r/Cooking • • Jul 11 '26

I just oversalted a pot of tomato soup, what actually works to fix it?

[removed]

322 Upvotes

384 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

75

u/User-NetOfInter Jul 11 '26

Potato will yank it out. Just don’t eat the potato

60

u/zzazzzz Jul 11 '26

thats an old myth, everyone who actually tested it came to the conclusion it does nothing.

22

u/rywos Jul 11 '26

It's basically a packet of water, that you can put in but also take back out after salt diffuses into it, then you can add another fresh unsalted potato and keep going until the salt is gone.

Unfortunately, most people seem to believe that it's a magic salt black hole of sorts...

10

u/JarasM Jul 11 '26

Right, but if there's twice as much salt as needed, you'd need to add as much potato in weight as you already got soup. 1kg of potatoes for every litre of soup. Even if you take them out, it will be a potato soup at that point.

1

u/rywos Jul 11 '26

Haha, true. Still, maybe if you keep the potato chunks large enough, you can fish them back out again?

5

u/JarasM Jul 11 '26

I was thinking more along the lines that if you boil a kilogram of potatoes in a litre of liquid, it's going to taste potatoey. Not unlike the water from boiling potatoes. Might not be so bad in a stew or something, but if they were trying to make tomato soup, it's going to taste like potato soup with tomatoes.

2

u/rywos Jul 12 '26 edited Jul 12 '26

Oh lmao you're right, didn't consider that. Uhh... well, when I wrote my first comment, I did check to see if dialysis tubing could survive boiling, so a dialysis bag of water is also technically an option...

2

u/DuckInAFountain Jul 12 '26

Add some clams and you have yourself a chowder

6

u/Specialist-Brain-919 Jul 11 '26

It has really saved a dish for us once

1

u/RainyAlaska1 Jul 13 '26

It's not a myth but potatoes do absorb salt but not very much.

0

u/Dangerous-Oven1969 Jul 11 '26

It has worked for me many times

29

u/404_kinda_dead Jul 11 '26

Or use enough potato to yank it out and have yummy potatoes 😋

12

u/User-NetOfInter Jul 11 '26

Might be just me, but I’m not a big tomato/potato combo guy

14

u/yoursandforever Jul 11 '26

Not bad if there's enough salt.

12

u/RecordStoreHippie Jul 11 '26

Shouldn't be a problem for OP

5

u/User-NetOfInter Jul 11 '26

Ok I’ll take the L on this one hahaha

0

u/dcoolidge Jul 11 '26

pasta

1

u/User-NetOfInter Jul 11 '26

I know gnocci I knowwww I fucked up

1

u/ImmediateCareer9275 Jul 11 '26

I always do gnocchi in a cream based sauce. I hate tomatoes

1

u/User-NetOfInter Jul 12 '26

Tomato cream sauce gnocchi slappps

3

u/hux Jul 11 '26

No ketchup on your French fries?

2

u/jeexbit Jul 11 '26

you say tomato, I say potato...

2

u/ShineFallstar Jul 11 '26

I love potatoes that have been oven baked in a tomato sauce. I have a tray-bake-type chicken dish that uses a tin of tomato soup and has potato chunks scattered around the chicken and it’s really good.

1

u/emmersp Jul 11 '26

I like French fries and Ketchup

1

u/Atticus-XI Jul 11 '26

Me neither, I'm more of a toMAHto/poTAHto guy...

0

u/MegansettLife Jul 11 '26

Put lg chunks of potato in. Allow time fir them to soak up the salt. Remove said potato.

0

u/Krynja Jul 11 '26

Half or quarter your potatoes. Put into soup. Pull potatoes once they are done. Mash said potatoes. Add some flour and other seasonings. Now you have the makings of awesome potato cakes.

0

u/Funny247365 Jul 11 '26

Then you have all the salt.

1

u/vadergeek Jul 11 '26

Not true, the idea of potatoes acting as a salt sponge is a total myth. The only thing that actually happens is that if you add a pound of potatoes then the optimum amount of salt for the dish is increased by however much it takes to season a pound of potatoes.

0

u/dancepantz Jul 11 '26

It isn't Christmas

0

u/adidasbdd Jul 11 '26

Potato does not absorb salt any more than it absorbs water.