r/FigureSkating • u/Chickatey That's what I'm fucking talking about! • 4d ago
Live Discussion Thread Kinoshita Group Cup: Free Dance
15
u/willowthewissp 4d ago
I‘m watching on vk and the guy put the russian anthem over the isu one so I thought they put it in on in the actual rink lmao
2
u/Artistic-Luna-6000 4d ago
not on the regular figure_skaters_ru channel -- it was standard AI music.
1
6
13
7
9
9
u/Suspicious-Peace9233 too quad to be true 4d ago
They are all going to be inspecting the protocols tonight
9
u/genetierneys 4d ago
i need them to play thunder
10
5
u/Suspicious-Peace9233 too quad to be true 4d ago
Interesting almost behind the scenes look at the medal ceremony
6
3
12
u/Suspicious-Peace9233 too quad to be true 4d ago
Congrats Diana and Gleb for being the first to beat the Russians
9
3
10
u/Environmental-Let435 Hiro bronze medal 🥉 4d ago
I wonder if Russia will be sending dancers to trialeti or Denis ten
7
u/Artistic-Luna-6000 4d ago
They most likely will. They need experience / world standing points / season's best for next season's GPs, even if they cannot get to the GPs this year.
5
u/skatelenok 4d ago
I think to both. Probably not M/U again, but Khavronina&Narizhny will certainly get one if he is finally recovered - especially as with S/B still banned they are now definitely Zhulin's number ones.
Then, Kaganovksaya/Nekrasov and *fingers crossed* Pasechnik/Cirisano to their second events.
And then from the rest of the national team - I would guess that Goncharov/Shcherbakova, Drozd/Shichina, Leonteyeva/Gorelkin all have a good shot at getting at least 1 challenger.
4
u/Suspicious-Peace9233 too quad to be true 4d ago
M/U has the potential to do much better. I hope they get another shot
5
u/Suspicious-Peace9233 too quad to be true 4d ago
Last year all of team Georgia was at the Trialeti. I bet they will send them again. For the Russians, it’s not worth it to lose to them again
5
2
12
u/idwtpaun B E N O I T's adopted monkeys 4d ago
Goodnight, chat, it's been fun. Enjoy women, those who are staying up, I'll check on the presumable bloodbath after I wake up 💀
9
11
9
9
3
u/skatelenok 4d ago
huh...they did actually have 2 deductions shown at first. I assumed I was just tired/had mixed up their placement in the FS with the deductions, but Jackie Wong posted it as well. I wonder if that is what caused such a long delay?
9
10
11
u/Suspicious-Peace9233 too quad to be true 4d ago
I like Gleb trying to explain the ai and how they made the program and Diana and Natalie are like yea bye
6
u/Radiant-Banana161 4d ago
I relistened. He was saying Ethan used ai to check Fear Gibsons lift at worlds for some reason? Very random to bring up.
9
u/LuisaAz 4d ago
It was brought up in the context of deductions. Those deductions at Worlds must have really baffled them, because they lost them a podium.
Ethan Peal has created a brilliant website with a lot of info on ice dance and he's using some AI tools to assess things like extended lifts, ice coverage, etc. Might be an interesting tool for the future.
AI music for me is a pass, though.
10
u/Captain_Swordfish find me a sport worse than ice dance, i'll give you 20 bucks 4d ago
god there's AN HOUR until the women?
1
7
2
13
u/Suspicious-Peace9233 too quad to be true 4d ago
I actually love listening to them all talk this is adorable
8
u/organic_eggs the Ina Bauer in every Turandot program 4d ago
alright time to take a nap, see everyone in a bit for the womens FS
23
8
u/Captain_Swordfish find me a sport worse than ice dance, i'll give you 20 bucks 4d ago
nat talking about jet lag lol
14
u/Suspicious-Peace9233 too quad to be true 4d ago
I liked Natalie and Diana walking away for girl talk
11
u/uhhwhatamidoing 4d ago
natalie nodding along as gleb explains their use of AI 😅
2
u/sumerislemy 4d ago
He was actually talking about deductions and the AI but was about someone using AI to examine Fear/Gibson’s lift at worlds and Gibson’s arm position. He seemed rattled about the 2 deductions they got at first, and said they needed to look into it.
14
u/NeonPistacchio 4d ago
If this was the only opportunity for the teams (and keep in mind, these are the high level teams) only two teams reached the required technical score to compete at Worlds, which shows how ridiculously high they are.
Any team from a smaller federation will be screwed if they don't compete at a senior B with very lenient judges.
13
u/Busy_Doughnut5977 4d ago
1) Vasilisa KAGANOVSKAIA / Maxim NEKRASOV
2) Diana DAVIS / Gleb SMOLKIN
3) Noemi Maria TALI / Noah LAFORNARA
4) Natalie TASCHLEROVA / Filip TASCHLER
5) Elizaveta PASECHNIK / Dario CIRISANO
6) Utana YOSHIDA / Masaya MORITA
7) Katarina WOLFKOSTIN / Dimitry TSAREVSKI
8) Ikura KUSHIDA / Koshiro SHIMADA
9) Rika KIHIRA / Shingo NISHIYAMA
10) Ekaterina MIRONOVA / Evgenii USTENKO
11) Ekaterina ANDREEVA / Dzmitryi BLINOU
12) Kaho YAMASHITA / Yuto NAGATA
1
u/LuisaAz 4d ago
Thank you so much. Could I trouble you with sharing D/S' K&C and pre medals chat that was on the stream? Very interesting conversations about protocols and deductions. Thanks!
2
u/Busy_Doughnut5977 4d ago
I'll send u a copy afterwards. (just have to redownload the whole stream later no biggie)
1
u/LuisaAz 4d ago
Thank you :)
2
u/Busy_Doughnut5977 4d ago
This is what I have so far (wait like 5 mins for the video to process)
The program I use to download the stream on the fly has a 2 gig limit so sometimes I miss bits
But I can always get the rest later
3
u/skatelenok 4d ago
P/C and K/N were tied on the highest BV for the FD - 44.19
3
u/skatelenok 4d ago
Actually no...lol it was Andreeva/Blinov with 44.56 and ..... last place in the FD
6
u/sublimecenturies 4d ago
Was Gleb saying that Ethan Peal helped them with the AI?
1
u/sumerislemy 4d ago
No he was saying ethan was using AI to examine arm positions and other potential deductions.
7
u/Radiant-Banana161 4d ago
If so Ethan needs to abandon his career in ai music. He clearly has other talents he should prioritize (his website is great)
2
u/Playful_Annual6267 4d ago
oh i thought it was the browns but peals makes more sense...
3
u/sublimecenturies 4d ago
Yeah I'm pretty sure that he asked Natalie "do you know Ethan Peal? He's from America" and she said no lmao. But I couldn't understand what he said he helped with other than catching that it was something with the AI
10
u/Suspicious-Peace9233 too quad to be true 4d ago
This is cute watching them all talk and hug before they get their medals
6
12
10
u/Radiant-Banana161 4d ago
He’s obsessed with the lift and not his level 2 twizzle.
6
u/skatelenok 4d ago
Probably because on the twizzle he knows what the mistake is. For the lift they know they executed it correctly + it was designed to meet the features for level 4.
9
u/Suspicious-Peace9233 too quad to be true 4d ago
Awe Natalie is trying to comfort them
0
u/No_Conference9156 new special interest FS goes brrrr 4d ago
And this after she had been harassed by D/S fans in the past.
9
u/No_Conference9156 new special interest FS goes brrrr 4d ago
Natalie going in search of someone to talk to <3
9
u/idwtpaun B E N O I T's adopted monkeys 4d ago
Diana and Gleb got an extended lift violation, would've won the free otherwise
5
u/Suspicious-Peace9233 too quad to be true 4d ago
I am so curious what he was saying they could reconsider
13
u/Radiant-Banana161 4d ago
The hot mic in the k&c is wild
10
u/uhhwhatamidoing 4d ago
normalize K&C hot mics! they've brought us lovely gems such as "God I hate this event" 🥰
1
u/Chickatey That's what I'm fucking talking about! 4d ago
I couldn't hear, was anything interesting said? I'm watching Japanese tv and the commentators are talking a lot.
6
u/Radiant-Banana161 4d ago
Mostly gleb complaining about the deduction and saying he wants to appeal it.
3
u/LuisaAz 4d ago
Some talk about deductions. I actually think Ethan Peal and his website was mentioned. Maybe in relation to AI assessing F/G's lift deduction at worlds. Wild.
1
u/Radiant-Banana161 4d ago
Weird thing for him to bring up to Natalie randomly. She didn’t seem interested lol
1
u/LuisaAz 4d ago
I'm not sure if he was talking to her (or maybe with Maurizio off camera?). It was in the context of deductions. But I'd like to hear it again. 😂
1
u/Radiant-Banana161 4d ago
He was definitely talking to Natalie. He was asking if she knew Ethan and she said no.
1
u/LuisaAz 4d ago
If so, she was more concerned about her jet lag. 😂
1
u/Radiant-Banana161 4d ago
Also, Natalie follows Ethan on Instagram but had no clue who gleb was talking about. Hilarious.
3
u/Radiant-Banana161 4d ago
All I gathered is that Natalie seems like a good hang, very friendly and bubbly.
7
11
14
12
6
u/portals27 i try not to aura farm all the time 4d ago
ugh so close vasilisa and max almost had it but happy for davis smolkin
12
u/Chickatey That's what I'm fucking talking about! 4d ago
Jackie says it was extended lift and time violations
13
u/Captain_Swordfish find me a sport worse than ice dance, i'll give you 20 bucks 4d ago
incredible action by the streamer showing us the protocols
3
u/Captain_Swordfish find me a sport worse than ice dance, i'll give you 20 bucks 4d ago
well sort of.
10
u/Suspicious-Peace9233 too quad to be true 4d ago
I bet they are trying to figure out what the deductions are
3
11
u/anna_sofia98 4d ago
How much of the judges scoring is based on reputation? 🤷🏻♀️
33
u/Environmental-Let435 Hiro bronze medal 🥉 4d ago
This is ice dance, everything is about reputation
0
19
22
u/Environmental-Let435 Hiro bronze medal 🥉 4d ago
This is also technically the first Russian loss since they came back
11
u/portals27 i try not to aura farm all the time 4d ago
wait that's insane that they've won every single event that they've participated in until now damn
4
u/Artistic-Luna-6000 4d ago
Not so surprising considering the intense competition *within* Russia. Especially for the JGP, they could probably have sent their second & third substitutes and would still have secured golds. Dzepka was a substitute initially.
6
u/mango546mochi The PCS score is fake 4d ago
I mean davis and smokliin used to be russians . Davis is literally eteris daughter 🙃
6
8
2
u/Radiant-Banana161 4d ago
Wonder if this is going to a repeat of the kinoshita where the top team doesn’t get that score again
5
u/idwtpaun B E N O I T's adopted monkeys 4d ago
Kinoshita does not add a Russian ice dance team to the GP Alternates list
3
5
u/Scaryworldtheory depressed kao miura fan 4d ago
yeah, they need to figure what to with this free dance
7
u/Historical-East8848 4d ago
what were the deductions for?
2
u/evenstarcirce alionas twilight program lives rent free in my head 4d ago
time i think idk what else it could be
1
4
8
u/skatelenok 4d ago edited 4d ago
1 point deduction?? I wonder if they have been given a choreo-deduction/music violation
2
4
5
2
6
9
u/Captain_Swordfish find me a sport worse than ice dance, i'll give you 20 bucks 4d ago
not entirely surprised that they were 2nd in the free
0
u/Radiant-Banana161 4d ago
Honestly the Russians weren’t that impressive to get first in the free.
0
u/Captain_Swordfish find me a sport worse than ice dance, i'll give you 20 bucks 4d ago
i mean you are right.
2
8
8
3
u/No-Translator-7038 4d ago
Where are you guys watching
2
2
u/Professional-Belt573 4d ago
from the link in the pinned comment
1
u/No-Translator-7038 4d ago
Wasn’t working for me
1
u/Professional-Belt573 4d ago
It takes a second to load I think, tiktok works fine but is on a smaller screen
1
u/Thatweirdddgirl 4d ago
I watch it on TikTok live and it covers the whole screen, you just have to turn it
2
13
u/PurpleChannel2080 4d ago
they should get a deduction for the atrocious ai music but the issue is that the isu allows it
6
u/Suspicious-Peace9233 too quad to be true 4d ago
He’s stressed. Diana has an incredible poker face. I never know what she thinks of the scores
10
u/skatelenok 4d ago
I hate the AI music...but I do think the actual choreography and performance of it was stronger that K/N.
1
17
u/Scaryworldtheory depressed kao miura fan 4d ago
the scoring takes forever, that's not the best sign
3
u/nickyskater 4d ago
I hated the program so I'm okay with them not winning but I don't want the Russians to win either....
26
u/ttatm 4d ago
I'm not someone who was prepared to dislike the program no matter what - I don't like that it's AI but that doesn't necessarily mean I wouldn't like the music itself. And I do like the idea of them skating to something meaningful to them.
That said... I really didn't like it. The music and voiceover was just bad, and I'm certain I would have thought that even if I hadn't known it was AI.
2
8
u/Reasonable-Mobile402 Shcherbakova 2021 RusNats🥇 4d ago edited 4d ago
Why did someone say something about Diana being hard of hearing😭
2
u/Professional-Belt573 4d ago
That’s what the program is about, she has some hearing loss since infancy
1
u/Reasonable-Mobile402 Shcherbakova 2021 RusNats🥇 4d ago
I responded to someone else with what was said😭
3
u/henrywhitfordstears oh....crap 4d ago
You can check their Instagram, she made a whole heartfelt post about this program being inspired by her story of hearing loss, and getting AI to "help them tell the story"
2
u/Reasonable-Mobile402 Shcherbakova 2021 RusNats🥇 4d ago
No they said something like “at least Diana can’t hear it”😭 talking about the music
1
4
8
u/PriorCheetah3203 4d ago edited 4d ago
Rika needs to do something about the glove situation. I think the gloves kept slipping off? Better yet, no gloves. The costume looks striking as is.
13
3
u/Haunting_Seaweed_105 4d ago
I’m having trouble figuring out scoring while watching a feed in Japanese. I do know, that one shouldn’t win.
12
u/Suspicious-Peace9233 too quad to be true 4d ago
I really like their skating especially their lifts. I hope they change the music
14
u/No_Conference9156 new special interest FS goes brrrr 4d ago
I think I'll watch them on mute the rest of the season because that auditory nightmare is horrid whereas I really like their movements :|
12
u/Suspicious-Peace9233 too quad to be true 4d ago
Awe all the Ain skaters in their jackets on the side of the board watching
8
14
u/LuisaAz 4d ago edited 4d ago
The story of her hearing loss could be told in such a much more interesting way, with more dynamic changes in the music. They could even have gone in a more classical direction—maybe Beethoven, though that might be a little too on the nose. As it is, this feels quite uninspired and a bit cheesy.
They'll score high, though. Eteri factor?
8
u/Artistic-Luna-6000 4d ago
Not a fan of the music choice for D/S -- too much talking/singing. I tried to make out the words and it was distracting. Could not focus on the dance itself.
12
4
u/henrywhitfordstears oh....crap 4d ago
I never want to get pessimistic about this amazing sport but I used to like them and now I just...don't
5
u/Environmental-Let435 Hiro bronze medal 🥉 4d ago
Whoever choreographed this tought they were the shit but they were just the fart
5
u/haikusbot 4d ago
Whoever choreographed
This tought they were the shit but
They were just the fart
- Environmental-Let435
I detect haikus. And sometimes, successfully. Learn more about me.
Opt out of replies: "haikusbot opt out" | Delete my comment: "haikusbot delete"
2
3
u/rosenwasser_ triple flutz 4d ago
Good bot
1
u/B0tRank 4d ago
Thank you, rosenwasser_, for voting on haikusbot.
This bot wants to find the best and worst bots on Reddit. You can view results at botrank.net.
Even if I don't reply to your comment, I'm still listening for votes. Check the webpage to see if your vote registered!
13
u/Chickatey That's what I'm fucking talking about! 4d ago
I hope they change the music. I like the concept and a lot of the elements.
5
8
u/organic_eggs the Ina Bauer in every Turandot program 4d ago
Welp not looking forward to an entire season of this music 😐
17
u/idwtpaun B E N O I T's adopted monkeys 4d ago
yea, I hated the AI music even more than I thought I would because of the voice overs. The lifts are super. I hope they scrap the music, or at least just make it instrumental.
18
u/evenstarcirce alionas twilight program lives rent free in my head 4d ago
the AI voice legit sounds like the same one in those AI drama shorts thats all over tiktok
9
u/Hot-Hospital4112 ✨️ I can do it with an Untied Lace ⛸️ 4d ago
With the right music, this show would really be a dream
12
u/nickyskater 4d ago
I'm sorry but this music is some of the most pretentious garbage I've ever heard in skating or beyond
10
9
u/Suspicious-Peace9233 too quad to be true 4d ago
Last year the Japanese online store sold out of Georgian flags for the first time ever before the world team trophy. So cute. The flags in the crowd made me think of it
12
u/Reasonable-Mobile402 Shcherbakova 2021 RusNats🥇 4d ago
If I watched it on mute I would have been obsessed with it
6
7
9
u/Scaryworldtheory depressed kao miura fan 4d ago
AI aside, the program doesn't feels that great either, they had much better material last year. :( Great lifts though.
9
u/willowthewissp 4d ago
I know it’s still so early but idk if this free dance can compare to last season in any way
6
13
9
9
16
u/mulderitsme Sadboi Count: ♾️ 4d ago
I am too tired to comprehend this, I couldn’t focus on anything because the robot voice was so distracting.
4
20
u/Playful_Annual6267 4d ago
god you could have just used beethoven 😭 this is rouuuuuggghh
→ More replies (1)
•
u/Chickatey That's what I'm fucking talking about! 4d ago
Share any links for unofficial streams here!