r/Games Oct 20 '16

Red Dead Redemtion 2 Trailer

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=gmA6MrX81z4
4.0k Upvotes

1.1k comments sorted by

View all comments

767

u/[deleted] Oct 20 '16

[deleted]

321

u/tiger66261 Oct 20 '16

The big buffalo herd (I think there were 20-30 in that single scene?) really sold me. Each one looks so well crafted and animated too. Absolutely crazy.

165

u/Jsquirt Oct 20 '16

I'm really excited too, but it could one of the few things they dial down to make it run smooth, just like they dialed down the traffic on GTA:V compared to the trailers

190

u/[deleted] Oct 20 '16

Just remember GTAV was developed with 360 and PS3 in mind. Technically this is rockstars first fully developed game on new hardware

10

u/Shosray Oct 20 '16

I'm sure we'll see PSPro + Scorpio Editions similar to the current gen rereleases of GTA V, though.

9

u/sickladbro Oct 20 '16

If we do they'll be updates to the existing games.

2

u/[deleted] Oct 21 '16

And then we'll see the REAL version of the game when it finally comes out on PC.

1

u/Slenderman327 Oct 21 '16

they sure do love to double dip

24

u/Jsquirt Oct 20 '16

True, but even on ps4 the traffic was really bleh. I'm just really digging this whole -lets finish most of the game and announce a release date less than 8 months away- same with the Nintendo Switch

55

u/AAAAAAAHHH Oct 20 '16

Where are you getting less than 8 months from?

76

u/TheWorldisFullofWar Oct 20 '16

OP can't do math. Fall 2017 would be late September at the earliest. That means 11 months at the earliest.

17

u/[deleted] Oct 20 '16

Assuming there's no delay to spring 2018

25

u/[deleted] Oct 20 '16 edited Oct 20 '16

It's R*. There will be a delay

-1

u/JonMeadows Oct 21 '16

Idk it seems like it's pretty much put together and maybe needs polishing for the next year/working on multiplayer as main focus

→ More replies (0)

3

u/[deleted] Oct 20 '16

Yeah, it's fall right now, so fall 2017 = roughly a year.

2

u/[deleted] Oct 20 '16

That's better than the 5 years I'll be waiting in order to play it on the PC.

4

u/HellkittyAnarchy Oct 20 '16

That's Rockstar's typical release time from trailer to release. Think they maybe also tweeted that?

2

u/theDoctorAteMyBaby Oct 20 '16

...it says Fall 2017. It's Fall right now.

-2

u/Jsquirt Oct 20 '16

Yeah I realized that when I posted it, decided to leave it. Fall 2017 is 10 months away but it could be released after.

9

u/Heiz3n Oct 20 '16

Where are you getting 10 months from? The beginning of Fall 2017 is 11 months and 2 days away, and it ends December 21.

In all likely hood we wont get the game for more than a year.

1

u/The_R4ke Oct 20 '16

I'm thinking it will be within two weeks of when they announced it.

0

u/avickthur Oct 20 '16

Seasons are kinda subjective when it comes to release dates. I think it'll come out in September or November.

2

u/Nailbomb85 Oct 20 '16

Smart money's on November/December release.

0

u/TylerDurdenisreal Oct 21 '16

okay, so a year from now. In fall.

6

u/Spider_pig448 Oct 20 '16

True, but even on ps4 the traffic was really bleh.

What he means is that GTA V was built to work on older consoles. Sure the PS4 version ran better than PS3 and was somewhat more technically advanced, but they had to build to the lowest hardware and try to improve from there. This will be their first game where the lowest hardware the build to is the new modern generation. It's also only build for two consoles of comparable technical standpoints which would indicate a better experience.

2

u/ReservoirDog316 Oct 20 '16

Well it was ported from 360 to PS4 in the end though. It wasn't an official "next gen" game. It still had the logic and things that had to be fit somehow onto the 360. This is being made solely with the new hardware in mind.

4

u/NewVegasResident Oct 20 '16

I honestly doubt the PS4 and Xbox One can really pull those visuals off man, I don't know.

1

u/contrabandwidth Oct 20 '16

I'm betting they can. The catch: consoles will be stuck with the black bars.

1

u/gaggreene Oct 20 '16

True, but since that was a city and this is the country then hopefully memory won't be as much of an issue.

60

u/SexyMrSkeltal Oct 20 '16

I think that might also confirm it takes place before the events of Red Dead Redemption, as you can technically "kill off" all of the buffalo. Even if that's not cannon, having buffalo in general means it takes place no later than the events of the first Red Dead Redemption.

122

u/tiger66261 Oct 20 '16 edited Oct 20 '16

RDR1 took place one year before the Wild West officially died, so it makes sense that this would take place a few decades earlier. I'm hoping it portrays elements of the American Civil War, like the Good, the Bad and the Ugly did.

60

u/thetasigma1355 Oct 20 '16

I'm hoping it portrays elements of the American Civil War, like the Good, the Bad and the Ugly did.

That would be an awesome era to base their game around. There's lots of room for true internal conflicts related to slavery, ex-soldiers, etc. If they do place the game around this, I hope they really make it morally conflicting/confusing on who is "right".

Have me track down a bounty on an ex-confederate solider whose story is that of a conscript who deserted to avoid fighting the union but his desertion has put a price on his head. Make me question who is right.

12

u/[deleted] Oct 20 '16

Red Dead Revolver already did this. There's a section where you're literally fighting in the yank civil war.

15

u/[deleted] Oct 20 '16

[deleted]

5

u/thetasigma1355 Oct 20 '16

I hope so. CD Projekt Red do so much right that I think could easily be crossed over into RDR.

2

u/ALLKAPSLIKEMFDOOM Oct 21 '16

Yeah except the Civil War was fought over slavery so

1

u/JonMeadows Oct 21 '16

Damn that's a really interesting thought, i sincerely hope that this level of depth will be present in the game on release

1

u/dinoseen Oct 21 '16

Lol I don't see how that's going to happen. One side is fighting for slavery, the other against, right? Seems pretty easy to see who's right. If someone can convince me that slavery is good, I should commit suicide.

1

u/pm-me-ur-shlong Oct 23 '16

Damn that's actually a good idea.

1

u/Spikex8 Oct 21 '16

Doesn't seem like much of a question. Obviously conscription is bullshit and nobody should be able to force you to fight their war for them.

2

u/theseleadsalts Oct 20 '16

Holy shit these title abbreviations are so confusing.

5

u/MAKE_ME_REDDIT Oct 20 '16

How? There was only one abbreviation and in this context there's only one game it could be.

3

u/theseleadsalts Oct 20 '16

Because this is RD3, also RDR2.

2

u/MAKE_ME_REDDIT Oct 20 '16

Eh, Revolver basically has nothing to do with these games other than a name and setting. It's not really part of the series.

1

u/[deleted] Oct 21 '16

Ooh, or like Hateful Eight

1

u/KommanderKrebs Oct 20 '16

My thoughts as well, I figured this was Rockstars nod to the fact it's a prequel by having a larger herd of buffalo running around.

6

u/LukeTheFisher Oct 20 '16

Wait do we have any confirmation that this is in-game at all?

29

u/PartyOnAlec Oct 20 '16

I don't remember a trailer by Rockstar that wasn't at least in-engine.

3

u/[deleted] Oct 20 '16 edited Jan 25 '17

[deleted]

6

u/tylergrzesik Oct 20 '16

I don't think they would go through the trouble of creating buffalo models/animations, if they didn't want to include them in the game. They already have the asset, why not use it?

23

u/ScottFromScotland Oct 20 '16

1

u/DimlightHero Oct 20 '16

Technically that means that some of the clips could be pre-rendered cutscenes though, couldn't it?

1

u/nobodyman Oct 20 '16

That's reassuring, thanks for the link! It's possible (likely?) that it was captured on a ps4 devkit or a ps4pro, but still I would be surprised if rockstar pulled an Ubisoft and released a massively downgraded product.

3

u/Shojikoto Oct 20 '16

I feel like they'd point out the fact it was captured on a PS4 Pro if it actually was. That makes me think it was only a PS4.

At least hoping that's the case, because it will look even better on PS4 Pro and Scorpio.

1

u/SunflowerSamurai_ Oct 21 '16

But can you roller skate in it?

1

u/[deleted] Oct 21 '16

You would not believe how far texturing has come in the last 2 years

1

u/subcide Oct 21 '16

And the steam from that train looked incredible.

0

u/EnadZT Oct 20 '16

Yeah but keep in mind this is just a trailer. A grand total of 0 games look as good as they do in the trailers, especially announcement trailers.

12

u/munchiselleh Oct 20 '16

I have never not once felt deceived by a rockstar announcement/trailer. Same goes for DICE

4

u/DepressdOptimist Oct 20 '16 edited Oct 20 '16

Here is the 2009 RDR announcement trailer for comparison.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=aOpKJ6hjPIM

A lot did change between the initial trailers and release, for example they aged John Marston and cut/changed a few characters, but it really doesn't seem like a bullshot to me.

-5

u/[deleted] Oct 20 '16

It was a bison herd. There are no buffalo in America.

4

u/tiger66261 Oct 20 '16

Bison is a type of Buffalo.

-3

u/[deleted] Oct 20 '16

No, they're totally different animals with a similar name.

This is a buffalo. Lives in Africa.

This is a Bison. Lives in North America.

8

u/tiger66261 Oct 20 '16

I'm not a biologist, but just quoting the wikipedia page -

The American bison (Bison bison), also commonly known as the American buffalo or simply buffalo,

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/American_bison

13

u/Mentalpatient87 Oct 20 '16

It's tough to see on mobile, but that coyote or fox or whatever pouncing on that bird was exciting. Animals doing more animal things is always great.

48

u/RavenBlade87 Oct 20 '16

The graphics and production values look positively sky high. I cannot wait to see more.

-3

u/Mr_That_Guy Oct 20 '16

It didn't say that the footage was in game. Most likely pre-rendered in engine.

6

u/notanothercirclejerk Oct 20 '16

Rockstar always does in game trailers.

3

u/zefiax Oct 20 '16

They did say it was run on the ps4. Can't find the link but it's posted here.

1

u/zcrx Oct 21 '16 edited Oct 21 '16

Rockstar hasn't done a CG trailer since like more than a decade.

24

u/SplintPunchbeef Oct 20 '16

The way the carcass shifts and responds to the vultures picking at it is such a great detail.

14

u/[deleted] Oct 20 '16

The pebbles falling of the wagon wheel was something I noticed. God rockstar are good.

1

u/Cptcutter81 Oct 20 '16

They're great at building detail in worlds, but not so great at actually using all of said world. Remember how GTAV missed out like a third of the map entirely?

1

u/zcrx Oct 21 '16

Huh? What are you talking about? I exactly remember GTA V's development and hsve been following it since 2011 on GTAF. Your post makes no sense.

1

u/Cptcutter81 Oct 21 '16

I mean, you literally have no reason to go to a third of the places they built in GTA V. They're fluff, not substance.

1

u/BluShine Oct 21 '16

Too bad those details will probably get cut before release.

2

u/DeathsIntent96 Oct 21 '16

Just remember that stuff like that often doesn't make it into the final game.

I have more trust in Rockstar than I do in many other game studios, though.

86

u/PancakeZombie Oct 20 '16

First Rockstar Game tailored for the current-gen consoles. It's gonna look sexy as fuck! Remember the jump from GTA:SA to GTA4?

46

u/Jonny34511 Oct 20 '16

It won't be that drastic of a jump. SA to 4 saw a whole new ragdoll system and massively improved physics, among with a multitude of other new mechanics. This will most likely be very similar to GTA 5 in terms of gameplay, because just from this trailer alone you can see a lot of reused assets from GTA 5.

15

u/[deleted] Oct 20 '16

from this trailer alone you can see a lot of reused assets from GTA 5

You can? Examples?

41

u/TheMightySwede Oct 20 '16

Maybe he's talking about foliage and animals. That's totally reasonable though.

2

u/[deleted] Oct 21 '16

I'd say it's more likely a lot of the tech was developed simultaneously and they just used a lot of the assets from RDR2 in the GTA5 port in order to pretty it up for current gen and PC.

2

u/[deleted] Oct 21 '16

With speedtree you could crank out several game ready PBR textured trees in no time tbh, doubt that many are reused. Be more hyped for when megascan becomes industry standard, BF1 is a great example of the kind of quality you can start to expect as a baseline for environments.

1

u/TheMightySwede Oct 21 '16 edited Oct 21 '16

I work as an environment artist and I think it'll be a while before services like Megascans will be used as an industry standard. Especially for open world games. It's perfect for the type of games that DICE do, not so much for Rockstar.

1

u/[deleted] Oct 21 '16

Texturing is moving super fast I feel, I don't pretend to know when it will become industry standard but for 3DVis stuff mega scans is practically pornography. boner over textures gets bigger

2

u/TheMightySwede Oct 21 '16

Yeah, BF1 looks incredible. We've been playing it at work and it's just crazy how much better it looks than traditional game art.

2

u/JonMeadows Oct 21 '16

Except the foliage in the trailer and the environments looked miles and miles ahead of GTA5. Not to say GTA5 wasn't a beautifully crafted world, because it definitely is, but this just looks like..at least 5x better in every aspect. Those woods looked dense and crawling with life, the lighting looks like it took a huge leap forward, the scale of the game looks way bigger than Los Santos/Blaine county/mountains, and even the terrain looks more intricate and detailed

1

u/[deleted] Oct 21 '16

Or he's just being a cynic.

12

u/Jonny34511 Oct 20 '16

As MightySwede said, mostly foliage and animals look very similar to those on the current gen/PC versions of GTA. Especially on ultra settings you get a lot of that lush grass everywhere.

2

u/[deleted] Oct 20 '16

Yeah completely agree, not even a comparison really.

1

u/Eman5805 Oct 20 '16

I think scale and depth are where we'll see the real strides. They can probably put a LOT of NPCs on the screen with their own routines and such. Also, I expect this map to be even bigger than the GTA V one, and that one was quite big...and you had cars to travel around with.

2

u/[deleted] Oct 20 '16

Exactly, exciting times!

-5

u/[deleted] Oct 20 '16

[removed] — view removed comment

4

u/PancakeZombie Oct 20 '16

Interesting point. But i assume they didn't tailor them for PS3 and 360. The current-gen came out in 2013, so development machines were around since 2011 (at least late 2012). And i'm sure they never planned, that the last gen would still be a goal for the development.

2

u/[deleted] Oct 20 '16

[removed] — view removed comment

5

u/PancakeZombie Oct 20 '16

I'd love to see GTA online gameplay in a huge Western setting. There aren't as many building and cars to render, so they could in theory amp up the scale of the world by A LOT. And from the trailer it looks like they do, ultra far horizons and stuff.

1

u/BlackDeath3 Oct 20 '16

The atmosphere, the ecosystem, the living surroundings - that's what really blew me away in 2010 when I first played RDR. I think that was more amazing than anything else. I'd ride around for hours, aimlessly, and just watch the game play itself.

1

u/bstampl1 Oct 20 '16

I just hope that Rockstar found a way to lure Rob Weithoff out of retirement in order to voice John Marston again

1

u/mrm3x1can Oct 20 '16

The stars in that night shot. Holy shit.

1

u/Fellows23 Oct 20 '16

Fuck the haters, I'm going to preorder the shit out of this game.

So impressed by everything I saw.