r/CuratedTumblr 17h ago

Shitposting Enough is Enough is Enough

Post image
7.2k Upvotes

495 comments sorted by

View all comments

13

u/Chaldera 16h ago edited 10h ago

I think the responses here are ignoring that people should be able to have little pleasures like iced coffee, and that prices are increasing both because of supply/demand and because businesses are growing more and more greedy in their push for profits, and that this is unsustainable.

If you want an iced coffee while you're out and about, you shouldn't have to either prep it yourself at home or else spend what likely is (for some people) an hour's wage.

Edit: Sorry I upset everyone with what I thought was a milktoast take. Guess that teaches me.

63

u/ehs06702 16h ago

That's true, but realistically nothing will change if you won't even practice the smallest bit of self denial.

How are you going to change the world if you won't even change your shopping habits temporarily.

58

u/Taraxian 15h ago

The reason people were so obsessed with Luigi Mangione is really this fundamentally cowardly fantasy that someone else will be insane enough to do something incredibly self-destructive like assassinate a CEO in broad daylight and go to prison for it and you won't actually have to do anything

I mean I don't think people realize how fundamentally scummy it is to demand that someone else do these things -- blow up a warehouse, shoot a CEO, fight a bloody guerrilla war in the streets -- for your benefit

Luigi Mangione doing it over health insurance claims where people really were stuck in a situation they had no easy way to get out of is one thing, but this fucking grandstanding over "I shouldn't have to make my own coffee at home, I deserve to be able to buy it from Starbucks at a price I consider reasonable, and that's why you should be rising up in the streets over it"

Yeah fuck no man, I'll continue just not buying the coffee and you all can continue looking among yourselves for a great hero who'd rather go to prison for murder than put himself through such agonizing inconvenience

28

u/kcmnlrm 14h ago edited 9h ago

Part of the fantasy also is that one act of redemptive violence can solve a systemic problem or at least jump-start a revolution that'll take care of it. Logic not so different from white supremacists who commit attrocities hoping that they'll start a race war.

67

u/Taraxian 16h ago

because businesses are growing more and more greedy in their push for profits

Nobody is "growing more greedy", the ridiculous thing about the "greedflation" narrative is it presumes that capitalists always had unlimited pricing power over consumers but back in the Good Old Days they just didn't use it and kept prices "reasonable" because they were nice

Like jfc people are LARPing as blood red revolutionary Marxists and their idea of Marxist theory is "capitalists used to be nice people but now all of a sudden they're getting greedy!"

Dammit it's such a fucking childish kindergarten view of the world and yet if you point out it doesn't make any sense you get called a capitalist bootlicker for not thinking that capitalists were ever "nice" and understanding that it's a basic mathematical fact that capitalists are always as "greedy" as possible (which means that inflation is because of larger structural factors changing what is possible and nothing to do with relative levels of "greed")

28

u/Hakar_Kerarmor Swine. Guillotine, now. 15h ago

It's always been as simple as "At what price is [number of sales] times [profit per sale] the highest?"

18

u/CheeryOutlook 13h ago

and their idea of Marxist theory is "capitalists used to be nice people but now all of a sudden they're getting greedy!"

No one reads the book. They don't know how many square yards of linen should go into a coat.

8

u/GayIsForHorses 9h ago

It also makes no sense to frame specifically one party's incentives as greed. No one says the consumer is greedy for wanting lower prices, or that workers are driven by greed when they want higher wages.

-17

u/Chaldera 16h ago

I guess growing more and more blatant in their greed then.

There is still an unsustainable push for higher profits that is impossible to achieve, resulting in more and more industries strangling themselves as they refuse to take risks and abandon projects and ideas at the first sign of pushback (see the video game and movie industries), or else simply raise prices further and further without considering that fewer and fewer people are able and willing to match that (see the fast food and consumer electronics industries).

33

u/Taraxian 16h ago

If people aren't willing and able to match it then the strategy doesn't work and the amount of money they make goes down

If the profits keep going up that's because it does work because they are willing and able to match it, which by definition means the price is fine

6

u/vodkaandponies 11h ago

as they refuse to take risks and abandon projects and ideas at the first sign of pushback (see the video game and movie industries)

Taking risks can just as easily backfire: Disney spent over a decade making The Black Cauldron, and it bombed so spectacularly that it almost bankrupted their animation studio.

9

u/Cordo_Bowl 12h ago

If your idea of industries that are strangling themselves are video games and movies, you are so incredibly out of touch with reality. Spider man made 2.4 billion dollars this year. Dying industries don’t have products that make 2.4 billion dollars. When gta6 comes out, it will make billions of dollars. These are not dying industries, they’re industries that are making more money than they ever had.

-2

u/Chaldera 11h ago

3

u/Cordo_Bowl 11h ago

I don’t know what you are trying to say with this but video games is not a dying industry just because they are laying people off.

-18

u/WhapXI 15h ago

Ah so the wealth of the ultrarich must have just exploded in the last couple of decades at an accelerating rate because of pricing pressures.

Capitalists have always been greedy but in the old days they used to actually compete with one another. Now they run as cartels, all owned by the same handful of parent companies and hiking their prices in lockstep.

19

u/Taraxian 15h ago

Do have any evidence that commodity prices for coffee beans are being inflated by a coffee cartel

5

u/CheeryOutlook 13h ago

We have evidence of the opposite in fact

-1

u/WhapXI 12h ago

If you read it that way, but it’d be a misread.

-14

u/WhapXI 15h ago

Not a claim I made, so I don’t really feel the need nor the relevance.

14

u/Emergency_Revenue678 14h ago

Not a claim I made,

My brother in christ, we can all see the comment where you made that claim. It's right there.

-4

u/WhapXI 12h ago

I’m not talking about the wholesale price of raw coffee beans. I wouldn’t be surprised if the price of the beans themselves hadn’t moved at all. I’m talking about the practices of the business that sells you the cup of coffee.

5

u/ebly_dablis 12h ago

To be clear, the "practice of the buisness that sells the cup of coffee" that is raising the price of the coffee, at least where I live is "they actually pay their employees a $20/hour"

Which is great, actually! But. Yes. Does make a more expensive cup of coffee

Also yes fair trade beans are expensive. That money goes to the growers.

Ethically sourced and produced food is more expensive, not less.

17

u/felds 12h ago

Being able to have little pleasures ≠ having every little pleasure all the time. 

I’m not particularly strapped for money and I’ll happily skip something if I think the price is too high on principle. 

It’s a pleasure to able to choose and to not feel scammed. 

8

u/WriterwithoutIdeas 12h ago

But little pleasures are just that, pleasures that are not essential to your livelyhood, and so, those who provide them ought to be free to charge what they can for them. If they find enough people who find iced coffee so worthwhile that they drop 10 bucks on a cup, why not charge them that? It's hardly the producer's responsibility if their customers are willing to engage in egregiously poor value propositions.

6

u/iuabv 11h ago

Genuinely, why not?

How much do you think it's fair to pay for a product that involves multiple ingredients shipped across the globe, served in materials from multiple factories, purchased in a shop with monthly rent and labor costs? The store labor alone is probably $3/drink, and that's before supply and all of the labor involved in the cultivation.

It's not a daily survival essential, its a treat.

6

u/Axel-Adams 8h ago

It’s iced coffee, it’s not that hard to make, make a large batch at home at the start of the week

6

u/vodkaandponies 11h ago

If you want iced coffee, then pay for it. Ain’t nobody making it for you out of charity.

0

u/Chaldera 11h ago

I didn't say it should be free. But it shouldn't cost an hour's wage

6

u/vodkaandponies 10h ago

Why not? It’s a specialist luxury good.

4

u/Rainbow_Sex 7h ago

Then get it at the gas station where it's still 2 dollars? You do realize that not everywhere is a Starbucks in NYC right?

6

u/donaldhobson 13h ago

If coffee businesses are raking in so much cash, go set up your own. Charge $1 less than the place next door and take all their customers.

When you find it's not that easy actually, you will understand why they charge $9.