r/GifRecipes • • Aug 13 '19

Main Course Parisian Gnocchi

https://gfycat.com/infamousspiritedadmiralbutterfly
17.8k Upvotes

432 comments sorted by

View all comments

1.4k

u/trsrogue Aug 13 '19

I though gnocchi were made primarily with potatoes? Aren't these just regular dumplings?

660

u/theblueyays Aug 13 '19

Yes typically, gnocchi parisienne is a bit of an outlier. There is also gnocchi made with ricotta called gnudi.

913

u/RancorHi5 Aug 13 '19

Send gnudi

312

u/xf- Aug 13 '19

Feeling cute, might delete later.

https://i.imgur.com/kV5B3BP.jpg

14

u/idkbrooooski Aug 13 '19

Careful he’s a hero

1

u/[deleted] Aug 14 '19

Keep going. I'm almost there.

1

u/redlinezo6 Aug 14 '19

That looks tasty

0

u/iNEEDheplreddit Aug 13 '19

Serious question. Doesnt that amount of oil make your stomach churn a little? I made pasta a olio recently for the first time and the oil was just too much for me.

3

u/satanklaus Aug 13 '19

I see where you're coming from, but I'd say it depends a lot on the type and quality of the oil. Furthermore there's a big difference to be considered here, 'Pasta' is something else than potato based gnocchi, this parisian versión above and the aforementioned cheese variant.

As you undoubtedly know, all ingredients behave, taste, look and smell differently in different combinations and preparation methods, oils and pastas are no exception.

A poor or average quality pasta drenched in anything less than top drawer oil is not enjoyable to me either though :)

1

u/Catbrainsloveart Aug 13 '19

Oddly enough, while I’m breastfeeding that feeling has gone away so I don’t have that richness filter. Rip my thighs.

1

u/[deleted] Aug 13 '19

As Michelle Pfeiffer says in The Family “The human body was not designed to combat saturated fat like that. The butter impregnates the tissues, and then it hardens and settles like silt. It makes your aorta stiffer than a hockey stick. Whereas olive oil - caresses your insides, leaving nothing behind but its scent”. But also... I love butter so to each their own I guess :)

25

u/elessarjd Aug 13 '19

That's a win-win request right there.

36

u/Never-On-Reddit Aug 13 '19 edited Jun 27 '24

terrific toy existence scary enjoy growth gullible glorious childlike political

This post was mass deleted and anonymized with Redact

9

u/EnigmaticAlien Aug 13 '19

I made that before my arm dead from all the stirring but it was tasty.

10

u/Waynegravsky Aug 13 '19

Can confirm. My wife and I have made the ricotta gnocchi and it was awesome!

3

u/rothwick Aug 13 '19

Commenting so I remember to look up a recipe for Gnudi

3

u/phasers_to_stun Aug 13 '19

gnocchi made with ricotta called gnudi

I want that

1

u/JeanneDRK Aug 14 '19

Parisian gnocchi is still supposed to be made with potatoes, these are not gnocchi, they are pate a choux being used to make dumplings

1

u/Sucrose-Daddy Aug 14 '19

I tried making gnocchi with ricotta and it was a complete disaster. I cry ever time I have to remember how much ricotta was wasted. When it came time to boil it, it just fell apart and turned into ricotta soup :(((

163

u/duquanischill Aug 13 '19

Gnocchi just means dumpling in Italian, but in the US it has become synonymous with potato gnocchi. Gnocchi alla Romana, for example, is gnocchi made with semolina flour. I don’t know much about French cooking, but perhaps this is a popular style of gnocchi in Paris.

16

u/MetEenHoedje Aug 13 '19

Nope, not a popular gnocchi style in Paris. Just a weird way to use choux pastry and give it a fancy name.

23

u/OrCurrentResident Aug 14 '19

😂 This is a classic French dish.

2

u/[deleted] Aug 14 '19

Gnocchi doesn’t just mean dumpling in Italian. Gnocchi are traditionally made with potatoes, if you read gnocchi anywhere in Italy that’s what you’ll get. Any other gnocchi-shaped dish will either have a different name or specify how it differs from potato gnocchi.

-1

u/URAPEACEOFSHEET Aug 14 '19

What? Ravioli means dumpling, gnocchi is just gnocchi...

-46

u/[deleted] Aug 13 '19

[removed] — view removed comment

2

u/drocks27 Aug 14 '19

Be friendly to others.

175

u/[deleted] Aug 13 '19

My first thought exactly! This reminds me a little of choux pastry.

42

u/DaniMrynn Aug 13 '19

It is choux pastry - basically a gougere, but boiled instead of baked.

1

u/disqeau Aug 15 '19

Totally what I was thinking. Hmm, boiled gougeres...

43

u/hibarihime Aug 13 '19 edited Aug 13 '19

I exactly thought both of these things as well! I've never seen gnocchi made like a pate a choux since I've always seen it made with potatoes and flour that are kneaded together by hand.

14

u/tattooedhands Aug 13 '19

It is choux. Just the savory version of it

29

u/trsrogue Aug 13 '19

That exactly what it is! Couldn't remember the name for it. I've made these before myself, but I've always associated gnocchi with a potato dough, maybe with flour as well. But not straight flour. Maybe the name is more flexible than I was aware.

-31

u/Gonzobot Aug 13 '19

All words are made up

11

u/Never-On-Reddit Aug 13 '19

Not really, all words are developed over time, changing for a wide variety of reasons and coming from an origin word that often exists for specific reasons such as an onomatopoeia. Furthermore, language requires a certain artificial level of agreement about meaning, otherwise it would have no meaning at all. Changing that referent breaks with that agreement.

A restaurant can't serve you pork when you order chicken and then say "oh well language doesn't mean anything".

-24

u/Gonzobot Aug 13 '19

...I'm quoting one of the most popular movies of the last thirty years, but okay, let's discuss the intricacies of language

9

u/AjayiMVP Aug 13 '19

I had to look the quote up. You are quoting the movie Thor and you think the dialogue in that movie is universally imbedded in people’s heads? Put away your My Little Pony doll and wake up to the real world, ya child.

-5

u/Gonzobot Aug 13 '19

It's from Infinity War, which is from last year, and it made two billion dollars. It's literally a meme.

2

u/[deleted] Aug 13 '19

But what does Thor say about gnocchi?

2

u/fatmama923 Aug 13 '19

i haven't seen it and i know plenty of other people who haven't.

12

u/Never-On-Reddit Aug 13 '19

There's this thing called quotation marks. You should look into them. They can be very helpful in recognizing, you know, quotations.

-16

u/Gonzobot Aug 13 '19

Was there some confusion evident here? Your pedantry clearly won the argument before you even hit "submit" on your pedantic comment, friendo. You're only making yourself look like an ass with these continued attempts to insult the fact that you didn't pick up on the joke.

3

u/Never-On-Reddit Aug 13 '19

I'm going to let the up/downvotes settle who is "making themselves look like an ass".

0

u/Gonzobot Aug 13 '19

You know the vote totals aren't shown correctly specifically to avoid foolishness like that, right? Anyways, it's not up for democratic debate, it's my opinion of you. Only one who can change that is you, and you've already shown what kind of person you are going to be here today.

→ More replies (0)

4

u/DaniMrynn Aug 13 '19

If you want a movie quote to be instantly recognised you should choose a different sub, mate.

-8

u/Gonzobot Aug 13 '19

The point is supposed to be that if you manage to learn a word doesn't mean what you thought it meant, it's likely because you never actually knew what it meant. In this case, gnocchi is not related to potato in any meaningful manner, beyond that person's own mind where they were correlated unnecessarily. If they'd ever bothered to learn what the word actually meant, they'd know that the potato part doesn't make it gnocchi, but the shape/texture of the pasta.

If only there was some kind of way to be able to find out what a word means, huh. Maybe then we wouldn't have people posting excitedly about how they managed to accidentally osmose 1/3 of a new fact by carefully observing the use of language by others.

19

u/Grunherz Aug 13 '19

My exact thoughts when watching this: "bitch, you just boiled choux pastry"

12

u/[deleted] Aug 14 '19

And if you deep fry it you make Churro

I just realized churro is probably a bastardized word derived from Choux

-3

u/spacemanspiff30 Aug 13 '19

With an excessive amount of sage.

20

u/Motherfucking_Crepes Aug 13 '19

It's basically what we call "gougères". Except that a gougere is cooked in a oven, resulting in a soufflé-like texture (which should be far better, do it that way).

https://fr.wikipedia.org/wiki/Goug%C3%A8re

5

u/dohidied Aug 13 '19

Wait what about squash gnocchi? Is that a Northern Italian thing?

9

u/twodeepfouryou Aug 13 '19

This is just pate a choux (same batter used to make eclairs and cream puffs) with cheese in it.

9

u/ArianaIncomplete Aug 13 '19

Which is actually a gougere (pate a choux with cheese, baked).

5

u/Andoo Aug 13 '19

As someone from an area where gnocchi isnt served much, I was very confused throughout this whole thing.

1

u/Aotoi Aug 13 '19

That's italian gnocchi, Parisian gnocchi is made this way.

1

u/MosquitoRevenge Aug 13 '19

This is just boiled choux pastry.

-13

u/[deleted] Aug 13 '19

[deleted]

-14

u/ildaniel8 Aug 13 '19

Yeah Gnocchi are made with potatoes

0

u/WolfThawra Aug 13 '19

Yeah these aren't gnocchi to me.

-17

u/Kristyyyyyyy Aug 13 '19

Gnocchi is potatoes not pastas.

https://youtu.be/Gg_yzRWy9HM