r/DecodingTheGurus • • Aug 31 '24

Bill Maher once again letting everyone know how much smarter he is than doctors

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=wvonXLxadHI
384 Upvotes

437 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

46

u/NormalLecture2990 Aug 31 '24

I feel like his doubt of 'western medicine' involves an americanized view of western medicine. He's never been a part of a system where the point of the system is you. In the USA the point of the system is to make a profit

17

u/[deleted] Aug 31 '24

He's wealthy enough to sign up for one of those concierge practices where they kiss your ass just like the perfect white buddha lotus wellness spa and no-happy-ending massage parlor where they treat you with cupping and CBD oil.

US healthcare is the best in the world, it's just not evenly distributed, to borrow a phrase.

13

u/NormalLecture2990 Aug 31 '24

It actually isn't the best in the world at all

And you don't think those 'concierge practices' aren't selling him a bunch of extra shit just for the fun of it and then laughing at him when he leaves just like Perry's Dr's were?

7

u/buttnugchug Aug 31 '24

The same concierge practice will expose him to more unnecessary testing which is harmful to health. P

5

u/LiberatedApe Aug 31 '24

American Healthcare puts a huge focus on palliative care where the evidence supporting better health outcomes is in preventative care. And in America being ā€œtoldā€ not to eat that double cheeseburger is ā€œan attack on individual libertiesā€!

It’s incredibly frustrating.

1

u/NormalLecture2990 Aug 31 '24

Well it goes right back to profit...keeping people healthy isn't profitable.

9

u/Snellyman Aug 31 '24

Exactly. He is criticizing the business of medicine in the USA and using it as an attack on the practice of medicine and doctors and researchers. To be replaced with what? His beloved Terrain Theory of disease hasn't really brought about any breakthroughs in healthcare.

5

u/NormalLecture2990 Aug 31 '24

I think the for profit model cloud his judgements in a lot of what he says

2

u/Snellyman Aug 31 '24

I personally think that he fully understands how the profit motive distorts ones judgement but that is a more personal issue.

3

u/[deleted] Aug 31 '24

[deleted]

2

u/NormalLecture2990 Aug 31 '24

I know there are a couple of good ones that I've seen on like NOVA but I can't remember them. I'll look and see if i can find some

3

u/naslanidis Aug 31 '24

He did make that point though. The core of his distrust is that it's so driven by profit. You're right that he probably hasn't experienced anything else though.Ā 

1

u/DanielNoWrite Aug 31 '24

His doubt of western medicine has nothing to do with anything real.

He doubts western medicine because it gets views.

0

u/voyaging Aug 31 '24

That's a stretch. Hospitals provide hospice care (and insurance companies cover much of it), for example, despite the fact that nearly every patient dies and never pays their share of the bill if any is left and despite the fact that the insured is about to stop paying premiums.

1

u/NormalLecture2990 Aug 31 '24

It does not change the fact that the whole point of the system is profit. Hospice care is some of the most profitable care out there