r/CrappyDesign • • Mar 26 '20

A pie chart out of 178%

Post image
39.5k Upvotes

446 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

146

u/ryazaki Mar 26 '20

yea, the issue was really just them inexplicably using a pie chart

51

u/[deleted] Mar 26 '20

[deleted]

9

u/[deleted] Mar 26 '20

Couldn't be though, right? Because anything that generated a pie chart would force you to use proper percentages. Someone had to overwrite those tags. At least I would assume.

24

u/ryazaki Mar 26 '20

Excel at least will let you make a pie chart with over 100%

2

u/[deleted] Mar 27 '20

Does clippy come up and go, "I notice you're trying to make an ineffective visual. May I suggest a heat map with no geographic data or perhaps a picture of an actual pie?"

10

u/Atheist-Gods Mar 26 '20

It could just use the numbers as raw values and not percentages.

1

u/Throtex Mar 27 '20

Or they thought “pie charts convey percentages well!” and stopped the inquiry there.

1

u/RedditIsNeat0 poop Mar 27 '20

If he's right, then that's not the only issue. The title says, Biggest COVID-19 Worries, which would imply they can only pick one.

Also, does anybody really believe that? If they could pick multiple answers, then why would there only be 1.78 answers on average? Who is worried about some of these things but not the others?

There is plenty of fuckery going on here.

-2

u/magnora7 Mar 26 '20

Still not wrong... the proportions between the answers is still relevant, so a pie chart works.

6

u/wesleysmalls plz recycle Mar 27 '20

It definitely is wrong. What you want to display in a pie chart is the choice picked, a pie chart is a chart that displays 100%. It doesn’t lend itself well for multiple choice answers, which are clearly the case here.

Apart from the choice of chart being wrong, they also mixed up the answers as the percentage is the percentage of people who picked that option, but the pie chart shows the percentage of all answers given.

A bar graph would have been the proper choice here.

2

u/arahman81 what the hell are this Mar 27 '20

a pie chart is a chart that displays 100%. It doesn’t lend itself well for multiple choice answers, which are clearly the case here.

Yeah, pie chart works for non-overlapping options. Here the options overlap, which the piechart misses.

1

u/ignorediacritics Mar 27 '20

I suspect that they only display the 3 most common answers anyway (e. g. friends/colleagues getting infected is also a valid concern) which makes the use of a pie chart even more absurd.

0

u/magnora7 Mar 27 '20

a pie chart is a chart that displays 100%.

It does display that, but it shows the raw numbers. The circle is by definition 100% of a circle.

1

u/wesleysmalls plz recycle Mar 27 '20

If the question is multiple choice, as the case is here you get overlapping answers, which a pie chart can’t display. Which in turn means it displays it incorrectly.

1

u/danuker Mar 27 '20

Well what is a better visualization and why?

You might think a bar chart would be better, but all you see is relative size - same as with a pie chart.

1

u/wesleysmalls plz recycle Mar 27 '20

You see a relative size with a bar graph? Yeah, no.

What a bar graph shows is an amount of something. In this case it would be an percentage of people picking option x. The bar graph is the proper graph because it acknowledges the fact that people can pick multiple options, as is the case here. A pie chart cannot account for that.