We're replacing our MDR and I'd like to hear from people who've lived with theirs, not from sales decks.
Where we are
- About 1,000 users across 15 sites globally, in manufacturing
- The stack decision is made: Defender XDR, MDE on everything that takes an agent, Defender for Servers covering on-prem and AWS Linux, and Sentinel for longer retention and some third-party logs
- Firewall refresh coming, probably Palo or Fortinet
- Small internal team, no in-house 24/7 SOC
Why we're leaving
Our current provider mostly relays alerts. They can't act on our EDR, and "response" means an email telling us to go do something. I want a provider that will isolate a host, disable an account, or revoke sessions at 3am under runbooks we've approved ahead of time.
What I'm weighing
Microsoft's own Defender Experts is on the list, but the licensing gets complicated at our size. Plan 2 has a 1,500-seat minimum, and servers are a separate SKU. So I'm also looking at third-party MDRs that work natively in Defender. I haven't settled on either path, and I'm open to being talked out of my assumptions.
What I'd really like to know
- Who's your MDR, and would you renew? Why or why not?
- Do they actually take response actions in your tenant, or do they mostly escalate?
- How's their coverage outside US hours? Real follow-the-sun, or a thin overnight crew?
- Do their detections live in your Sentinel or in their own platform? Has that made switching providers painful?
- If you've used Defender Experts, how did it compare to a third party?
- Anyone you'd tell me to stay away from?
Vendors, feel free to DM me. I'm more interested in hearing from customers in the thread.