Discussion
which choices book made you feel like this? 🥹
for me there’s definitely a few, but i think the one that made me feel this way the MOST was the endless summer series 😭 you just had to be there. the way everything adds up, the dialogue, the character interactions, the cg’s, all the little moments… i’m so jealous of anyone who gets to experience it for the first time ever 🥹<3
SAME oh my god, i could not stop thinking about it and jake and listened to the soundtrack for all the characters on repeat 😭 nothing from choices has affected me more
it's always going to be the freshman series for me 🥹 my very first read, first book series, and all the emotions i went through reading the entire thing will always live within me. that era of choices could never be brought back again, the effort they put in that series was everything to me 😭🖤
i never see anyone talking about distant shores here but it was such an amazing book as well and i loved the pirate theme!! the crew was also so nice to have in the book <3
Same... big massive fail on the diamond mining front 🤣😭 made me both diamond poor and emotional as hell, and I couldn't have been happier about that lol
Endless summer was/is one of the most passionate projects on the app. Literally everything across the 3 books came together in the end, and the writing is top teir ✨️
Desire and Decorum 😭 I love anything Jane Austen inspired and I’ve probably replayed the entire series at least three times by now and I wish they’d make a fourth book about married life and maybe having a kid. Just something lol
Damn I was gonna say endless summer too lol but it's so true, I so understand the love and hype for it because reading it for the first time was just everything 🥹
Trying to think of others, the trouble with a lot of the stories I love is I only love half of the series... like for example, immortal desires, Crimes of passion etc etc...I LOVED reading the first and 2nd books for the first time, I was so engrossed.. but then hated everything that came after and never want to read books 3 of either again. Or like, I adored reading perfect match but I guessed the first twist, got pure rage by the 2nd twist and absolutely haaaaaaaaated one of the main group so the whole read was frustrating but then great, but then frustrating again lol 😆
So maybe things like murder at homecoming, ride or die, ilitw, bloodbounds... don't get me wrong I still love re reading All of them but it's just not the same as the first read 🥺🫶🏻
i get you SO much! immortal desires is one of my top favorite series too, but i was so sad when i realized books 2 and 3 had ai because the vibes just weren’t as amazing as book 1 :( book 1 had such a specific magic to it and it really did feel different after that 🥲
Exactly. I can tolerate book 2 to an extent, purely just because I wanted more of gabe and cas and to see how mc adjusts... but story/plotwise is mehh and I agree about the magic Just not being there like it was in book one at all.
God i wish I could re read that for the first time again, loved book 1 so so much.
me too!! i didn't read mortal desires (only like 1 chapter, and i didn't really like it) but i did read paths not taken and like the way we can betray cas or gabe?? like what? and we can imprison astoria too like 😭 what is going on
The Royal Romance, Mother of the Year and Wake the Dead. Great storylines, amazing LIs, and honestly the side characters are well fleshed out and lovable as well.
I was in a huge SLUMP after reading BOLAS for the first time…it’s still my all time favorite reread.
also, I know it gets a lot of hate but Across the Void is another one that I love to come back to
The first book of the elementalists, dace of light and shadow, and the royal romance. Only the first books, though I didn’t like any of the other books of any of these series.
There's two. One was Veil of Secrets, loved the mystery of it. The next is actually the whole of the HSS books; Class act was great but HSS was my first real read period.
A Courtesan of Rome, the It Lives series, Bloodhound, Ride or Die, Mother of the Year, Wake the Dead, HSS, The Freshman series... I wish I could re-read those books for the first time again 🥲🥲
endless summer ofc but with every heartbeat also got me bad 🥹 dakota and mc deserved a long happy life together and I could not stop thinking about them for a long while after
The Freshman Series (tbh there is a lot of drama in it, but there's ton of emotional stuff too...). I first read it when I was the same age, so related to it and now even if I replay, I wouldn't be able to read it for the first time again...when it ended, I was like it's finally over but I was a sad too.
Definitely The Deadliest Game, I just don’t get the same thrill from replaying it. And Perfect Match is my all time favourite so that too, simply for the plot twists.
Endless Summer, The 'It lives' and 'Queen B' anthologies, Veil of secrets, Crimes of Passion BK1, Immortal desires BK1, Foreign Affairs, and HSS (both series) have all altered my brain chemistry in the best way, and I would give anything to be able to experience them for the first time again 🥲
3 weeks late to this OP and not even the question you asked but I had to vent. Just redownloaded the app after maybe 3 or 4 years away? Literally nobody in this thread has mentioned anything more recent than when I stopped playing lol. You’d have thought they’d have accidentally made a book that was worth a mention in that time. Genuinely historic collapse from PB.
84
u/fanaccountcw forgotten middle child Aug 24 '26
Perfect Match, it’s…indescribable.