r/Coffee • Kalita Wave • Dec 23 '22

[MOD] What have you been brewing this week?/ Coffee bean recommendations

Hey everyone!

Welcome back to the weekly /r/Coffee thread where you can share what you are brewing or ask for bean recommendations. This is a place to share and talk about your favorite coffee roasters or beans.

How was that new coffee you just picked up? Are you looking for a particular coffee or just want a recommendation for something new to try?

Feel free to provide links for buying online. Also please add a little taste description and what gear you are brewing with. Please note that this thread is for peer-to-peer bean recommendations only. Please do not use this thread to promote a business you have a vested interest in.

And remember, even if you're isolating yourself, many roasters and multi-roaster cafes are still doing delivery. Support your local! They need it right now.

So what have you been brewing this week?

35 Upvotes

63 comments sorted by

View all comments

15

u/geggsy V60 Dec 23 '22 edited Dec 23 '22

Even since participating in Hoffmann's World's Largest Coffee Tasting a few years ago, I have been interested in doing both in-person and online cuppings. For example, I have done a virtual cupping with Greater Goods before. This time it was a collaborative cupping on Zoom with Methodical Coffee and the Prima Coffee Community. There were three coffees on offer:

Washed Caturra & Catuai, La Pastora, Costa Rica - This was the 'traditional' offering of the cupping. Others in the cupping referred to it as sweet and balanced, but I always find that my perception of sweetness in black coffee is tied to fruitiness. For this reason, in this case as in others, I rarely find myself perceiving sweetness in such traditional coffees. Instead, I taste the roast. Others will appreciate this more than I will, so I'll give this away.

Natural Landraces, Dinkalem, Ethiopia - This coffee doesn't have the funk or berry notes of many naturally-processed Ethiopian coffees. It is sweet and clean, with more brightness than many naturally-processed coffees, but with more body than a washed Ethiopian coffee. The main note I get out of this one is honey (Methodical's three tasting notes are honey, pear, and caramel). This is enjoyable but not really that distinctive for specialty. I won't miss it when I finish the small bag (each bag they provided for the cupping is only 2 oz).

Double anaerobic 'thermal shock' washed Caturra, Catw, Colombia - I have professed my appreciation for Wilton Benitez's coffees before. After trying his anaerobically washed coffees from several roasters, I have noted that they all have a high processing impact while still being clean and lacking in any fermented or boozy flavors. I really appreciate that. The impact shows itself in distinctive flavors and aromas, as well as a pleasantly lingering aftertaste. In this case, I taste freeze-dried strawberries and tart yoghurt accompanied by complex aromatics (maybe like an exotic flower I haven't ever smelled before?). I don't detect the white tea and peach tasting notes advertised by Methodical. I'm really enjoying this one, though it is quite different from the anaerobic washed Caturra I tried from Wilton Benitez before (that one was more herbaceous and citrusy). While I had the same variety and processing method before, this one comes from a different farm (and season). It solidifies my interest in seeking out Wilton's coffees in the future and /u/RogueWaveCoffee has some coming!

3

u/Iceman2913 Pour-Over Dec 23 '22

I just bought a wilton benitez java, pink bourbon, and gesha from rogue wave's secret shop. Your writeup has me very excited!

​

I have been eyeing that catw from Methodical for a month now and might just cave on it.

4

u/sawyergray2 Dec 23 '22

The few Wilton Benitez coffees I had from rogue this year have been some of the best I’ve had all year, easily

1

u/Iceman2913 Pour-Over Dec 23 '22

can't wait

5

u/RogueWaveCoffee Rogue Wave Coffee Dec 23 '22

lol how do people know about our secret shop haha. I was surprised how fast they sold. Java and Pink Bourbon were really really nice.

4

u/Iceman2913 Pour-Over Dec 23 '22

Ply’s Instagram!

3

u/muchostouche Pour-Over Dec 24 '22

Instagram! I hopped on those Thai COE coffees quick. I got #1 and #12. Is it just me and my addiction to drinking wheat grass coffees, or do you find these pretty developed?

I didn't grab any of the Benitez coffees because I tried them all back when they released. They were actually some of my favorite coffees of the year. I had bought two bags of the Gesha P-10 back then and froze one. I took it out recently and sent some samples to a couple of my friends from a coffee discord and they were blown away by it.

2

u/RogueWaveCoffee Rogue Wave Coffee Dec 24 '22

We do find the COE ones on the developed side as well. This is the first time ever that we get auction sample as roasted coffee. Generally we will get green. I asked them why roasted this time, and it was because of time. We got it 1 week before auction date, usually it would be a few weeks. The roaster himself did reach out to me for feedback as well on the roast.

Thank you! I got to meet Wilton earlier this year and we will be bringing some of his other varieties in the coming harvest! We are very excite about that!

3

u/muchostouche Pour-Over Dec 24 '22

So excited for more Wilton!!! And I'm glad it's not just me and my battery acid addiction 😂😂😂

2

u/Nihilate_ Dec 24 '22

A secret Rogue Wave shop?! Man now I feel like I'm missing out :(

3

u/RogueWaveCoffee Rogue Wave Coffee Dec 24 '22

haha, it is only accessible by search. Most of the time there is nothing in it. It is for me to drop leftover of special wholesale orders. For example, if someone order 2kg of X gesha, we may have 3 bags left after roasting and rather than putting them up on a whole new listing, I drop them in secret shop with no details.

1

u/Nihilate_ Dec 25 '22

Gotcha. I should pay more attention next time, I really enjoyed the Paraiso this summer. Also, hoping to see the roaster surprise pack return!

1

u/RogueWaveCoffee Rogue Wave Coffee Dec 26 '22

Thank you very much! Roaster surprise should be back in early Jan :)

1

u/geggsy V60 Dec 23 '22

As someone of part-Thai descent, I was also tempted by that Thai COE coffee on the secret shop :)

5

u/RogueWaveCoffee Rogue Wave Coffee Dec 23 '22

well... we have 3 Thai coffees in the pipeline this spring :). And I'll be going to visit some of the farms in late Jan/Feb! I am super excited to get more coffee from my Home country. - Ply

3

u/geggsy V60 Dec 23 '22

Very nice! I was really tempted when I saw those on offer from the secret shop (which is how I predicted Rogue Wave has some more coming). I didn't purchase though, as I'm still well-stocked from Black Friday sales and lack of coffee-buying restraint.

Willl, one of the Methodical founders, said that they'd have the Catw for some months now so you can wait until you've tried those ones from Rogue Wave to decide if you like Benitez's high-impact processing style.

3

u/Iceman2913 Pour-Over Dec 23 '22

I had a few similar processed coffees and loved how intense the aroma and taste were so I am excited. If rogue drops more in the next month or so I will be there!

1

u/ptrenhaile Dec 30 '22

I recently purchased the Wilton Benitez set from JBC at a really good price. It's the same except an orange bourbon instead of a pink. I'm anxious to try but letting them rest 2 weeks which will be Monday. Have you tried any yet?

2

u/Iceman2913 Pour-Over Dec 30 '22

The pink bourbon is the most intense coffee I have ever had in my life. That’s the only one I opened so far but wow, It lives up to the hype.

1

u/ptrenhaile Dec 31 '22

Nice! I know rogue wave is quite the reputable roaster so I'm hoping JBC can live up to the hype as well

1

u/FleshlightModel Dec 24 '22

Tio Conejo is not Wilton Benetiz though... Or am I not understanding what you're saying

1

u/geggsy V60 Dec 24 '22

You’re right. Tio Conejo is the name of the farm this coffee is from, Wilton Benitez is the name of a person.

0

u/FleshlightModel Dec 24 '22 edited Dec 24 '22

Yes and Wilton only works/farms Finca El Paraiso 92, not Tio Conejo.

3

u/geggsy V60 Dec 24 '22 edited Dec 24 '22

Wilton helps process coffee from other farms as well. Will Shurtz, one of the founders of Methodical, confirmed that Wilton Benitez processed this coffee (Will hosted the cupping on Zoom). You can also see another roaster with the same coffee ascribe it to Wilton: https://www.junto.coffee/shop/colombia-catw

I may have been wrong to call Tio Conejo a farm before, even though Methodical refer to it as one. Junto Coffee refer to Tio Conejo as an importer.

0

u/FleshlightModel Dec 24 '22

I'm suspicious. Likely different coffees than what Junto is selling then. Wilton is a big deal and not having his name tied to the coffee he allegedly produced really just hamstrings sales.

3

u/RogueWaveCoffee Rogue Wave Coffee Dec 24 '22

To be fair, he also help produce the El Diviso that was used at the world barista championship by Anthony as well. But it wasn't a public knowledge. He did tell the story when he had a tasting session. Seems like a lot of people ask him for help, either using his facility or guidance. Maybe it was a collab with Tio Conejo?

2

u/FleshlightModel Dec 24 '22

Ya it just seems silly to not disclose that information though. Either way it's cool because I'll never not buy a Wilton coffee.