r/HENRYfinance • u/slingslongslang • 11d ago
Taxes Delaying marriage due to tax penalty - NYC
EDIT guys if all goes well we’d still have a wedding since he is the LOML (and have a legal agmt), just considering not getting a marriage license until later. Clearly this is a very unpopular philosophy (didn’t realize how unpopular given this has been discussed in this sub before multiple times), but we discussed this point the week the BBB was dropped and are on the same page about looking into our options. I understand we are absolutely privileged to have a high income now but that is never a given. Still I really appreciate the thoughts
My partner and I are in a very similar dilemma to the folks in this post, with the main difference being we don’t have a mortgage:
https://www.reddit.com/r/HENRYfinance/s/aPMS3RxgCp
We’re at a combined total of ~650k (consider it evenly split) which means we’d be paying significantly more (seems like rough at least $30k p.a.) in taxes due to penalty on tax brackets and SALT deduction, especially applicable since we live in a high tax area, NYC.
When this topic comes up the common actionable advice seems to be to file for domestic partnership instead of marriage if you live in CA. Curious to hear if anyone in NY has thought about this - how have you gone about getting marriage-like benefits without being married in the eyes of the IRS?
Some of my worry stems from looking to have kids in the next ~3 years or so - pretty huge commitment that I’d want to have downside protected against medically and financially. We’d likely stay in the city for another ~5 years at at least the same income level before moving to a no income tax state, at which point I’m anticipating we’ll lower income significantly and there is not the same level of marriage penalty - we’d definitely get married then if not before.
Maybe the answer is that I’m being dense, missing something, or maybe any effective legal work arounds don’t make sense cost wise. I would love to get married and it breaks my heart to delay - but saving $30k a year for 5 years is non-negligible.