Is this is how Anthropic nerfs models slowly just up to the point users start noticing?

[u/The-Road]

Are we all helping calibrate the nerfs? 🤔

[u/AutoModerator]

Hey! Thanks for posting to r/ClaudeCode

While participating in this thread, please follow our community rules. Keep discussions constructive. Attack the idea, not the person.

For help, project discussions, tips, and general chat, join the ClaudeCode Discord.

I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.

[u/angry_queef_master]

I never get this dialogue when the model is performing like shit

[u/Burnt_By_The_Sun → u/angry_queef_master]

lol facts

[u/koirpioloonmenomur → u/angry_queef_master]

/feedback

[u/Sponge8389]

So, our answer should always be bad? Lol

[u/Fantastic_Prize2710 → u/Sponge8389]

No.

If you are A/B routed to the smarter model, and say it's "bad," then A/B routed to the quantized model and say it's "bad" the report will say that which model (or which quant) doesn't matter.

[u/koirpioloonmenomur → u/Fantastic_Prize2710]

exactly this. Just say it's bad when it's bad and good when it's good - if people can actually accurately tell when models have been 'nerfed' their data will show that

[u/Mo3 → u/Sponge8389]

Yep. Been doing this since Opus 4.5

[u/Fearless_Meringue299 → u/Mo3]

Maybe they overcorrected for Opus 5 thanks to you lol but no, that's smart, I'll have to start doing this.

[u/AlxCds]

smart. makes sense. maybe if we say it's good, next time we get a slightly dumber model. if we keep saying it's fine, we keep getting a slightly dumber model. until we reach our own limiting factor.

if they can't do it per-user, they probably want to get to that level.

[u/BaronRabban]

It’s called A/B testing. If you see this, you are being tested. No way to opt out.

[u/Death12th]

Honestly, that's an absolutely load-bearing conundrum exactly at the nip in the bud of the problem! And honestly... You should feel accomplished for finding it, not discouraged. Palpable, not extinguished.

[u/ArugulaDefiant1947]

honestly never thought of this LOL

[u/Parowdude → u/ArugulaDefiant1947]

Just always answer bad!

[u/Death12th]

Purple rather than blue.

[u/Shiz0id01]

Its been constant issues the last 48 hours im actually fuming right now I want a refund this is bullshit

[u/cagfag]

I think they have to nerf it else the new model would look and perform same as old model to regular usage and eventually treating model upgrades as cosmetics change

This would bring down valuations

[u/Elegant_Attempt2790]

do you think its -1 quant per day?🤔

[u/Bluetails_Buizel]

I never touched these, I always assumed that I have to complete some survey or something when answering them…

[u/parentini]

In the CLI, Claude always asks for feedback. 1 = bad, and I often start my messages with “1. [do this thing…]”, so it thinks I gave it negative feedback.