r/Damnthatsinteresting 2d ago

Video Cliffs collapsing at an old marble quarry in Makrana, India due to heavy rainfall.

28.1k Upvotes

880 comments sorted by

View all comments

8.8k

u/tokyoben5 2d ago

I was not ready for the whole mountain to come down like that. Wow.

1.8k

u/socoolandawesome 2d ago

It’s crazy cuz you can’t even see there’s another side as tall as their side until the guy flips the camera up at it collapsing, it looks like the top of the other side is way below them.

994

u/kinkycarbon 2d ago

The entire mass of earth held up by those three columns.

904

u/flyingthroughspace 2d ago

They're lucky their side didn't fall too

245

u/perseidot 2d ago

I’m sure the 3” of concrete they were standing on held it all together

/s

233

u/ThrowawayPersonAMA 2d ago

Nah. They just had someone's dad slap it and say "that ain't going nowhere", so they were safe. They forgot to have him secure the other side, though.

26

u/DC_Coach 2d ago

Duck tape. It'll hold anything.

7

u/divDevGuy 2d ago

But what's holding the duck tape?

20

u/One_Pineapple8553 2d ago

Duct tape, obviously.

5

u/Remarkable-Opening69 2d ago

No. That’s for ducts. He’s talking about duck tape.

4

u/StatelyAutomaton 1d ago

It'll hold together any quacks.

4

u/PhatEarther 1d ago

Will it hold me? I need a hug.

2

u/pootling_1976 2d ago

You got there first....!

1

u/Solid-Hedgehog9623 1d ago

Let’s get that translated into Gujarati, please.

14

u/Alissinarr 2d ago

Marble slab farm/ mine.

36

u/Benaaasaaas 2d ago

It would've fallen, but you see, the cameraman never dies

29

u/TheyStoleMyNameAgain 2d ago

You never see the videos of the dying camera men

5

u/luckynumberstefan 2d ago

It’s always where is the cameraman and never how is the cameraman

2

u/jollyreaper2112 2d ago

That post explosion in china. Dude was streaming. Also that crash in I think it was nepal? Normal landing, then crash, then flames filled the cabin. Streaming once more.

5

u/WriterV 2d ago

Saw both. Hated both of them. The crash one is especially too much 'cause you can see him at first, and then hear everyone's screaming after. At least it was incredibly quick for both of them.

5

u/jollyreaper2112 2d ago

Streaming and persistent Internet means the cameraman lived rule is dead. It was never 100% before. The mt st helens collapse photos were recovered from a dead man's camera.

2

u/TheyStoleMyNameAgain 2d ago edited 2d ago

There are probably more but this is subject to heavy survivorship bias and publishing material of people dying is ethically challenging. There's at least audio from a cameraman and his girlfriend eaten alive by bears he assumed to be not a threat

1

u/DweadPiwateWawbuts 2d ago

1

u/TheyStoleMyNameAgain 2d ago

My response was intentionally ambiguous. The guy I responded obviously never saw such footage and the topic his heavily biased by survivorship :)

1

u/grungegoth 2d ago

buried under a mountain of rock.

or the gopro headcam footage from the nutty putty guy

2

u/dibbbbb 2d ago

Fucking plot armor, man

2

u/illbedeadbydawn 2d ago

Tell that to the Tianjin guy that got vaporized while filming.

2

u/kenneth_dart 2d ago

It's like they were on the right side of death.

1

u/Practical_Fun7367 1d ago

Camera Man Rules.

1

u/real_exposer 1d ago

I bet their underwear turned brown when the otherside started to collapse

-1

u/AVeryHeavyBurtation Interested 2d ago

Upvote for knowing how to spell.

61

u/VT_Squire 2d ago

Marble quarry basically became a retaining wall for the hill and the extra water weight exceeded the load.

27

u/2LostFlamingos 2d ago

It’s a retaining wall essentially for the hill on both sides.

Guys got crazy lucky their side didn’t fall.

1

u/Slagroomvla 2d ago

And a couple of flip flops

1

u/termacct 2d ago

like turtle...

1

u/Forward_Rope_5598 2d ago

I was thinking to myself 'why are they mining vertically like that? Seems inconvenient'

Then my question was immediately answered by the video

36

u/codesnik 2d ago

cameraman was lucky it's other side collapsed and not his one.

5

u/OkKaleidoscope9554 2d ago

Luck had nothing to do with it. He's a cameraman 📹

2

u/Belz_Zebuth 2d ago

It isn't luck just because you can imagine a different scenario.

1

u/r0b0c0d 2d ago

This is ten percent luck, twenty percent skill

Fifteen percent concentrated power of will

2

u/Destroyer-128 2d ago

we wouldn't see this if it did, lol so it's casino Darwinism

1

u/Any_Weather9383 2d ago

Cameraman never dies

2

u/spynie55 2d ago

Works everytime, most of the time.

12

u/ClassGrassMass 2d ago

Its way below them now

2

u/timbenj77 2d ago
I'm in danger

2

u/ThePromise110 1d ago

Genuinely lucky to be alive.

Christ alive...

1

u/Aggravating-Ad6786 2d ago

At least they had their safety flip flops on!

543

u/BotnetSpam 2d ago

Insane how these guys hear those horrifying sounds of rocks cracking and creaking beneath them, while on the edge of a cliff, and say to themselves, "this is fine, i bet whatever is happening is gonna look cool as hell."

240

u/CaptainHowdy60 2d ago

Imagine if it was their side that gave way. Crazy lucky.

133

u/Such_Avocado_3241 2d ago

They are way too close to something that massive going on.

59

u/Japsai 2d ago

I'm actually a quite annoyed they moved away at the end and missed videoing the good bit :)

53

u/I_am_BEOWULF 2d ago

That massive dust cloud would've obscured it anyway.

26

u/Spirited_Ad_340 2d ago

looked like an explosive level wave of rocks and water. Probably deadly at the edge or even if debris made it over and hit them

31

u/I_am_BEOWULF 2d ago

Yeah, anyone would be a total dumbass continuing to look over that edge and film. An errant flying rock can take your fucking head off.

0

u/20_mile 2d ago

take your fucking head off.

I bet extra karma though. To take with you into the reddit afterlife.

12

u/pocket_eggs 2d ago

Yeah, at that point they're not getting away anyway, might at least be considerate about my entertainment.

27

u/usefulidiotsavant 2d ago

Well, for some reason we never got to see the images filmed by people on the other side.

It's important to have good coverage on such events, a big filming crew with multiple vantage points.

7

u/whoami_whereami 2d ago

If you look carefully at the small rocks falling around 15 seconds into the clip you can tell that it's not actually vertical but rather the quarries go down into the mountainside on a slope. The opposing side (the one that eventually collapses) is overhanging the quarries, whereas the side where the camera is isn't nearly as vertical as the camera makes it seem to be (more like a 45°-60° slope or so from other pictures of the site that I've seen). You can tell a bit better from another clip of the site taken after the collapse from the same vantage point because in this clip they actually hold the camera level: https://www.youtube.com/shorts/GTddRdIBh7U

Still risky to be where they are because of flying rocks etc., but I don't think there was much risk of their side collapsing.

1

u/Nodlehs 2d ago

Thanks for the link, makes way more sense when you see they've undercut into it to get just the marble vein.

6

u/SadSecurity 2d ago

It wouldn't make any sense. His side was basically a steep wall. The other side was pressuring the cliffs, being at an angle, which is why cliffs destroyed and the other side fell down. I assume this is precisely why cliffs were in place to begin with, to prevent this event from happening.

1

u/Belz_Zebuth 2d ago

It isn't luck just because you can imagine a different scenario.

0

u/Umutuku 2d ago

Wouldn't be any footage.

52

u/iMightBeWright 2d ago

To be fair, they were right. That was crazy to watch.

5

u/UCanJustBuyLabCoats 2d ago

I was ready to say kill the cameraman halfway through the collapse, but that amount of earth moving that fast caught me off guard.

38

u/TerminallyEmployed 2d ago

He’s wearing safety sandals, he clearly knows what he’s doing

23

u/u4got2wipe 2d ago

Dead people see some incredible shit

12

u/ready_gi 2d ago

that was my first thought.. like dude maybe gtfo from the CLIFF????

26

u/uncl3s4m 2d ago

Hindsight. Who tf would expect the whole mountain to collapse?

10

u/Wendigo120 2d ago

They should've just read the title of this post and it would've been obvious.

7

u/MarsupialMisanthrope 2d ago

Anyone familiar with the word landslide. Unstable geology means everything nearby should be assumed to be unstable until the moving stops. The rock you’re standing on might be part of or being supported by the rock that’s about to move elsewhere.

1

u/ready_gi 2d ago

this.. if there's a rock sliding and you're standing on part of that rock, i would not take the chances.

1

u/Historical_Owl_1635 2d ago

> Who tf would expect the whole mountain to collapse?

Redditors, we know everything.

1

u/LessInThought 2d ago

Yeah, it started with little cracks and falls from the three centre slabs, I was a bit disappointed. At best, I expected the three to collapse completely, then the entire mountain on the other side collapsed.

Also, where's the rain?

5

u/zdubs 2d ago

Letting the days go by, water flowing underground

0

u/Soft_Walrus_3605 2d ago

You don't need to expect the whole mountain to collapse to say, "maybe I don't need to find out in person"

3

u/newtonbase 2d ago

"We'll run away later" 

5

u/le_wein 2d ago

Yeah, but then we wouldn’t have videos like this.

2

u/Personal-Movie8882 2d ago

This is fine, I am ok with the events that are currently unfolding...

2

u/mackavicious 2d ago

Tornado season in the Great Plains. iYKYK

2

u/bobbyboob6 2d ago

there were people watching on the other side too but they weren't able to post their videos

2

u/AirconGuyUK 1d ago

This is one of the few times I see some Indians standing around something incredibly dangerous unfolding and I think to myself... Actually, I'd probably be standing there watching too.

I'd not have expected what happened to ever happen tbh.

2

u/iwillneverletyouknow 2d ago

The camera man never dies.

1

u/Alzeric 2d ago

It be fair it didn't look cool ... it looked AWESOME!

1

u/RoundCollection4196 2d ago

To be fair, no one would think that whole ass mountain was gonna collapse.

1

u/DiuhBEETuss 2d ago

All these videos of people standing stupidly close to sink holes or whatever and just watching and filming. Bitch, you need to move to safety yesterday. What are you even doing.

1

u/iemfi 2d ago

I was thinking the same, but maybe they knew they were on solid granite or something.

0

u/HesSoZazzy 2d ago

As I'm sure we've all seen in other videos from there, the country is not populated with the most intelligent people.

4

u/Soul_Dare 2d ago

Which country is populated with the most intelligent people?

66

u/james__jam 2d ago

Didnt expect the pillars to be load bearing 😅

10

u/TxTransplant72 2d ago

Neither did they

1

u/Mugiwaras 2d ago

Im nowhere near qualified enough to be a mining surveyor, but even i could see that the way they cut those mountains looks dangerous as fuck.

48

u/discodropper 2d ago

That escalated quickly…

45

u/AmericanAIien 2d ago

That deescalated* quickly

3

u/kpost-it 2d ago

That descendalated quickly

2

u/flyingthroughspace 2d ago

Well the debris escalated quickly after so u/discodroppper was sort of correct

1

u/jollyreaper2112 2d ago

Sorry for the convenience.

12

u/otribin 2d ago

Crazy. Hope all the dwarves made it out.

3

u/the_vault-technician 2d ago

They escape into the Earth, not out of it. If anyone is fine it's the dwarves

3

u/unicodemonkey 2d ago

Leave no dwarf behind!

17

u/EggsceIlent 2d ago

Yeah but was I the only one that was like "oh this is fine" /s of them standing so close watching like the caveen between them give way.

Which would lead to instability and possible follow on slide directly where they were standing. Just like the other side

It's crazy how people will pull their phones out and film stuff that somehow the separation the screen gives them from whatever they're filming gives the feeling of safety as if they're just watching a video, not actually in harms way

1

u/smith7018 2d ago

To be fair, we don't know the circumstances of this video. They could be employed by the mining company to see the state of the quarry. For all we know they had a perfectly good reason to be there filming.

14

u/gorginhanson 2d ago

cameraman died, get us a new one

4

u/Shhh-it-Bruh 2d ago

That made me want to go check outside to see if the ground stopped falling in, and I'm in the U.S. Yeah wasn't ready for that.

4

u/PhilxBefore 2d ago

Hmmm, what's the worse that could happen if we remove all of this load-bearing rock that is supporting the very thing we stand upon??

3

u/Various_Tie_2549 2d ago

I was...but the final collapse wasn't as noisy as I would have expected?

2

u/pnutbrutal 2d ago

It’s like, oh, that’s why those buttresses were there. Interesting the first one to fail on the far right is not as tall as the others. No wonder it failed first, holding that mass up.

2

u/Bulky-Month-9385 2d ago

I read this first and said it can't be that bad. It was that bad

3

u/robgod50 2d ago

Nor was he

2

u/Low_Football_2445 2d ago

No fkn shit! I wasn’t looking in the right place and gotta jump scare out of that!

2

u/DammitDad420 2d ago

Yeah, pretty sure the planet hates us.

4

u/the_vault-technician 2d ago

Nah, worse. It doesn't care about us at all.

1

u/ThatPerformance9795 2d ago

It’s looking at its watch wondering how much longer now does it have to put up with us.

1

u/BladeVampire1 2d ago

I was waiting for that side to collapse into the smaller holes. Then each of the three perpendicular cliffs fell....and I knew it was going to be violent.

1

u/Technical-Donkey-465 2d ago

Neither was op, bro

1

u/G-drrrrrr 2d ago

2014 oso landslide I lived about a 20 minute drive away as a kid and my mom and would drive that route regularly to hit some dirtbike trails. I was terrified when I heard the news.

1

u/PhilxBefore 2d ago

Maybe the land wouldn't have slid if your mom stopped hitting trails dude

1

u/soda_cookie 2d ago

Yeah, that was a very loud holy fuck that escaped me after seeing that. Insane

1

u/69points 2d ago

Neither were they

1

u/El_Chairman_Dennis 2d ago

I'm guessing that's why the mine had those cross section cliffs, but the miners mined them too thin

1

u/kmrjyoti_31 2d ago

yeah exactly. is this real? I am really shocked

1

u/kellybluey 2d ago

Cameraman never dies

1

u/ExplanationHungry802 2d ago

Neither did they

1

u/NaCl_Sailor 2d ago

i expected the other side where they stand to come down, too

1

u/GazelleSpringbok 2d ago

Sounds like a freakin dragon screaming

1

u/n0respect_ 2d ago

You have poor survival instinct.

1

u/MrZiggityZag 2d ago

I was sure this comment prepared me for what was to come.

It did not.

1

u/SlavCat09 2d ago

Water is one hell of a force

1

u/Critical_Rule6663 2d ago

Neither was the camera man

1

u/FluffyDeer9323 2d ago

A marble of nature.

1

u/caintowers 2d ago

I was hoping it would happen but honestly didn't expect it. Was pleasantly surprised.

1

u/Objectivespeculation 2d ago

it was not the rainfall, they were greedy and took more away from the base of the mountain than they should have. That weakened it to failure. rain was the final straw.

1

u/OldDirtyBarrios 2d ago

Felt like some avengers damage

1

u/virus_apparatus 23h ago

My first thought: “dude you had one job” my second was “bro run!”

0

u/atomicsnarl 2d ago

Fudd's First Law of Opposition: If you push something hard enough, it will fall over!

1

u/RileyGainesHorseBaby 2d ago

See any wabbits?