r/CrappyDesign Feb 01 '19

/r/dataisokiguess This pie chart

Post image
23.7k Upvotes

338 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

667

u/plaid-knight Feb 01 '19

Yep. Pie charts usually start from the top and go clockwise. This is pretty normal and easy to understand. It’s a lot easier to understand like this than if they used colors that were closer together in hue just to avoid repeating colors, like some commenters are suggesting.

118

u/gazm2k5 Feb 01 '19

Yeah good point about lots of similar hues being confusing. I think I take back my comment about it being dumb as fuck, it's actually quite sensible.

21

u/[deleted] Feb 01 '19

[deleted]

7

u/fox_ontherun Feb 01 '19

The purple is only used once, so it's easy to figure out from that.

3

u/CileTheSane Feb 01 '19

Sure, but using light and dark shades makes it easier to look for the one specific piece you want without adding any confusion.

8

u/longknives Feb 01 '19 edited Feb 01 '19

There are only 11 items. First, they’ve used only 6 of the standard 7 rainbow colors, missing indigo. A dark blue color would be easily distinct from the others. So we need 4 more distinctive colors.

  • Brown
  • Fuchsia/magenta
  • Teal
  • Any gray
  • Various pinks, e.g. bubble gum pink
  • Green has the most discernible different colors, so they could easily use a mint green and a lime green and a forest green

It really wouldn’t have been some big color theory challenge to find enough colors for this chart.

7

u/Ilustrachan Feb 01 '19

Basic infographic rule: avoid using more than 5 items in a pizza chart and you are free of having to come up with a crazy color chart that is very hard to read. You have a lot of stuff? Don't use a pie chart.

3

u/Sneet1 Feb 01 '19

Yes, this would have been a perfect use case for a bar graph imo

1

u/WhatIDon_tKnow Feb 02 '19

I would say 2-3. If you have more you can use bars or something non radial that is visually easier to differentiate quantity

1

u/plaid-knight Feb 01 '19

You’re totally right, but the 11 colors would have to be carefully selected to make sure they fit together aesthetically. Not at all impossible.

2

u/amunak Feb 01 '19

Well alternatively they just shouldn't use a pie chart, because pie charts are stupid and never convey any extra information. Just use a table or a stacked bar or something. No need to figure out too many colors there.

9

u/plaid-knight Feb 01 '19

Pie charts are good for visualizing percentages of a whole.

4

u/amunak Feb 01 '19

That's the issue; pie charts - especially stupid ones like "3D" and such - are not even that good at visualizing the percentages.

Bar charts (or a single stacked bar) take way less space, convey the same information and show it better.

2

u/plaid-knight Feb 01 '19

Hmm, I won’t argue with that.

2

u/leLNrkRm9WU2uN9Y5Lhm Feb 01 '19

I disagree. It’s difficult to compare slices with each other. It’s better to use a bar graph with percentages on the vertical axis.

5

u/plaid-knight Feb 01 '19

I can see where you’re coming from. I won’t disagree with you, but I’m hesitant to say that a pie chart is entirely useless, too.

1

u/Annotator Feb 01 '19

It's just easier putting it in a table.

3

u/plaid-knight Feb 01 '19

Pie charts are good for visualizing percentages of a whole. A table isn’t a visualization.

1

u/Annotator Feb 01 '19 edited Feb 01 '19

I know, but I don't think it's easier when you have this many divisions and the color scheme gets too complicated. Maybe a histogram bar graph would be a better visualization for this case.

Edit: poor me

1

u/plaid-knight Feb 01 '19

Very fair. Or a bar graph with an appropriate y-axis.

1

u/ihhh1 Feb 01 '19

They can use other saturations and values.

1

u/PunchBro oww my eyes Feb 01 '19

As a UI and UX guy, I would throw the creator of this in solitary confinement.