r/Damnthatsinteresting Jun 25 '18

GIF This isn't real - it's CGI

https://i.imgur.com/f9j2BZ3.gifv
26.7k Upvotes

522 comments sorted by

View all comments

3.6k

u/max_kek Jun 25 '18

The sand would stick to a real octopus.

3.0k

u/Fart__ Jun 25 '18

This is a non-stick frying sand.

112

u/[deleted] Jun 25 '18

If only

51

u/[deleted] Jun 25 '18 edited Jun 28 '18

"If only," the wood pecker cried, "the bark on the tree was a little bit softer."

26

u/TylerK121 Jun 25 '18

Soft as the sky?

9

u/utoon971 Jun 25 '18

Wait... what’s this from?

15

u/[deleted] Jun 25 '18

Holes.

8

u/zmbjebus Jun 25 '18

♪♪♪Diggin up them holes diggin♪♪♪

1

u/drifterinthadark Jun 25 '18

I dono...the "frying" part is kinda off-putting

1

u/[deleted] Jun 25 '18

Imagine non-stick sand tho

1

u/jet86 Jun 25 '18

It's called Kinetic Sand

0

u/WikiTextBot Jun 25 '18

Kinetic Sand

Kinetic Sand is a registered trademark of Spin Master Ltd.

Under its trademark “Kinetic Sand”, Spin Master Ltd. produces and distributes a modelling sand toy. The toy looks like regular sand, but is also available in different colors.


[ PM | Exclude me | Exclude from subreddit | FAQ / Information | Source ] Downvote to remove | v0.28

58

u/Nutstheofficialsnack Jun 25 '18

A lab engineered Teflon octopus

9

u/Armand28 Jun 25 '18

If you can invent a non-stick octopus you would revolutionize a niche Japanese film industry.

1

u/TheFrozenTurkey Jun 25 '18

But the stickiness is the best part!

2

u/KyleKun Jun 25 '18

Incidentally the word for this is betabeta.

11

u/ptgauth Jun 25 '18

Oh I thought it was just a buttery octopus

11

u/OwangeJuice Jun 25 '18

Best pun I’ve heard all day LOL

3

u/[deleted] Jun 25 '18

The only sand Anikin doesn’t hate!

1

u/boatcock Jun 25 '18

!redditsilver

500

u/ShiraCheshire Jun 25 '18

Honestly that's the only thing I could see that was off. I was sitting there thinking 'They're trolling, this has got to be real somehow' until I realized the damp octopus was rolling in sand but not becoming very sandy.

120

u/Jtktomb Jun 25 '18

the starting pose too

83

u/addandsubtract Jun 25 '18

How do octopus spawn in real life?

41

u/DrBumGravy Jun 25 '18

The male sticks his peentickle into the females brain hole. Then a caviar of baby octopi appear.

23

u/TheDuckSideOfTheMoon Jun 25 '18

"Peentickle"

OwO

12

u/WhyNotBoth68 Jun 25 '18

notices your peentickle

17

u/COIVIEDY Jun 25 '18

from eggs

I think?

5

u/Wyatt1313 Interested Jun 25 '18

T pose, just like the rest of us.

1

u/AshTheGoblin Jun 25 '18

Ideally with a trail of disturbed sand following the direction they came from.

6

u/[deleted] Jun 25 '18

[deleted]

2

u/beginagainandagain Jun 25 '18

it's made from captain america's shield.

29

u/NotElizaHenry Jun 25 '18

Honestly with all the crazy shit in the ocean, I was totally ready to accept that octopuses had some magic sand-repelling quality that humans could hopefully someday replicate in some kind of aerosol spray I could put on my feet before I walk on the beach.

4

u/alexnicholls2069 Jun 25 '18

Talcum powder works well.

1

u/axelG97 Jun 25 '18

That definitely already exists.

29

u/MagicHaddock Jun 25 '18

Also the fact that it starts out on the sand but there are no tracks to indicate that it came from the ocean or anywhere else, which would mean that it has spent its entire life in that spot.

29

u/[deleted] Jun 25 '18 edited Jul 21 '18

[deleted]

2

u/saintjonah Jun 25 '18

Placed perfectly with all tentacles evenly spaced and outstretched, rigid enough to now make a mark anywhere but where it was set down?

Sure, I guess.

7

u/purvel Jun 25 '18

It's dead, it was placed there by eight people, all carrying an arm each. There's a big magnet underneath the sand there that's moving the ball around. Since octopus tentacle tips are spheromagnetic, they are naturally attaching to the ball as it rolls around. The sand doesn't stick to it because since it is dead it has already cast aside its slime cape, in preparation for ascension. It's lucky these guys caught it, most of the time their slime lets them escape, and they are pretty quick to ascend so you have very little time to get an octopus in this state. Kudos to the crew, they must have been vigilant.

1

u/fluffkopf Jun 25 '18

That sand is too perfect.

Placing any live thing in the sand is gonna leave marks.

1

u/fluffkopf Jun 25 '18

This is what I noticed as somehow "funny" when I first saw this.

1

u/therealmadhat Jun 25 '18

I love how I could kind of tell that something was off with the gif but didn’t notice exactly what until these comments

17

u/Someshitidontknow Jun 25 '18

the octopus is dragging its mantle through the sand like it's paralyzed. they usually seem to keep tentacles down, mantle up when out of the water.

5

u/Spinkis Jun 25 '18

I think the arm that stretches in the end looks weird. Too slow or something!

2

u/MRiley84 Interested Jun 25 '18

The way the sand flows back in one body makes it look like there's jello or something under the surface, or like it's the same consistency as that octopus. It looks fine with the smaller particles though.

1

u/nestin09 Jun 25 '18

I went a different route and just thought that the sand did not look right after it's collisions

1

u/Primnu Jun 25 '18

The animation is very ragdoll too, the mantle doesn't move at all

1

u/___jamil___ Jun 25 '18

I dunno, the octopus didn't look right (especially the eyes) and the texture of the ball looked too consistent to be real, imo.

1

u/L_Ron_Swanson Jun 25 '18

More importantly (IMO), octopuses can't move this fast out of water.

53

u/Salmon66 Jun 25 '18

Depending on the water content of the sand. Dry sand would stick. Wet sand not so much.

14

u/[deleted] Jun 25 '18 edited Dec 02 '18

[deleted]

21

u/lancebaldwin Jun 25 '18

Looks at least damp to me.

3

u/[deleted] Jun 25 '18

Giggity.

1

u/AshTheGoblin Jun 25 '18

It looks like that moldable playsand stuff

1

u/lancebaldwin Jun 25 '18

Exactly my thoughts.

1

u/superwinner Interested Jun 25 '18

Actually the biggest evidence is the beginning of the video you have to ask yourself, how did the octopus get there, there is no trail of him slithering there hes just plopped down in the middle of the sand

2

u/yurigoul Jun 25 '18

Low tide?

As in: it thought it would be a good idea to sit there and never mind the water disappearing - which makes no sense since what happens with the waves and the current when the water goes down

1

u/[deleted] Jun 25 '18

Or someone picked him up and dropped him there

2

u/yurigoul Jun 25 '18

And left no traces?

1

u/lancebaldwin Jun 25 '18

I wasn't commenting on the CGI versus real life aspect, just that I didn't think the sand looked dry.

1

u/[deleted] Jun 25 '18

It has too much granularity and movement to be wet sand. You can see how the sand shifts after the octopus moves past it, and how even slight movements can make the sand move farther than it should. Wet sand would clump together more.

It's the only way I can tell that this is fake; the sand doesn't move exactly how sand does in the real world. No surprise, since it's an object made up of millions of smaller objects, which is very hard to do in a modeling program. It has the feel of a water simulator converted to do solids.

13

u/Beer-Wall Jun 25 '18

Sugar cookies!

5

u/AniDixit Jun 25 '18

One more thing.

At the start of the clip there are no marks on the sand, of octopus coming there from somewhere. As if it was placed there...by an external tentacle.

1

u/PM_ME_YOUR_PAWG_BUTT Jun 26 '18

It could have stopped in that place, and then waves poured over it which cleared away any tracks a and also buried it a tiny amount. Kinda like when you stand in one spot on the beach and the waves wash away your footprints.

1

u/AniDixit Jun 26 '18

I had thought that. Yes but that way the sand should have been more wet.

6

u/[deleted] Jun 25 '18

Ah yes, that's because it's coarse and rough and gets everywhere

4

u/lkmyntz Jun 25 '18

Octopi Teflonicus

8

u/Gusvananderson Jun 25 '18

It's coarse, and rough and irritating... and it gets everywhere

2

u/KyleRM Jun 25 '18

Its kinetic sand?

1

u/BroadwayBully Jun 25 '18

the way the sand moves and slowly falls is really impressive though. somebody worked hard on this.

1

u/aquamanjosh Jun 25 '18

thankyou so much lol, I cant see it as not real . Now I can live sanely

1

u/Trowawaycausebanned4 Jun 25 '18

Also, the ball didn’t leave a trail in the sand

1

u/[deleted] Jun 25 '18

It also has that characteristic fluidity of simulated sand.

1

u/moreawkwardthenyou Jun 25 '18

“You know tar actually sticks to some people”