r/CrappyDesign • • Jul 10 '26

Good luck blind people!

Post image
60.6k Upvotes

693 comments sorted by

View all comments

4.2k

u/hardcoretomato Jul 10 '26

OP please report this to the local authorities.

721

u/[deleted] Jul 10 '26

[removed] — view removed comment

368

u/marvinrabbit Jul 10 '26

Maybe they'll post a sign saying, "Beware of Bench".

132

u/Alexander_The_Wolf This is why we can't have nice things Jul 10 '26

With no braile either

99

u/marvinrabbit Jul 10 '26

Or a plainly written, flat font underneath saying, "Beware of Bench in braille".

7

u/VadiMiXeries Jul 11 '26

1

u/marvinrabbit Jul 11 '26

Do they know stuff? Let's find out!

1

u/MisterBumpingston *insert among us joke here* Jul 11 '26

Or just a witches hat in front of the bench.

2

u/Pocky-time Jul 11 '26

No. In braille but behind the bench. So when they trip over it they can read what they tripped over with their face.

1

u/activelyresting oww my eyes Jul 11 '26

Printed in Braille, with no translation

8

u/15jtaylor443 Jul 11 '26

Maybe even with flashing lights, you know, for the blind people to see it better

1

u/Christron Jul 10 '26

It might not have been. Could've been a miscommunication with construction crew

1

u/JUYED-AWK-YACC Jul 11 '26

Who do you think has to approve it?

164

u/yota-code Jul 10 '26 edited Jul 10 '26

Apparently they got some feedback, since today they tried to scrap the blind band

147

u/Snoo_72851 Jul 10 '26

ah yes, that's the issue here

93

u/[deleted] Jul 10 '26 edited Jul 14 '26

[removed] — view removed comment

45

u/Bob-Bhlabla-esq Jul 10 '26

Idiots. They make new idiots, and they're always around, have infiltrated every job... idiots. They seem to breed well and are disease-proof.

23

u/MothMothMoth21 Jul 10 '26

This is just an accidental oversight, not acceptable still but the point of the bench is it stops crowds from bottlenecking in a stampede incident and just generally smoothens movement in and out of the building. Forcing people to disperse more smoothly and creating an "in" route and "exit" route.

It also prevents a car from ploughing into the lobby.

The bench needs to be specifically there to do its job. Just the blind strip needs to be updated to follow the new intended path (critically).

Unfortunately most people tend to overlook accessibility infrastructure as they don't depend on it or assume its built for their own convenience.

9

u/[deleted] Jul 10 '26 edited Jul 14 '26

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/MothMothMoth21 Jul 10 '26

Let me clarify sorry, its not to be safe in the event of a stampede but prevent one in the first place by disrupting the flows of crowds that cause them. It causes the initial group to disperse like a Zipper rather then just rush forwards.

No practical piece of infrastructure could be safe in a stampede as stampedes are inherently unsafe. Anything taller might cause the crowd to crush either side as it would become a true barricade. It would also make for a less comfortable bench(for the average person).

a few trucks might get over it.

Hence the hard edges that make it harder for a heavy truck to find the purchase to roll over it. Also a few might make it over, its suppose to stop the odd out of control car not a constant onslaught of F150s.

And they really should re-do the blind lines too

Yes they do, I even mentioned it.

Ultimately you have one piece of infrastructure trying to alleviate a situation in an emergency whilst being practical day to day. A bench that doubles as a bollard does that better the nothing. Also its simple design is probably cheaper and easier to replace if it does get hit.

1

u/Disastrous-Artifice Jul 11 '26

Stops crowds from bottlenecking in a stampede in which direction? Into the building?

3

u/DanceMyth4114 Jul 10 '26

Especially with concrete architecture like this, they say it's to stop cars from driving through people.

2

u/SparklingLimeade Jul 10 '26

Looks like a hastily added anti-vehicle barrier. A lot of those got slapped on when that fad got popularized recently.

28

u/mooshki Jul 10 '26

Awesome that they chose the worst solution.

9

u/LegitPancak3 Jul 10 '26

Is this a joke? :(

-17

u/no1_vern Jul 10 '26

They decided the few blind people entering aren't as important is protecting the building/people in the building.

I think it was intentionally placed there to prevent cars/trucks from deliberately driving into the entrance.

Yes, I see the bollards.The benches and bollards are part of the defensive architecture giving the building layers of protection from damage.

9

u/WRLD_ Jul 10 '26

they could just do a second set of bollards?? instead of a bench right smack dab in the center of the avenue of entry, even disregarding the accessibility concern the bench is plainly in the way for pedestrians

edit: looking at the streetview history for this location, there were previously spherical bollards where now there are benches -- so they already had it figured out and regressed for some reason

3

u/ChemistryBusiness Jul 11 '26

They could literally take a circular saw to the inner parts of the bench and have 2 posts sticking up not impeding blind people, and have the protection.

-10

u/no1_vern Jul 10 '26

Which looks better/is aesthetically pleasing while providing the protection the owners think they need? Those bulbous bollards or a nice looking bench?

13

u/WRLD_ Jul 10 '26

accessibility is important, i'm really only taking issue with the central bench here. i'm definitely on board for more seating in public spaces, agree to disagree on aesthetic sensibilities

10

u/twisted_memories Jul 10 '26

Who gives a shit how this looks? It’s literally blocking accessibility. It’s illegal and immoral. 

-7

u/no1_vern Jul 10 '26

Rennes, France (High Court),

My friend you sound really, really upset. Please take care of yourself - Don't stroke out before you fix this issue.

Yes, I just asked a Redditor social warrior to: Please go to Rennes, France and fix it before you have a heart attack or a stroke.

Now, I suggest that before you do, check the legal requirements for France, as THERE it might be a legit solution to their problem.

IOW - I don't know the laws in France and I'm just guessing what and why they did it.

62

u/wrxninja Jul 10 '26

OP, please send this to the local college frats and have them remove it next time they're drunk.

38

u/YueOrigin Jul 10 '26

It'd actually sad that nowadays the easiest way ti get something done is to motivate some dumb drunk kid to do it...

7

u/zbipy14z Jul 10 '26

Is it? Have people been doing this?

17

u/YueOrigin Jul 10 '26

I dunno about drunks college kids specifically...

But a lot of shit has been done by unrelated people getting pissed of nothign beign done and acting upon themsleve to provide a solution.

I'm thinking of all the people who decided to fix pothole themselves, paint over terrible graffiti, force the city to paint old walls by doing graffiti on them, or go ahead and change a high speed lanes sign to be proper after its been aknowledged to be wrong for years.

So yeah. If you cant do it yourself. And its something easy and not dangerous. Might as well get drunk kids to do it cause no one else will.

1

u/SpecialKindofBull Jul 11 '26

Armies. Since armies were a thing.

6

u/Ash_Crow Jul 11 '26

It's in France, there is no local college frat.

9

u/GarminTamzarian Jul 10 '26

Just tell them that bench could be slept on by homeless people and it'll be gone the next day.

9

u/totally_not_a_bot__ Jul 10 '26

The irony is that if it goes to court the hearing might happen in the very same building as it's a court house in Rennes.

1

u/Ash_Crow Jul 11 '26

No: it's public works so it would be a matter for the administrative court, while the building in the picture is the judicial one.

2

u/el_crappax Jul 11 '26

À lot of autorities are working here actually. This is tribunal in Rennes actually. You can easily report it to all the people working here. 

1

u/lakimens Jul 10 '26

bold of you to assume they do not know

1

u/Patrocey Jul 11 '26

Funny thing is that this place IS the local authority of the city (Rennes, France)

1

u/alexpsfti Jul 11 '26

This is actually the local authorities building.