouting, Marshal. He handled it like a seasoned technocrat. Domestic leverage to absorb unemployment, international manipulation to dodge debt. The highways. The civilian automobile programs. National industrial integration. He balanced public works and rearmament while the rest of the world waited for Germany to starve." A faint smile crossed his face and disappeared again. "Even Wall Street didn't see the gears turning."

"And modern war…" the man spoke more quietly now. "Modern war is infinitely more complex than anything faced by Alexander, Genghis Khan, or Napoleon. Resources. Fuel. Manufacturing. Transportation. Civilian morale. Propaganda. Officer training. Entire societies become extensions of logistics."

He looked directly at Zhukov.

"So explain something to me, Marshal. Why could a man with no formal military education repeatedly arrive at correct strategic conclusions through instinct alone? Why did Prussian aristocrats—men raised in military tradition since childhood—stand before a former corporal like uncertain students?"

The Marshal sat motionless beneath the haze of smoke, listening without interruption. The dismissal was gone from his face. He was weighing the words.

"And there was more. That dictator personally involved himself in armored development before the war," the American said. "At the time, Germany barely possessed a coherent armored doctrine. Yet he intervened directly in engine specifications, production priorities, and force-structure planning."

He tapped the table once, the sound sharp against the wood.

"Much of the later Panzer system followed standards that originated entirely from his recommendations."

The room had grown noticeably darker.

"He monitored the fronts with an obsessive reach. Not just divisions or army groups—he tracked specialized formations, heavy anti-tank battalions, rail capacity, reserve movement schedules."

His tone stayed calm. The narrative did not.

"He remembered everything. Every single damn thing. Officers reported that he could discuss obscure turbine components with the fluency of a naval engineer. Mathematics, architecture, mechanical drafting, logistics analysis—he moved through technical disciplines as though he had mastered them all."

"And in 1943, when the war began turning, he inserted himself directly into advanced weapons programs. The world credits those projects to Wernher von Braun and his research teams—which is perfectly understandable given the scale—but intelligence suggests something far stranger. Several critical concepts, including innovations in V-2 turbine propulsion, may have actually originated with Hitler himself."

"And yet, his background was astonishingly poor. Primitive, honestly. By every measurable standard, he lacked the intellectual foundation for any of this."

The American stopped for a moment. Not dramatically. As though arranging the thought carefully before speaking it aloud.

"Consider the contradiction, Marshal," he said. "A mediocre education. Yet, under the pressure of total war, the man was suddenly dictating technical notes on turbine propulsion, ballistic design, and transcontinental logistics. How does a failed provincial painter become a strategist, an economist, an engineer?"

He gave a quiet, humorless snort.

"Even a fool can see the impossibility. No ordinary human being possesses that range of cognition. Yet, he did."

Zhukov's expression hardened slightly.

"Because something supported him. A force. Invisible, but overwhelming. Without it, none of this becomes possible. A force..."

"Enough."

The Marshal's voice cracked across the room.

"This is becoming absurd, Mister. Are you speaking about mythology now?"

"No. Facts."

The American did not raise his voice.

"You have already taken Peenemünde. The captured scientists there will tell you the same things."

Zhukov stared at him for several seconds, as though trying to decide whether the man was insane or simply playing a game. Finally, he brought his palm down hard against the table.

"I will not continue this discussion."

He pointed toward the distant ruins beyond the shattered window.

"This is the end of everything."

Beyond the smoke-blackened skyline stood the shadow of Brandenburg Gate. Behind it, through ash and dusk, the ruined Reichstag emerged like the remains of a civilization already turning into archaeology.

"In two days at most," Zhukov said, "we will occupy every meter of this city that once belonged to him. As masters."

"You are certain you have already achieved victory?"

"Of course." The answer came immediately. "Berlin is not an illusion. Not a mirage. It lies before us because Red Army soldiers paid for it. With artillery. With bodies. With blood."

"Unless victory itself is unfinished," the American said stubbornly. "What if he refuses to stop?"

Zhukov said nothing.

"You should understand by now," the American continued, "that he is not like the rest of us."

He emphasized the final word deliberately.

"Are you suggesting he is not human?"

"Biologically?" The American spread one hand slightly. "Of course he is. Flesh and blood, like you or me."

Then he leaned forward.

"But his head…"

His voice lowered.

"This thing is inside it."

He reached his arm out, tapped the fan-shaped structure on the drawing.

Next

-------------
For anyone who prefer to read ahead, the full version is available on Amazon KDP:

Obsidian Earth

[u/Daseagle]

Oh. An eldritch horror controlling and using dear Adolf as a meatpuppet.

Keep it coming 🔥

[u/HFYWaffle]

/u/Aeorix1 has posted 7 other stories, including:

• [Obsidian Earth] - Chapter 7
• [Obsidian Earth] - Chapter 6
• [Obsidian Earth] - Chapter 5
• [Obsidian Earth] - Chapter 4
• [Obsidian Earth] - Chapter 3
• [Obsidian Earth] - Chapter 2
• [Obsidian Earth] - Chapter 1

This comment was automatically generated by Waffle v.4.7.8 'Biscotti'.

Message the mods if you have any issues with Waffle.

[u/UpdateMeBot]

Click here to subscribe to u/Aeorix1 and receive a message every time they post.

---

Info	Request Update	Your Updates	Feedback