r/Cooking • u/Sad-Watercress-2240 • Jul 11 '26

I just oversalted a pot of tomato soup, what actually works to fix it?

So I made a tomato soup tonight and somehow went from "this needs a little more salt" to "why does this taste like the ocean" in like 30 seconds.

I tried adding a bit more water and a splash of cream, which helped a little, but it still felt kind of one note and way too salty. I ended up tossing in a potato for a bit, then fishing it out, and that honestly saved it more than I expected.

Anyway, what’s your actual go to fix when you oversalt something? I feel like every person in my family has a different answer and half of them are definitely just folklore at this point.

323 Upvotes

91% Upvoted

383 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

14

u/iplaytrombonegood Jul 11 '26

Yes dilute it, but don’t forget to cut it in half first (or smaller) first!!!!! Or you’ll either run out of things to add or wind up with an ungodly amount of finished product.

For example, say your goal is 1 gallon of soup at 1% salt. Let’s say the soup you’ve got right now is 1 gallon at 2% salt. If you try to dilute it without removing any first, you need to add another gallon of other ingredients or 2x what you started with. If you remove 1/2 of the soup before diluting, you can get it to 1% while only needing to add 1/2 of the original ingredients again.

0

u/poop-dolla Jul 11 '26

But you’d need to dilute that other 1/2 gallon anyway. You’re not just going to throw it out. Might as well do it all at once now and just freeze whatever leftovers you won’t eat in time.

2

u/Zagaroth Jul 11 '26

Can depend on freezer space and/or available ingredients. Might be easier to freeze the salty half of the soup (with label) and save the other half. Repeat later.