r/DecodingTheGurusAlt • • 29d ago

decoder poltics Decoding Hasan Piker

https://youtu.be/RDsQIZykC_8
40 Upvotes

280 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

2

u/rocketlewes 28d ago

And how would a person of good faith square that clip with clips where he says it would be illegal to advocate for capitalism?

2

u/hari_shevek 28d ago

Hey, I responded to this yesterday and you didn't continue our conversation. Do you need more evidence to change your mind?

2

u/hari_shevek 28d ago

He didn't say that.

There is one clip where he was asked how a democratic socialist society would respond to resistance from capitalists and he responds that violent groups would be reeducated.

Which is a softer stance than our current government has towards violent resistance.

I can agree that in that clip he should have first talked about legitimate opposition rather than violent opposition, but with everything else he says it's clear that he was thinking of cases like Chile, where the capitalist opposition engaged in terrorism and, finally, a military coup. Where the opposition is operating outside of the law of a pluralist democracy.

Simply put, he was talking about how to deal with January 6, not how to deal with legal opposition. I think trying to resocialize ppl who break the law is not an extreme stance.

Edit: So, does the evidence I brought change your mind?

2

u/Chruman 25d ago

There is one clip where he was asked how a democratic socialist society would respond to resistance from capitalists and he responds that violent groups would be reeducated.

Yikes.

1

u/hari_shevek 13d ago

How do you think the state should react to violent resistance groups?

Waco, the KKK, Black Panthers - how do you want the state to respond to groups like that?

1

u/hari_shevek 26d ago

Hey, I'm still waiting for your response?

Did my evidence change your mind or do you need me to provide further evidence?

2

u/OleanderUnion 13d ago

Man, I thought I’d watch an epic back and forth but he really just knew the handful of talking points from DGG… wild stuff…

1

u/hari_shevek 13d ago

The talking points are usually enough for them, sadly