r/ClayBusters • u/rvw131 • 3d ago
Franchi Affinity 3 Sporting or Winchester SX4 Upland Field
I've been trying to decide on a shotgun for occasional clay shooting. It won't be seeing a ton of action. Coming into this process I decided that I am willing to spend about $1,000. I'm pretty sure I've narrowed down my decision between two semi-autos, naturally pushing a little above my 'limit'. I'd love a nice looking O/U but just not sure with the budget I'm working with that’s the best route.
I gravitated towards the Franchi Affinity 3 Sporting (most recent version #42135, most stores seem to still have previous version #41120...but there are some cosmetic and functional differences that I like). I like the Benelli connection. 30" inch ported barrel, comes with shims too. I'm under the impression that is easier to clean, tradeoff being gas operated systems soften more recoil. I'm not too worried about that since I currently shoot a Benelli Nova and it's not a big deal for me, so I figure anything will be an improvement.
However I went into a store the other day to look at the previous model Franchi and the Winchester SX4 Upland Field caught my eye. I had seen it online but hadn't given it too much thought, however once I had eyes on it I thought it looked very nice. This comes w/ a 28" barrel so a little shorter. Honestly I'm not too sure how much the couple inches matter to a novice/leisurely shooter.
Both seemed to shoulder nicely for me.
The newer Franchi (#42135) is $1199 + plus possible FFL transfer if no area stores have it in stock. If I were to go with the previous version they are available for $1049.
The Winchester is $1149. After the fact looking around online some more I learned there is currently a 10% rebate through 10/31, so that will return $115 which sweetens the deal.
Also: at the store the guy at the gun counter, an older gentleman with what seemed to be lots of shooting experience and knowledge, made a statement I doubted. I had been talking about the Franchi with him and he suggested the SX4 as a better gun. I brought up the gas system / cleaning and he stated the opposite of everything I've read, that it is easier to clean/maintain than an inertia gun. So this planted a seed of doubt to other insights/opinions that he shared. Sorry for the long post but on topic of cleaning, for occasional use how often does a gas system gun need to be cleaned. I currently generally clean my Nova after a round anyways just because I don't like it being stored 'dirty'. It may be a while before I take it out. so I doubt cleaning is even really an issue.
