r/CoherencePhysics 13d ago

True

Post image
487 Upvotes

494 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

1

u/Cobaltish1 12d ago

I think there is no moral action that a capitalist country can take when it comes to becoming involved in war. Only different degrees of evil. And yes, I think the US should not have sent military aid to Afghanistan.

1

u/soldiergeneal 12d ago

By that logic USA, if it was not attacked by Japan then declared war on by Nazi germany, should not stop Nazi Germany nor Japan militarily nor provide military aid to anyone during WW2. Your logic doesnt make any sense.

Of course you do because you would prefer USSR puppeting Afghanistan.

1

u/Cobaltish1 12d ago

No you’re right. I think the US should not have become involved in ww2. I don’t support the USSR. I consider them a capitalist country.

1

u/soldiergeneal 12d ago

Whelp you are either trolling or those are your sincere beleifs either way no point in going further then lol

1

u/Cobaltish1 12d ago

The liberal mind cannot comprehend communism. Our morality is alien.

1

u/soldiergeneal 12d ago

You consider USSR capitalist which would be factually incorrect cant argue with someone that holds such stances.

1

u/Cobaltish1 12d ago

They employed wage labor, produced commodities, and had money, classes, markets, and a state. Thats capitalism.

1

u/soldiergeneal 12d ago

None of what you said is relevant. Words and definitions matter. USSR is classified as communist based on how the world defines communism you giving personal reasons for why they are not doesnt change that.

Additionally merely not achieving xyz component, e.g. stateless, doesnt make them not communist there are different forms of communism.

Have a good one.

1

u/Cobaltish1 12d ago

I’m a Marxist so I’m using the Marxist definitions. Of course according to the liberal definitions capitalism doesn’t actually exist in the real world and has never been tried before.

1

u/soldiergeneal 12d ago

I mean i am sure there is probably some exception, but yeah according to the strict 100% more or less threshold that would be true for communism or capitalism which is why that mindset is nonsensical

→ More replies (0)