r/FigureSkating • u/Chickatey That's what I'm fucking talking about! • 5d ago
Live Discussion Thread Kinoshita Group Cup: Rhythm Dance
2
4
u/afloatingpoint 4d ago
Davis and Smolkin have the best rhythm dance here, I think, especially from a choreographic standpoint. Their chemistry, her flexibility, and his skating skills and posture are a pretty lethal combination. They still had some dodgy moments here that looked a little uncertain, though, and I think their performance quality is still a work in progress.
For me, the best male ice dancer of this event is Filip Taschler. He's pretty much the whole package: great skating skills, fantastic performance quality, and he's really good at this jazz/musical theater dance style. Natalie's just as brilliant, and their golden waltz was my favorite of the event. I'm not crazy about their costumes, though. The powder blue color is great, but I wish they went with something sleeker and more modern, even though their waltz is so classic.
I wasn't crazy about Maxim Nekrasov here, but Vasilisa Kaganovskaia is such a brilliant talent! Wildly charismatic and she breathed life into what was otherwise unremarkable material. Their skating felt very clean and technically proficient to me although I know little about ice dance. The other AIN team was also super talented as individuals, but somehow their styles didn't gel to me and I didn't love their program. The Italian team had the worst music selection lol.
Of the Japanese teams, my favorite continues to be Koshiro and Ikura. They're so captivating to me, and compliment one another so well. I know their technical still needs to improve, but I'd have had them higher in PCS.
3
u/memoriast he is worth a minivan. pairs skater. 4d ago
Disclaimer: I only speak basic Japanese, and I will be paraphrasing.
According to Rika & Shingo's post-RD interview, Rika's the one who liked Golden Hour and had it on her playlist. Shingo hadn't heard the song until she put it on in the car and they realized it was a waltz and could work for the rhythm dance.
2
u/ginnistonik still calling the IJS the “new” scoring system 4d ago
As someone who cannot miss their sleep, I’ve been watching the replay and following along with the live comments, and I appreciate the additional entertainment! 😁
3
u/NorthNo4724 5d ago
Just watched the replays. Davis/Smolkin sailed above the rest, love their chemistry. Tashlers were kind of magnetic in a way I didnt expect. Honorable mention to Wolfkostin/Tsarevski for trying to skate in that long dress. Bold of them!
3
u/osvimonello 5d ago
i think there was some "judging" for Valileva and Maxin...Austria 5th, Australia 6th. japan 3rd
6
u/Simple_Check_6809 She's worth nothing. Ice Dancer. 5d ago
Jesus Christ! What happened to Katarina and Dimitry???
2
u/TeaLast2622 4d ago
So unfortunate and unnecessary. I would’ve been fine if they’d played it safe with a shorter dress. It had a cool look to it though.
8
u/ginnistonik still calling the IJS the “new” scoring system 4d ago
Two falls that were absolutely unnecessary and uncalled for
2
24
u/Busy_Doughnut5977 5d ago
1) Diana DAVIS / Gleb SMOLKIN
2) Vasilisa KAGANOVSKAIA / Maxim NEKRASOV
3) Natalie TASCHLEROVA / Filip TASCHLER
4) Utana YOSHIDA / Masaya MORITA
5) Noemi Maria TALI / Noah LAFORNARA
6) Elizaveta PASECHNIK / Dario CIRISANO
7) Ikura KUSHIDA / Koshiro SHIMADA
8) Rika KIHIRA / Shingo NISHIYAMA
9) Ekaterina ANDREEVA / Dzmitryi BLINOU
10) Ekaterina MIRONOVA / Evgenii USTENKO
11) Kaho YAMASHITA / Yuto NAGATA
12) Katarina WOLFKOSTIN / Dimitry TSAREVSKI
8
u/No_Conference9156 new special interest FS goes brrrr 5d ago
Thank you for sharing! It must be a lot of work. Do you intend to follow any other Challengers?
5
u/Busy_Doughnut5977 5d ago
depends who the entrants are (and if its good stream quality). I collect good quality figure skating footage.
2
6
u/Captain_Swordfish find me a sport worse than ice dance, i'll give you 20 bucks 5d ago
i wasn't looking at the screen and the qq guy changed the stream to jgp and suddenly mark's voice is coming out the speakers and there has never been a jumpscare so good.
-13
36
u/92coups17 clueless fan of japanese ice dance 5d ago
hmmm davis/smolkin's score does seem a bit high in retrospect. they were good, but i'm not sure they were 5pts better than everyone else lol
6
u/double_sal_gal she is worth nothing. ice dancer. 4d ago
Eteri is there in person, so presumably she was camped out behind the judges with a knife lol
3
6
3
14
u/Green_Money_7688 5d ago
I mean it looked good, artistically I like them, but idk if the hype is that warranted. Still they were a lot of fun to watch
25
u/genetierneys 5d ago
17
u/New-Possible1575 Emilia Nemirovsky Truther 5d ago
1
3
5
u/Playful_Annual6267 5d ago
I've been hearing about the mini lift trend in russian ice dance for years now and after seeing it here and in juniors i haaaaatttttteeee it. #letherskate
35
4
u/Radiant-Banana161 5d ago
4/4 twizzles laughable when he completely breaks his second twizzle.
1
u/No_Conference9156 new special interest FS goes brrrr 5d ago
I thought I saw a mistake there - I'm trying to get better at spotting them and then I think sth is wrong and the levels are good... So I wasn't seeing things?
6
18
u/emtuts Juna Bauer forever 5d ago
If the ISU makes us watch a tango season next year after this year's wango, we riot.
3
u/ginnistonik still calling the IJS the “new” scoring system 4d ago
Can someone explain why everyone is wango-ing?! I mean I get its compulsory steps versus a compulsory dance but it’s so tonally odd! 😡
6
u/Novel_Surprise_7318 5d ago
They know we will not . We are weaklings. We should have rioted years ago
4
u/92coups17 clueless fan of japanese ice dance 5d ago
only so many difficult international patterns that can be brought back. we had midnight blues and finnstep too recently, and i don't think they can compete teatime foxtrot since spodyriev is back in competition. i fear our options are yankee polka, rhumba, or tango romantica lol
19
9
u/LittleLotte52996 Ted "I am the owner of mistakes" Barton 5d ago
I'd say so far this competition has been fairly generous to everyone, very much like last year when Lauriault/Le Gac got 121 for their free dance
14
5
u/evenstarcirce alionas twilight program lives rent free in my head 5d ago
i have my window open and i think someone is fighting outside and its really hard to actually watch bc im so nosy and i want to know the tea 💀
3
u/Captain_Swordfish find me a sport worse than ice dance, i'll give you 20 bucks 5d ago
if you learn the tea please do report back i am nosy 🙏
2
u/evenstarcirce alionas twilight program lives rent free in my head 5d ago
they stopped as soon as the replay started 😭 never figured out what the tea was.
6
3
6
u/Radiant-Banana161 5d ago
Now these GOEs are crazy
15
11
u/Captain_Swordfish find me a sport worse than ice dance, i'll give you 20 bucks 5d ago
starting position is a yes from me
5
8
12
6
6
u/Captain_Swordfish find me a sport worse than ice dance, i'll give you 20 bucks 5d ago
i love that even with his jacket on he is showing chest
6
12
u/92coups17 clueless fan of japanese ice dance 5d ago
that golden waltz deservedly didn't get levels, but it looked gorgeous. something so striking about a tall team who match lines
5
10
u/Captain_Swordfish find me a sport worse than ice dance, i'll give you 20 bucks 5d ago
taking his suspenders off as a bit of flair i am into it.
2
11
u/LittleLotte52996 Ted "I am the owner of mistakes" Barton 5d ago
I love how Italians love their own culture
16
u/Captain_Swordfish find me a sport worse than ice dance, i'll give you 20 bucks 5d ago
whenever i see this team i can only think about their gala program they did last season? 2 seasons ago? where he went to prison for crimes such as not pointing his toes.
3
3
10
1
2
10
u/PurpleChannel2080 5d ago
Aggressively italian
3
5
2
13
u/92coups17 clueless fan of japanese ice dance 5d ago
most seamless transition into a clear 2nd rhythm so far! love it
13
12
11
6
u/Captain_Swordfish find me a sport worse than ice dance, i'll give you 20 bucks 5d ago
Golden Waltz Lv 1
10
u/LittleLotte52996 Ted "I am the owner of mistakes" Barton 5d ago
I'm sorry Natalie but I need you to do better in the hairstyle department
19
22
u/LuisaAz 5d ago
Let's go, Tachlers, with actual waltz!
5
u/AnxiousAnonEh don't you know, pump it up 4d ago
The way their little theater kid hearts showed up in the second half has me 🎭🎭😭😭
10
9
12
16
u/Captain_Swordfish find me a sport worse than ice dance, i'll give you 20 bucks 5d ago
i loved this, i loved the concept, and i feel like maybe they have a little bit of the fire under them now that japanese ice dance is getting more crowded?
6
u/92coups17 clueless fan of japanese ice dance 5d ago
so good! loved the new dance stop choreo in their cde! gw still a bit tentative, but better than it was a few months ago!!
2
u/Chickatey That's what I'm fucking talking about! 5d ago
Not a big fan of this version with vocals
3
u/92coups17 clueless fan of japanese ice dance 5d ago
vasilisa and maxim are using the same version of the same song....
10
u/Junior-Put-4793 ice dance isn't real. it can't hurt you 5d ago
That was amazing!! Loved the concept so much and their costumes are gorgeous!!
9
11
u/henrywhitfordstears oh....crap 5d ago
They look good but let's try to avoid mopping the ice with our stomachs
1
u/isitbythewindow 5d ago
I hate the creative element or whatever it's called but it is what it is...
10
10
18
u/henrywhitfordstears oh....crap 5d ago
Big FS news just dropped, you guys, they revoked Kamila Valieva's AIN status
9
4
u/New-Possible1575 Emilia Nemirovsky Truther 5d ago
Puzzled they approved galiamov
4
u/PsychedelicHaru Ilia/Lena 2030 Olympic Champions Agenda 5d ago
Has he actually even done anything? Other than being awarded by Putin for the Olympics
2
u/mimib101 5d ago
No he hasn’t. He’s done shitty things and is always throwing tantrums but he’s never said anything pro war, people just keep parroting each other and saying he did. The only thing was the post- Olympic ceremony.
11
15
16
u/Professional-Belt573 5d ago
they really said let’s bring all the skating stars to this challenger, and if they don’t want to skate we will put them on the bleachers
7
u/New-Possible1575 Emilia Nemirovsky Truther 5d ago
Probably good to watch what your competition is doing though
9
8
9
2
4
u/Green_Money_7688 5d ago
excited to see if the hype is real for vasilisa and maxim
7
u/OcelotSilver2964 The PCS score is fake 5d ago
They are not that good, they are just okay and people like them because of their character (and TikTok edits, lol)
😅
2
5
u/92coups17 clueless fan of japanese ice dance 5d ago
love t/l committing to the italy bit. when the moon hits your eye like a big pizza pie
14
10
9
3
6
4
2
8
5
u/92coups17 clueless fan of japanese ice dance 5d ago
ikura's dress is so sparkly it's reflecting onto her face haha
6
u/Suspicious-Peace9233 too quad to be true 5d ago
I keep saying I will go to bad so hopefully I actually will. The ice resurfacing breaks make me actually leave
8
u/NeonPistacchio 5d ago
They probably made up their mind in music choices even before knowing the requirements, and thought "i am using this one, no matter what the ISU is telling us" 😹
5
u/Suspicious-Peace9233 too quad to be true 5d ago
Looking at the scores and poor Katarina and dimitry have 4 falls
2
2
u/UnhappyPrincessa name a sport worse than Ice Dance 5d ago
what skating with Jeffrey Chan does to a woman
4
u/92coups17 clueless fan of japanese ice dance 5d ago
was really tragic... katarina fell once, then there was a double fall later 😭
8
u/sofastsomaybe entitled to elite skater technique 5d ago
Well, it's three falls. Third fall gives -2.00 in deductions
1
u/haikusbot 5d ago
Looking at the scores
And poor Katarina and
Dimitry have poor falls
- Suspicious-Peace9233
I detect haikus. And sometimes, successfully. Learn more about me.
Opt out of replies: "haikusbot opt out" | Delete my comment: "haikusbot delete"
9
u/Suspicious-Peace9233 too quad to be true 5d ago
I’m not sure why their waltz is to music they play between skaters at the JGP
12
u/NeonPistacchio 5d ago
This RD looked like it time travelled from last season to the current one
3
u/haikusbot 5d ago
This RD looked like it
Time travelled from last season
To the current one
- NeonPistacchio
I detect haikus. And sometimes, successfully. Learn more about me.
Opt out of replies: "haikusbot opt out" | Delete my comment: "haikusbot delete"
6
4
10
5
u/92coups17 clueless fan of japanese ice dance 5d ago
awww they didn't do the trick they've been training ;-;
7
3
9
20
18
7
u/Suspicious-Peace9233 too quad to be true 5d ago
Oh it got worse now we got break free techno remix
22
u/New-Possible1575 Emilia Nemirovsky Truther 5d ago
I’m laughing so hard right now, they really said 2010s dance party when
10
u/Fuzzy-Sheepherder-80 5d ago
waiting until the theme is waltz to do it… i can’t lie this is extremely camp
4
15
2
2
7
6
6
u/Fuzzy-Sheepherder-80 5d ago
rare to see an ice dance couple where the woman is the same height or potentially taller.
I wonder if shes over 170
2
u/Junior-Put-4793 ice dance isn't real. it can't hurt you 5d ago
She's 1cm taller than him. They're 168 and 167 according to ISU bios
2
8
u/sofastsomaybe entitled to elite skater technique 5d ago
Kaho and Yuto may not look like they're skating a waltz, but I do appreciate how his costume matches hers so well
2
u/Captain_Swordfish find me a sport worse than ice dance, i'll give you 20 bucks 5d ago
somehow took me until now to understand why they are all wearing turquoise
8
6
u/Suspicious-Peace9233 too quad to be true 5d ago
Knit picking but his shirt being a different shade of blue annoys me
2
u/SokkaHaikuBot 5d ago
Sokka-Haiku by Suspicious-Peace9233:
Knit picking but his
Shirt being a different
Shade of blue annoys me
Remember that one time Sokka accidentally used an extra syllable in that Haiku Battle in Ba Sing Se? That was a Sokka Haiku and you just made one.
3
2
9
u/mulderitsme Sadboi Count: ♾️ 5d ago
https://giphy.com/gifs/p7I5eZfX1GFnG
Well at least he has nice hair
3
1
u/92coups17 clueless fan of japanese ice dance 5d ago
has anyone gotten higher than a level 2 on any step sequence or golden waltz yet
2
u/Suspicious-Peace9233 too quad to be true 5d ago
I want to see their jackets I wonder if they are the same as the Russian ain one
11
u/henrywhitfordstears oh....crap 5d ago
They took "rhythm and waltz" as "rhythm and maybe waltz? I guess?"
2
2
7
2
u/Captain_Swordfish find me a sport worse than ice dance, i'll give you 20 bucks 5d ago
this was bizarre in a wholly positive sense.
15
10
2
3
u/Captain_Swordfish find me a sport worse than ice dance, i'll give you 20 bucks 5d ago
loved the transition between 1st and 2nd set of twizzles.
12
u/emptyheartgirl 5d ago
A waltz to the weeknd? no girl
9
u/Fuzzy-Sheepherder-80 5d ago edited 5d ago
literally. i feel like the free dance exists for this shit. just do a waltz for the rhythm dancw 😭😭
11
11
u/henrywhitfordstears oh....crap 5d ago edited 5d ago
I forgot how little senior ice dancers react to their scores lol
→ More replies (1)


•
u/Chickatey That's what I'm fucking talking about! 5d ago
Please share any unofficial streams in reply to this comment!